Does soaking milk in bone broth put excessive strain on a baby's kidneys?
If a broth made from large bones, carrots, and potatoes is used to skim fat from milk, will it overload the kidneys of a one-year-old baby?
Tina, 0~9 year old female. Ask Date: 2001/11/27
Dr. Shi Zhongxian reply Pediatrics
It will not cause kidney strain, and eating it once every few days should be fine.
Reply Date: 2001/11/27
More Info
When considering the dietary practices for infants, particularly regarding the consumption of bone broth and milk, it is essential to understand the nutritional implications and the potential impact on a baby's developing kidneys. The question at hand is whether soaking milk in a broth made from bones, carrots, and potatoes could overload a one-year-old's kidneys.
Firstly, it is important to note that a one-year-old child has a developing renal system, which is still maturing and may not handle certain dietary components as efficiently as an adult's kidneys. Bone broth is often praised for its nutritional benefits, including minerals such as calcium, magnesium, and phosphorus, as well as collagen and amino acids. However, the concentration of these nutrients can vary significantly depending on how the broth is prepared.
In general, the kidneys of a healthy one-year-old can handle a variety of foods, including those rich in protein and minerals, as long as they are introduced in moderation. The concern regarding kidney overload typically arises from excessive protein intake or high levels of certain minerals, which can be taxing on the renal system. However, when bone broth is diluted or combined with other ingredients like carrots and potatoes, the overall nutrient density may be balanced, making it less likely to cause harm.
Soaking milk in bone broth may not inherently overload a child's kidneys, especially if this practice is done occasionally and not as a primary source of nutrition. It is crucial to ensure that the overall diet of the child remains balanced, incorporating a variety of foods to meet their nutritional needs without overwhelming their system. For instance, a diet rich in fruits, vegetables, whole grains, and appropriate protein sources is essential for healthy growth and development.
Moreover, it is advisable to monitor the child's reaction to new foods. If there are any signs of discomfort, such as changes in stool consistency, abdominal pain, or unusual irritability, it may be wise to consult a pediatrician. They can provide tailored advice based on the child's health history and dietary needs.
In conclusion, while soaking milk in a broth made from bones, carrots, and potatoes is unlikely to overload a one-year-old's kidneys when done in moderation, it is essential to maintain a balanced diet and observe the child's response to new foods. Consulting with a pediatric nutritionist or healthcare provider can provide additional guidance tailored to the child's specific needs and ensure their dietary practices support their overall health and development.
Similar Q&A
Is Goat Milk Powder Safe for Babies with Kidney Issues?
Dear Doctor: My friend's baby has congenital "polycystic kidney disease with renal hypoplasia" and is under regular monitoring, with the current situation being stable. They are considering introducing goat milk formula, but have heard that the mineral content in c...
Dr. Xiao Kaiwen reply Pediatrics
Goat milk contains more minerals than cow's milk, primarily phosphorus, calcium, chloride, sodium, and potassium. However, the levels of iron and folate in goat milk are lower. If a newborn exclusively consumes fresh goat milk, it may lead to severe anemia; therefore, fresh ...[Read More] Is Goat Milk Powder Safe for Babies with Kidney Issues?
Managing Hypercalciuria in Infants: Dietary and Health Considerations
Dear Dr. Huang, My daughter is currently one year and one month old, and her urine test has diagnosed her with hypercalciuria. I would like to ask the following questions: 1. Is this condition related to her water intake or diet? We use a "Lady's Calcium Ion Water Pur...
Dr. Huang Zheming reply Pediatrics
The hypercalciuria that your daughter is experiencing is likely unrelated to the water dispenser, milk, or other dietary factors. This is an issue related to the kidneys and glomeruli. It is advisable to consult a specialist in urology or nephrology at a major hospital for furthe...[Read More] Managing Hypercalciuria in Infants: Dietary and Health Considerations
Can Toddlers Drink Fresh Milk? Expert Advice on Dairy Alternatives
Hello Doctor: My child is almost two years old and currently does not drink formula milk, which is quite concerning for me. Can I start giving him fresh milk? A pharmacist told me that fresh milk has too much protein and that children under two should not drink it, as it could pu...
Dr. Zheng Hongyi reply Internal Medicine
Hello: Your question is answered by pediatrician Dr. Tan Yu-Tang. Drinking fresh milk will not cause kidney burden in a two-year-old child; however, fresh milk lacks added vitamins and minerals (especially iron), so children who consume fresh milk for a long time may experience n...[Read More] Can Toddlers Drink Fresh Milk? Expert Advice on Dairy Alternatives
Is Your Baby Drinking Too Much Water? Pediatric Insights on Hydration
Hello, doctor. My daughter is currently 7 months and 23 days old. She usually drinks water and even prefers it over milk compared to other children. When she's hungry, she drinks 120-150 ml of water at once, and she needs to drink 90-100 ml of water before bedtime to feel sl...
Dr. Xiao Kaiwen reply Pediatrics
Infants under six months of age have immature kidneys and should not be given water. For infants over seven months, while their kidneys have developed the ability to excrete excess fluids, they are still relatively immature and should not be given excessive amounts of water. Adeq...[Read More] Is Your Baby Drinking Too Much Water? Pediatric Insights on Hydration
Related FAQ
(Pediatrics)
Infant Urination(Pediatrics)
Breastfeeding(Pediatrics)
Shaken Baby Syndrome(Pediatrics)
Bedwetting(Pediatrics)
Baby Stool(Pediatrics)
Pediatric Vomiting(Pediatrics)
Accidental Ingestion(Pediatrics)
Jaundice(Pediatrics)
Infant Nutrition(Nutrition)