Is Goat Milk Powder Safe for Babies with Kidney Issues? - Pediatrics

Share to:

Does goat milk powder impose a burden on the kidneys?


Dear Doctor: My friend's baby has congenital "polycystic kidney disease with renal hypoplasia" and is under regular monitoring, with the current situation being stable.
They are considering introducing goat milk formula, but have heard that the mineral content in commercial goat milk formulas may place a burden on the kidneys.
Is this true? Should my baby avoid goat milk formula as well? What level of mineral content is considered excessive enough to cause kidney strain? I would like to inquire about your professional advice for patients with this condition.

Yí māmī, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2008/04/11

Dr. Xiao Kaiwen reply Pediatrics


Goat milk contains more minerals than cow's milk, primarily phosphorus, calcium, chloride, sodium, and potassium.
However, the levels of iron and folate in goat milk are lower.
If a newborn exclusively consumes fresh goat milk, it may lead to severe anemia; therefore, fresh goat milk is absolutely unsuitable as a primary source of nutrition for infants under one year of age (unless it is a formula goat milk powder approved for infant consumption by health authorities).
For infants with congenital "polycystic kidney disease with developmental dysplasia," goat milk may place an undue burden on their kidneys and is not recommended.
Professional advice for patients with this condition can be sought from pediatric nephrologists or neonatologists.

Reply Date: 2008/04/11

More Info


When it comes to infants and young children, especially those with kidney issues such as congenital polycystic kidney disease, careful consideration must be given to their diet, particularly the types of milk they consume. Goat milk powder has gained popularity as an alternative to cow's milk, but it is essential to understand its implications for children with kidney conditions.

Goat milk does contain higher levels of certain minerals compared to cow's milk, including calcium, phosphorus, and potassium. While these minerals are vital for growth and development, excessive amounts can place a strain on the kidneys, particularly in children with pre-existing kidney issues. In the case of congenital polycystic kidney disease, the kidneys may already be compromised, making them less capable of handling high mineral loads. Therefore, introducing goat milk powder into the diet of a child with this condition should be approached with caution.

The concern regarding mineral content is valid. High levels of calcium and phosphorus can lead to complications such as hypercalcemia (high calcium levels in the blood) and hyperphosphatemia (high phosphate levels), which can further exacerbate kidney problems. Additionally, goat milk lacks certain essential nutrients that are typically fortified in infant formula, such as iron and vitamin D. This deficiency can lead to nutritional imbalances, particularly if goat milk is used as a primary source of nutrition.

For infants under one year of age, it is generally advised to avoid using goat milk or any unfortified animal milk as a primary source of nutrition. Instead, specialized infant formulas that are designed to meet the nutritional needs of infants, especially those with specific health concerns, should be used. These formulas are carefully balanced to provide the necessary nutrients without overloading the kidneys.

If the child is older than one year and the parents are considering introducing goat milk powder, it is crucial to consult with a pediatric nephrologist or a healthcare provider specializing in pediatric nutrition. They can provide tailored advice based on the child's specific health status, kidney function, and nutritional needs. Monitoring kidney function through regular check-ups and urine tests will also help assess how well the child's kidneys are coping with dietary changes.

In summary, while goat milk powder can be a nutritious option for some children, it is not universally safe, especially for those with kidney issues. The potential for high mineral content to exacerbate kidney problems makes it essential to seek professional guidance before making any dietary changes. A healthcare provider can help determine the best dietary approach to ensure the child's health and well-being while managing their kidney condition effectively.

Similar Q&A

Concerns About Goat Milk Formula for Infants with Kidney Issues

I previously inquired with Dr. Hsiao about whether goat milk powder would impose a burden on the kidneys of infants with "polycystic kidney disease with renal hypoplasia." This time, I would like to ask for more detailed information. Are the mineral contents in commerci...


Dr. Xiao Kaiwen reply Pediatrics
Goat milk infant formula is an adjusted formula made from goat milk (where the protein and mineral content is reduced, and the previously lacking folic acid and iron are added in sufficient amounts). This means that the nutrients have been modified to resemble those in breast mil...

[Read More] Concerns About Goat Milk Formula for Infants with Kidney Issues


Can Goat Milk Powder Help Reduce Allergies in Infants?

Hello, doctor! I would like to ask, I heard that babies who drink goat milk powder may have a lower incidence of allergies and asthma. However, I found various opinions online regarding the pros and cons. My baby is one year and one month old; is it suitable to use goat milk as a...


Dr. Ma Yiqun reply Pediatrics
Hello, Mom: According to numerous clinical studies, a significant portion of children with cow's milk allergy also exhibit allergic reactions to goat's milk, with results showing rates as high as 90%. Therefore, it is not recommended to substitute goat's milk for c...

[Read More] Can Goat Milk Powder Help Reduce Allergies in Infants?


Benefits of Drinking Fresh Goat Milk During Pregnancy for Child Health

Hello, doctor. I would like to ask you a question—since I don't know which specialty to consult, what are the benefits of drinking fresh goat milk during pregnancy for the child after birth? Thank you for your response.


Dr. Pei Rensheng reply Pediatrics
Hello: 1. Fresh goat milk has deficiencies in folic acid and vitamin B, and a lack of these two nutrients can easily lead to growth retardation in infants, as well as neurological disorders and hematological diseases. Therefore, formula goat milk powder made from fresh goat mil...

[Read More] Benefits of Drinking Fresh Goat Milk During Pregnancy for Child Health


Mixing Cow and Goat Milk for Infant Nutrition: Is It Safe?

Hello Dr. Cheng: My son is now 4 and a half months old and is currently drinking Enfa A+. A friend mentioned that goat milk formula can be beneficial for the respiratory system. I am considering mixing cow's milk formula with goat milk formula for his feeding. Is this approp...


Dr. Zheng Peian reply Pediatrics
Hello, Ru'er's Mommy: Your baby weighed 2.5 kg at birth and 6.5 kg at four and a half months, which is considered normal. It is recommended to record height, weight, and growth development every two months and document it on the growth chart in the health booklet for re...

[Read More] Mixing Cow and Goat Milk for Infant Nutrition: Is It Safe?


Related FAQ

Kidney

(Pediatrics)

Infant Formula

(Pediatrics)

Complementary Foods

(Pediatrics)

Infant Urination

(Pediatrics)

Baby Stool

(Pediatrics)

Thalassemia

(Pediatrics)

Vaccine

(Pediatrics)

Purpura

(Pediatrics)

Fontanelle

(Pediatrics)

Kidney

(Nutrition)