Should You Wear Knee Braces During Rehab for ACL Injuries? - Rehabilitation

Share to:

Knee braces, muscles, and muscle strength?


Hello Dr.
Chen: I previously purchased two knee braces.
My condition is that I have undergone reconstruction of the posterior cruciate ligament and the lateral collateral ligament in my right knee, and the surgery is complete.
I am now preparing to start some muscle and strength training.
As for my left knee, there is a partial tear of the posterior cruciate ligament, and the doctor has advised me to focus on rehabilitation for now.
I have a question: if I wear a knee brace during rehabilitation, will it prevent me from building muscle and strength? Should I wear the brace while rehabilitating?

Xiao Jie, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2007/02/04

Dr. Chen Xianchang reply Rehabilitation


1.
Generally, protective gear should be removed during exercise unless in the acute phase.
During the acute phase, "isometric" exercises can be performed.
2.
For a more conservative approach, it is advisable to work with a therapist and use "isokinetic" exercise equipment for strength and range of motion training, which reduces the risk of injury.
3.
If pain or cramping occurs, exercise should be stopped.

Reply Date: 2007/02/04

More Info


When it comes to rehabilitation following an ACL (anterior cruciate ligament) injury, the use of knee braces can be a topic of considerable debate among healthcare professionals. In your case, where you have undergone surgery for reconstruction of the ACL and lateral ligaments, and are now preparing for muscle and strength training, it is important to consider both the benefits and potential drawbacks of wearing a knee brace during your rehabilitation process.


Benefits of Wearing a Knee Brace
1. Stability and Support: A knee brace can provide additional stability to the knee joint, especially in the early stages of rehabilitation. This can be particularly beneficial if you are experiencing pain or instability during movement. The brace can help to prevent excessive movement that might lead to further injury.

2. Pain Reduction: For some individuals, wearing a knee brace can help reduce pain during physical activity. This can encourage participation in rehabilitation exercises, which are crucial for recovery.

3. Psychological Comfort: Knowing that your knee is supported can provide psychological reassurance, allowing you to focus on your rehabilitation exercises without the fear of re-injury.


Drawbacks of Wearing a Knee Brace
1. Muscle Atrophy: One of the concerns with prolonged use of a knee brace is that it may lead to muscle atrophy or weakness. When the brace provides too much support, the muscles around the knee may not engage as much, which can hinder strength gains during rehabilitation.

2. Dependency: Relying on a brace can lead to a psychological dependency, where you may feel unable to perform movements without it. This can impede your confidence and progress in rehabilitation.

3. Limited Range of Motion: Some braces may restrict the range of motion, which is essential for regaining full function of the knee. It is important to ensure that any brace used allows for the necessary range of motion required for rehabilitation exercises.


Recommendations
1. Consult Your Therapist: It is crucial to discuss your specific situation with your physical therapist or orthopedic surgeon. They can provide personalized advice based on your recovery progress and the specifics of your injury.

2. Use During High-Risk Activities: If you are engaging in activities that may put your knee at risk of re-injury, wearing a brace during those times may be beneficial. However, during low-risk rehabilitation exercises, it may be advisable to remove the brace to allow for full muscle engagement.

3. Gradual Weaning: If you choose to wear a brace, consider gradually reducing its use as your strength and confidence improve. This can help your muscles adapt and regain strength without the reliance on external support.

4. Focus on Strengthening: Engage in exercises that target the muscles surrounding the knee, such as quadriceps and hamstring strengthening exercises. This will help stabilize the knee joint naturally and reduce the need for a brace over time.

5. Monitor Pain and Progress: Pay attention to your pain levels and overall progress during rehabilitation. If you notice increased pain or instability, consult your healthcare provider for further evaluation.

In conclusion, while wearing a knee brace during rehabilitation for ACL injuries can provide support and stability, it is essential to balance this with the need for muscle engagement and strength building. Collaborating closely with your healthcare team will ensure that you make informed decisions that align with your recovery goals.

Similar Q&A

Managing ACL Injury: Knee Brace Use and Rehabilitation Tips

About three years ago, I fell while roller skating with friends. An MRI later confirmed that my ligament was damaged (it wasn't torn; a doctor mentioned it might be about 10% injured). Previously, I would occasionally experience sudden jerks (which felt like slight misalignm...


Dr. Wang Zhaomin reply Rehabilitation
Knee braces can protect the knee joint from injuries during vigorous activities, heavy labor, or prolonged standing and walking. They are not necessary during low-level activities or rest at home. It is important to choose the appropriate size, and braces with supportive structur...

[Read More] Managing ACL Injury: Knee Brace Use and Rehabilitation Tips


Importance of Wearing Braces After ACL Surgery: Risks of Not Using Them

Hello Dr. Chen, I just had anterior cruciate ligament surgery. The doctor told me to wear a brace. I would like to ask what would happen if I don't wear it? Thank you!


Dr. Chen Xianchang reply Rehabilitation
Hello Sir: Thank you for your inquiry. I would like to address your question and provide the following recommendations: 1. After anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) surgery, it is usually necessary to wear a brace, as the function of the ACL is to prevent the tibia from sliding forw...

[Read More] Importance of Wearing Braces After ACL Surgery: Risks of Not Using Them


Post-ACL Surgery: Should You Consider Rehab and Support Options?

Hello, doctor! I just had anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) surgery, and I'm eager to start rehabilitation. Is it really better to go to a rehabilitation clinic? The surgeon who performed the operation said it's not necessary, but my friends all say I should. I'm un...


Dr. Shi Guozheng reply Orthopedics
It is still advisable to go to the hospital. After anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction, it is important to strengthen muscle training and also to increase the range of motion of the knee joint. Post-surgery, it is necessary to use crutches and a brace according to the...

[Read More] Post-ACL Surgery: Should You Consider Rehab and Support Options?


Recovering from ACL Rehab: Overcoming Setbacks and Pain Management

Hello, doctor. A few days ago, I asked about "slipping during ACL rehabilitation," and I appreciate your response. Initially, my original doctor mentioned that the MRI showed a white area near the upper side of the knee bone, suggesting possible muscle contusion or near...


Dr. Shi Guozheng reply Orthopedics
After anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) surgery, the typical rehabilitation period is about six to nine months. Although you have sustained another injury, the good news is that there is no further significant damage. Therefore, continuing with rehabilitation therapy to strengthen...

[Read More] Recovering from ACL Rehab: Overcoming Setbacks and Pain Management


Related FAQ

Acl

(Rehabilitation)

Knee

(Rehabilitation)

Knock Knees

(Rehabilitation)

Ankle Sprain

(Rehabilitation)

Artificial Ligament

(Rehabilitation)

Muscle Strain

(Rehabilitation)

Buttocks

(Rehabilitation)

Clavicle

(Rehabilitation)

Coccyx Pain

(Rehabilitation)

Anterior Cruciate Ligament

(Orthopedics)