Severe Left Thigh Pain: Should I Consider Surgery or Continue Rehab? - Neurosurgery

Share to:

Severe pain in the left thigh?


Dear Dr.
Ding,
I am 57 years old and have been experiencing severe pain in my left thigh for the past three weeks.
The pain has escalated from 20 minutes daily to the point where I can no longer get out of bed or walk.
Last Friday, I went to the emergency department at Shin Kong Hospital for pain relief, but it was ineffective.
An MRI was performed, and the doctor diagnosed me with degeneration of the cartilage tissue at the S1 and L5 levels, recommending surgery.
I have a 20-year history of diabetes and hypertension, and I underwent coronary artery bypass surgery three years ago.
I am concerned about the risks associated with surgery and whether surgery will guarantee recovery.

Additionally, a physical therapist visited my home yesterday and made some adjustments, teaching me a few exercises.
After the session, my pain has decreased significantly, and I can now get out of bed and walk a few steps.
Should I continue with rehabilitation and monitor my condition before considering surgery?
Thank you for your response; I appreciate your help.

Cai Xiaoyang, 50~59 year old female. Ask Date: 2007/06/25

Dr. Ding Xianwei reply Neurosurgery


Dear Mr.
Tsai: Please discuss in detail with your physician before making a decision, or seek a second opinion at the Neurosurgery outpatient clinic of Taoyuan General Hospital.
Sincerely, Dr.
Ding Hsien-Wei, Neurosurgery Department.

Reply Date: 2007/06/25

More Info


When considering the management of severe left thigh pain, especially in the context of your medical history, it is crucial to weigh the options of surgical intervention versus continued rehabilitation. Given your age, diabetes, hypertension, and history of coronary artery bypass surgery, these factors significantly influence both the risks associated with surgery and the potential benefits of conservative management.

Firstly, the MRI findings indicating degeneration of the S1 and L5 vertebrae suggest that your pain may be related to spinal issues, potentially involving nerve compression or irritation. This can lead to symptoms radiating down the leg, including the severe pain you are experiencing. In cases like yours, where conservative measures such as physical therapy have shown some improvement, it is often advisable to continue with rehabilitation before opting for surgery.

Physical therapy can be particularly beneficial in managing pain and improving function. It often includes exercises aimed at strengthening the muscles around the affected area, improving flexibility, and enhancing overall mobility. Since you mentioned that the physical therapist was able to provide some relief and you could walk a few steps after their intervention, this indicates that conservative treatment may still be effective for you.
Surgery, while it may provide relief for some patients, carries inherent risks, especially for individuals with pre-existing conditions like diabetes and hypertension. Surgical risks can include infection, delayed healing, and complications related to anesthesia. Additionally, there is no guarantee that surgery will completely resolve your pain; some patients may continue to experience discomfort even after surgical intervention.

Given your situation, it would be prudent to continue with physical therapy and closely monitor your symptoms. If you find that your pain persists or worsens despite rehabilitation efforts, or if you experience new symptoms such as weakness or numbness, it may then be appropriate to revisit the option of surgery.
In terms of your specific questions regarding surgery:
1. Risks of Surgery: The risks associated with surgery in patients with diabetes and a history of heart disease can be significant. It is essential to discuss these risks with your surgeon, who can provide a detailed assessment based on your overall health status.

2. Likelihood of Recovery: While many patients do experience significant relief from surgical interventions, outcomes can vary. Factors such as the extent of degeneration, the specific surgical procedure, and individual healing responses all play a role in recovery.

3. Continued Rehabilitation: Continuing with physical therapy is a reasonable approach, especially since you have experienced some improvement. It is essential to maintain open communication with your healthcare providers about your progress and any changes in your symptoms.

4. Monitoring Symptoms: Keep a close eye on your symptoms. If you notice a decline in your ability to perform daily activities or if pain becomes unmanageable, it may be time to reconsider surgical options.

In conclusion, while surgery may be a viable option for some, your current improvement with physical therapy suggests that continuing this approach could be beneficial. Regular follow-ups with your healthcare providers will help ensure that you make informed decisions about your treatment as your condition evolves. Always prioritize a multidisciplinary approach, involving your primary care physician, physical therapist, and any specialists, to ensure comprehensive care tailored to your needs.

Similar Q&A

Understanding Leg Pain: Insights into Neurological Issues and Rehabilitation

I apologize for the inconvenience, but I would like to ask some questions about my own condition. I am currently a student, and about two years ago (around July to August 2014), I began experiencing sharp pain on the outer side of my left thigh, approximately between the hip and ...


Dr. Lan Shengxing reply Neurology
The issue you described seems to be related to the nervous system. I recommend seeking a neurologist at a different medical facility for further evaluation.

[Read More] Understanding Leg Pain: Insights into Neurological Issues and Rehabilitation


Struggling with Recovery: When Will I Walk Normally Again?

Hello Doctor, After the Lunar New Year, in early February, I underwent surgery to remove a Baker's cyst (approximately 2 cm) from the back of my left knee. The doctor explained that due to the depth of the surgery, tendons and ligaments were cut and then sutured back toget...


Dr. Yin Xinbei reply Rehabilitation
Please proceed to the rehabilitation department for further evaluation and treatment.

[Read More] Struggling with Recovery: When Will I Walk Normally Again?


Understanding Iliopsoas Tendinopathy: Symptoms, Treatment, and Recovery Tips

Hello, over the past six months, I have occasionally experienced a sharp pain in the middle of my left thigh, as if the bone were twisted, while walking or going up and down stairs. The pain gradually extends to the outer upper side of my left knee and my left hip, but it disappe...


Dr. Chen Wayda reply Rehabilitation
You should consider switching to another hospital for a consultation.

[Read More] Understanding Iliopsoas Tendinopathy: Symptoms, Treatment, and Recovery Tips


Should You See a Rehab Specialist for Persistent Left Hip Pain?

Hello Doctor, I have been experiencing pain at the junction of my left hip and thigh for over three weeks. The pain is primarily located at the left ischial area when sitting, and it becomes quite noticeable after sitting for just three to five minutes, making it difficult to sit...


Dr. Li Yanheng reply Rehabilitation
It is recommended to visit the rehabilitation department for imaging-assisted examinations to determine the cause of the condition.

[Read More] Should You See a Rehab Specialist for Persistent Left Hip Pain?


Related FAQ

Thigh Nerve Pain

(Neurosurgery)

Leg

(Surgery)

Left Foot Numbness

(Neurosurgery)

Left Shoulder Bone Pain

(Neurology)

Leg

(Neurology)

Tibia

(Rehabilitation)

Thigh Soreness

(Orthopedics)

Coccyx Pain

(Rehabilitation)

Folliculitis

(Surgery)

Postoperative

(Neurosurgery)