the Myths of Big Hospitals: A Patient's Perspective - Family Medicine

Share to:

The Myths of Large Hospitals


Dear Dr.
Tsai,
First of all, thank you for taking the time to read this letter.
I believe that those who ask questions online are often confused and seeking answers either before or during their medical treatment.
I frequently see dedicated doctors advising patients to go to a "large hospital" for "detailed examinations." While this advice is well-intentioned, the reality is that hospitals, especially large ones, have such specialized divisions that very few doctors are willing to conduct examinations based solely on a patient's word.
Unless you are paying out of pocket or visiting a so-called VIP clinic, this is often the case.
For example, I have been suffering from chronic back pain for three years, to the point where I can hardly get out of bed.
I have visited outpatient clinics (including public hospitals and private hospitals) but have never received a clear diagnosis.
Instead, I have been prescribed a multitude of painkillers.
Unfortunately, I still have to sneak out of work every week, spending around 400 TWD on taxi fares and medication costs to obtain a week's supply of painkillers to support my need to work.
I still hold hope for the medical community in Taiwan and sincerely hope you can guide me on the right path.
I am 155 cm tall and weigh 42 kg (down from 47 kg over the past three years).
My back pain is severe, radiating to my neck, shoulders, and arms.
My appetite is deteriorating, and I experience low-grade fevers every 2-3 days (around 37.2 to 37.8 degrees Celsius), leaving me feeling weak and fatigued.
I have a history of alcoholic liver disease, pyelonephritis, and gastric ulcers.
I earnestly seek your advice on which specialty I should consult or what examinations I should consider paying for out of pocket.
If you still advise me to go to a hospital for detailed examinations, I must inform you that I have already been doing so for three years.

Thank you very much, and I wish you all the best.
Sincerely,
Doctor Q&A Teams

wu mu, 40~49 year old female. Ask Date: 2008/01/04

Dr. Cai Jueren reply Family Medicine


Hello: Based on your age and medical history, it is difficult to make an accurate assessment due to the lack of 1.
medication records 2.
occupation or job history 3.
past examination results 4.
family medical history.
It is suspected that a physician may consider 1.
rheumatoid arthritis 2.
systemic lupus erythematosus, or other autoimmune diseases.
There is also a less common condition: extrapulmonary tuberculosis (tuberculous infection in the spine).
I recommend consulting your family medicine physician.
Additionally, many cases of ankylosing spondylitis can be challenging to diagnose in the early stages.
If you have time, please send me your medication and examination reports, or provide a detailed account of your symptoms; this may allow me to offer more accurate suggestions and assessments.
Thank you for your correspondence.
Dr.
Tsai Jue-Ren, Hualien Hospital.

Reply Date: 2008/01/04

More Info


Dear Patient,
Thank you for reaching out and sharing your experiences and concerns regarding your health journey. It’s clear that you have been through a challenging time, and I appreciate your openness in discussing the frustrations you’ve encountered with the healthcare system, particularly in large hospitals.

Your situation highlights a common issue many patients face: the complexity and fragmentation of care in large medical institutions. While these hospitals often have advanced technology and specialists, the sheer size and specialization can sometimes lead to a feeling of being lost in the system. Patients may find it difficult to navigate through various departments, and as you mentioned, it can feel like no one is truly listening or addressing your specific concerns.

Given your symptoms of chronic back pain, weakness, loss of appetite, and recurrent low-grade fevers, it’s essential to take a comprehensive approach to your health. You have a history of several medical conditions, including alcoholic liver disease, pyelonephritis, and gastric ulcers, which complicates your overall health picture.
In your case, I would recommend the following steps:
1. Primary Care Physician (PCP): If you haven’t already, consider establishing care with a primary care physician. A PCP can serve as a central figure in your healthcare, coordinating referrals to specialists and ensuring that all aspects of your health are considered. They can help interpret your symptoms in the context of your medical history and guide you on the next steps.

2. Pain Management Specialist: Given your chronic back pain, a referral to a pain management specialist may be beneficial. These professionals can offer a variety of treatments, including physical therapy, medication management, and possibly interventional procedures to help alleviate your pain.

3. Rheumatologist: If your back pain is associated with systemic symptoms (like fever and weight loss), it may be worthwhile to consult a rheumatologist. They specialize in autoimmune and inflammatory conditions that could be contributing to your symptoms.

4. Gastroenterologist: Since you have a history of gastric ulcers and liver issues, a gastroenterologist can help manage these conditions and assess if they are contributing to your current symptoms, including your appetite and weight loss.

5. Diagnostic Imaging and Tests: If you feel that previous imaging or tests have not adequately addressed your concerns, you might consider discussing specific tests with your PCP or specialists. For example, an MRI of the spine could provide more insight into the cause of your back pain, while blood tests could help evaluate your liver function and rule out infections.

6. Mental Health Support: Chronic pain and ongoing health issues can take a toll on mental health. If you haven’t already, consider seeking support from a mental health professional. They can provide coping strategies and support as you navigate your health challenges.

7. Self-Advocacy: Continue to advocate for yourself. If you feel that your concerns are not being addressed, don’t hesitate to express this to your healthcare providers. It’s important that you feel heard and that your symptoms are taken seriously.

Lastly, I understand the financial burden of healthcare, especially when it comes to out-of-pocket expenses for tests and treatments. If you are considering self-pay options, discuss this with your healthcare providers to ensure that any tests or treatments are necessary and appropriate for your situation.

I hope this guidance helps you find a clearer path forward in managing your health. Remember, you are not alone in this journey, and there are resources and professionals available to support you.

Wishing you strength and healing,
Doctor Q&A Teams

Similar Q&A

Is Changing Hospitals a Good Option for My Sister's Delusional Disorder?

My sister has delusional disorder and is being treated at Chang Gung Memorial Hospital, but her condition is not improving. The doctor mentioned that she has been treated with high-dose medication. Our family is considering switching her to another hospital for treatment. Doctor,...


Dr. Chen Guangpeng reply Psychiatry
Dear family member of the patient, Thank you for your letter, which raises a common concern regarding treatment efficacy, prognosis, and strategies. First, mental illnesses are chronic conditions, and it is ideal to maintain a stable and continuous doctor-patient relationship; s...

[Read More] Is Changing Hospitals a Good Option for My Sister's Delusional Disorder?


Understanding Patient Voices: Trust and Perception in Psychiatry

As a patient, are my words not trusted or considered? If I only express sensations related to my body, will they immediately be attributed to a disease? What methods are available to diagnose this condition? A patient poses the question: Horses and dogs can hear high frequencies ...


Dr. Chen Wenke reply Psychiatry
Hello: Diseases themselves have specific definitions, and regardless of the criteria used for diagnosis, there are certain reference methods. In our assessments, besides utilizing existing diagnostic tests and examination tools, clinical interviews and physical examinations are a...

[Read More] Understanding Patient Voices: Trust and Perception in Psychiatry


Navigating Patient Emotions: A Neurology Perspective on Care and Compassion

Hello, thank you, but isn't it a bit too much? Won't there be any issues? Also, people always love to question your expertise; that must be frustrating for you! I'm sorry, I'm not very good with words, so I’ll just write it down. Watching an elderly lady anxio...


Dr. Ye Boshou reply Neurology
Hello: All correspondence will definitely be posted online! Pay close attention to your emotional changes, and it will improve. Thank you~

[Read More] Navigating Patient Emotions: A Neurology Perspective on Care and Compassion


Navigating Psychiatric Appointments: Tips for Effective Communication

When visiting a general psychiatric department in a regular hospital, is it common for the doors to be left open? Is there usually a nurse sitting nearby to assist with documenting prescriptions in the medical records and handling the initial health insurance card check? Is the o...


Dr. Chen Yuying reply Psychiatry
Hello Linlin, Each hospital has slightly different setups for psychiatric outpatient services. Some have independent consultation rooms with doors that can be closed and no consultation assistants, while in other hospitals, the consultation assistant shares the same desk with th...

[Read More] Navigating Psychiatric Appointments: Tips for Effective Communication


Related FAQ

Family Medicine

(Family Medicine)

Head

(Family Medicine)

Family Medicine

(Orthopedics)

Face

(Family Medicine)

Family Medicine

(Surgery)

Family Medicine

(Plastic Surgery)

Contagion

(Family Medicine)

Common Cold

(Family Medicine)

Hands

(Family Medicine)

Gout

(Family Medicine)