Sacroiliac Joint Dysfunction or Piriformis Syndrome: What's Your Diagnosis?

Sacroiliitis or Piriformis Syndrome?

Hello Doctor: I have a painful spot in my left lower back (it feels like there is a "knot" when I touch it), and the discomfort extends from my buttock down to my left toes (the little toe and the ring finger), which often feel sore and numb.
I also have a persistent sensation that my left leg is shorter.
I have been undergoing rehabilitation for almost a year now.
The feeling of having a leg length discrepancy has resolved, but recently I have been experiencing soreness and numbness from my left lower back to my left toes, which is very uncomfortable.
Previous examinations by doctors, including X-rays and MRI, showed no issues, and I was diagnosed with piriformis syndrome.
When I visited the rehabilitation center, the therapist mentioned that my pelvis is misaligned and my sacrum is tilted to the left.
I am currently receiving electrical therapy, heat treatment, and ultrasound, and I am also doing the exercises recommended by the therapist (like stretching).
Recently, I came across a report mentioning sacroiliac joint dysfunction, and I think the therapist might be correct.
However, during my follow-up appointment, the doctor still believes I have piriformis syndrome and prescribed a topical analgesic (would this be effective if it were a sacral issue?), while rehabilitation continues.
The therapist is focusing on the sacral issue in my rehabilitation.
I would like to ask, regardless of whether it is a sacral issue or piriformis syndrome, does rehabilitation really take this long? Sometimes my condition improves, and other times it worsens, and I am starting to lose track of whether I will recover.
I pay attention to what the therapist advises, so why is it still taking so long? Is my condition leaning more towards a sacroiliac joint issue or piriformis syndrome? (Because even with rehabilitation, the effects seem minimal.) Is it possible that it is not a sacral issue at all? (But both X-rays and MRI show no problems.) Currently, I can only rely on physical rehabilitation; are there no other treatment options? (I want to recover quickly.) I look forward to your reply.
Thank you.

Apei, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2010/03/21

Dr. Chen Shunsheng reply Rare Disease

The condition is likely Piriformis Syndrome.
What is Piriformis Syndrome? The piriformis muscle is a muscle that passes through the posterior hip joint.
It is smaller than other surrounding muscles in the buttocks and thighs and helps with the external rotation of the hip joint.
The piriformis muscle and its tendon are closely related to the sciatic nerve, which provides motor and sensory functions to the lower limbs.
The tendon of the piriformis muscle and the sciatic nerve cross each other deep in the posterior hip, with both structures having a diameter of about one centimeter.
Piriformis Syndrome is a relatively rare neuromuscular disorder caused by the compression or irritation of the sciatic nerve by the piriformis muscle, which is the largest nerve in our body.
The piriformis is a narrow muscle located in our buttocks.

What do patients with Piriformis Syndrome think? It is often believed that the tendon of the piriformis muscle may entrap the sciatic nerve, leading to nerve irritation.
Although this cannot be definitively proven, some physicians theorize that when the piriformis muscle and its tendon are too tight, they can almost cause a blockage of the sciatic nerve.
The pressure can also reduce blood flow to the nerve, further irritating it.

What else could cause similar pain? Sometimes referred to as deep buttock pain, other causes of this type of pain include spinal issues (such as herniated discs, spinal stenosis, etc.), sciatica, and tendonitis.
The diagnosis of Piriformis Syndrome involves ruling out these other diagnoses.
Pain caused by the compression of the sciatic nerve is often described as a tingling or numbness that radiates from the buttock along the nerve down the leg.
The pain may worsen after prolonged sitting, climbing stairs, walking, or running.
Diagnosis primarily relies on symptoms and physical examination.
There is no definitive method to confirm the diagnosis, but X-rays, MRI, and nerve conduction studies may be needed to rule out other conditions.

Typically, treatment for this disorder begins with stretching and massage.
Anti-inflammatory medications can be taken.
It is advised to stop running, cycling, or similar activities.
Injections of steroids near the piriformis muscle and sciatic nerve may provide temporary relief.
In certain cases, surgery may be recommended.
Unfortunately, treatment for Piriformis Syndrome is somewhat conventional, and the treatment recommendations are:
- Physical therapy – emphasizing stretching and strengthening the hip rotator muscles.
- Rest – avoiding activities that provoke symptoms for at least a few weeks.
- Anti-inflammatory medications – to reduce the inflammatory response around the tendon.
- Deep tissue massage – some physicians advocate for deep tissue massage.

When these treatments fail, patients may require surgery to release the piriformis muscle tendon.
This surgery is not minor and is generally considered a last resort if conservative treatment does not resolve the issue over a long period.

What is the prognosis? Most individuals with Piriformis Syndrome have a good prognosis.
Once the symptoms resolve, normal activities can typically be resumed.
In certain cases, an exercise program may need to be modified to reduce the likelihood of recurrence or worsening.

For more information, refer to my blog: tw.myblog.yahoo.com/neuron-neuron.

Reply Date: 2010/03/21

More Info

Sacroiliac Joint Dysfunction (SIJD) and Piriformis Syndrome are two conditions that can cause similar symptoms, particularly pain and discomfort in the lower back and legs. Given your description of symptoms, it is essential to differentiate between the two to determine the most effective treatment plan.

Understanding the Conditions
Sacroiliac Joint Dysfunction occurs when there is abnormal movement in the sacroiliac joint, which connects the lower spine to the pelvis. This dysfunction can lead to pain in the lower back, buttocks, and legs. Symptoms often include:
- Pain in the lower back or buttocks, which may radiate down the leg.

- Pain that worsens with prolonged sitting or standing.

- Discomfort when climbing stairs or getting in and out of a car.

Piriformis Syndrome, on the other hand, is a condition where the piriformis muscle, located in the buttock region, spasms and causes pain. This muscle can irritate the nearby sciatic nerve, leading to symptoms such as:
- Pain in the buttocks that may radiate down the leg.

- Numbness or tingling in the leg, particularly in the distribution of the sciatic nerve.

- Pain that may worsen with prolonged sitting or activities that involve hip movement.

Diagnosis and Treatment
From your description, it seems that you have been experiencing persistent pain and discomfort, with previous imaging studies (X-rays and MRI) showing no significant abnormalities. This can sometimes complicate the diagnosis, as both SIJD and Piriformis Syndrome may not always be visible on imaging studies.

1. Diagnosis:
- Given that your symptoms include a "knot" in the left lower back and radiating pain to the toes, it is crucial to consider both conditions. The fact that your physical therapist noted pelvic and sacral misalignment suggests that SIJD could be a contributing factor.

- A thorough physical examination, including specific tests for SIJD (like the FABER test or the Gaenslen's test) and assessments for Piriformis Syndrome, can help clarify the diagnosis.

2. Treatment:
- Physical Therapy: Continuing with physical therapy is essential. It can help strengthen the muscles around the pelvis and lower back, improve flexibility, and correct any postural issues. It may take time to see significant improvements, especially if the condition has been present for a long time.

- Pain Management: While topical analgesics may provide temporary relief, they are not a long-term solution. If pain persists, discussing other pain management options with your physician, such as oral medications or injections, may be beneficial.

- Activity Modification: Avoiding activities that exacerbate your symptoms and incorporating low-impact exercises can help manage pain levels.

- Alternative Therapies: Some patients find relief through chiropractic adjustments, acupuncture, or massage therapy. These can complement your physical therapy regimen.

Conclusion
It is understandable to feel frustrated with the prolonged duration of your symptoms. Recovery from conditions like SIJD and Piriformis Syndrome can be gradual, and it often requires a multifaceted approach. If you feel that your current treatment plan is not yielding results, consider seeking a second opinion from a specialist in musculoskeletal disorders or a pain management clinic. They may offer additional diagnostic tests or alternative treatment options that could lead to better outcomes.

In summary, both SIJD and Piriformis Syndrome can cause overlapping symptoms, and a comprehensive evaluation is necessary to determine the best course of action. Continue to communicate openly with your healthcare providers about your symptoms and treatment progress, and don't hesitate to advocate for further evaluation if needed.

Similar Q&A

Understanding Piriformis Syndrome: Diagnosis and Treatment Options

The following content is a physician's recommendation, but some examinations have already been conducted at China Medical University, and no issues were found. The parts in parentheses indicate the responses from the examinations that have been performed. The physician'...

Dr. Chen Shunsheng reply Rare Disease
Consultation with a relevant neurologist is necessary, and this consultation cannot replace an in-person examination. You will need to provide the original films to your physician for review.

Understanding Sciatica and Piriformis Syndrome: Symptoms and Treatment

Hello Doctor, during this time, I have been experiencing tightness and pain in my right leg, extending from the inner thigh down to the back of the calf. The discomfort is particularly noticeable when bending and straightening my leg. I have consulted several clinics; some sugges...

Dr. Zhang Junwei reply Neurosurgery
Without a physical examination, I cannot provide an answer. Please rest more, and for rehabilitation issues, please consult the rehabilitation department.

Understanding Sacroiliac Joint Dysfunction: Rehabilitation Options Explained

Hello, Dr. Chen! I have lower back pain that comes and goes. The most difficult part is that after sitting for a long time, I can hardly get up due to the pain. I also experience pain when turning over in bed and after walking for a while. A doctor mentioned it could be sacroilii...

Dr. Chen Xianchang reply Rehabilitation
1. It may also be due to lumbar intervertebral disc herniation accompanied by muscle stiffness. 2. A thorough examination should be conducted (X-rays and electromyography or further magnetic resonance imaging) to identify the underlying cause. 3. If the disc herniation is severe,...

Understanding Chronic Pain Below the Hip: Is It Piriformis Syndrome?

Hello, my mother has undergone two surgeries for spondylolisthesis and has been experiencing long-term pain below the hip joint postoperatively. She has consulted both orthopedic and neurosurgeons, but none have been able to identify the true cause. Multiple doctors believe that ...

Dr. Li Weiqiang reply Rehabilitation
Hi: Q1: Severe pain below the hip joint due to two surgeries for spinal spondylolisthesis has resulted in long-term pain below the hip joint. I have consulted both orthopedic and neurosurgeons, but none have been able to identify the true cause. Multiple doctors believe that the ...