The relationship between osteoarthritis and exercise (pain and exercise relationship)?
Dear Director Shih,
I am reaching out based on the medical information available online regarding your professional background and expertise.
I humbly seek your advice and assistance in alleviating the pain caused by my condition, including whether my current exercise routine may lead to worsening lower back pain and knee discomfort.
Approximately 5 to 6 years ago, I suddenly experienced knee pain.
After an X-ray, the doctor diagnosed me with osteoarthritis, which I was skeptical about.
A subsequent visit to a physician at National Taiwan University Hospital resulted in a diagnosis of tendinitis.
Both doctors prescribed painkillers, which provided no relief or improvement.
I later heard about "Glucosamine" and took it for a while, but it had no noticeable effect.
During multiple visits to the clinic, the doctors only prescribed pain medication and advised me to exercise to prevent further deterioration.
I have always enjoyed exercising, but due to my knee pain, I have refrained from long-distance running or hiking.
Instead, I chose to play table tennis, which I do about five days a week for approximately one hour each session.
While I sweat profusely during play, I sometimes experience lower back pain and occasional mild knee discomfort.
My movements and reactions are quick, and my opponents are equally matched, making the games exciting and exhausting.
We also take breaks as needed, yet I find immense joy in the sport.
Despite this enjoyment, I remain concerned: will this level of activity exacerbate my knee pain and lower back issues? I always wear knee braces while playing.
During my visits to the hospital, it has been challenging to receive satisfactory answers and explanations from the doctors.
To avoid "asking in vain," I specifically seek your insights, Director Shih.
Is it advisable for me to continue this level of exercise? Additionally, how can I relieve my discomfort? Is it effective to continue taking "Glucosamine"?
I look forward to your valuable insights and explanations at your convenience, understanding that you may be quite busy.
Thank you very much!
Sincerely,
LION
November 23, 2010
Lao Shi Weng, 60~69 year old female. Ask Date: 2010/11/23
Dr. Shi Guozheng reply Orthopedics
Degenerative arthritis can occur in individuals over the age of fifty.
If you have already had an X-ray that shows significant degenerative changes, then engaging in high-impact exercise may not be advisable.
However, since you mentioned that the physician at National Taiwan University believes you have tendonitis, this diagnosis is more credible.
You can continue to exercise, but avoid overexertion.
If you experience soreness or pain, you should reduce the intensity of your activities.
It is important to have adequate rest after exercising, along with applying heat therapy.
Reply Date: 2010/11/23
More Info
Managing osteoarthritis pain, particularly in the context of exercise, is a nuanced topic that requires a careful balance between maintaining physical activity and preventing exacerbation of symptoms. Osteoarthritis (OA) is a degenerative joint disease that often leads to pain, stiffness, and reduced mobility, particularly in weight-bearing joints like the knees. Your experience with knee pain and the conflicting diagnoses of osteoarthritis and tendonitis highlight the complexity of joint issues, and it's understandable that you seek clarity on how to manage your condition effectively.
Firstly, it's essential to recognize that while exercise is generally beneficial for individuals with osteoarthritis, the type, intensity, and frequency of exercise must be tailored to the individual's specific condition and pain levels. Engaging in low-impact activities is often recommended, as they can help maintain joint function and reduce stiffness without placing excessive strain on the joints. Activities such as swimming, cycling, and even table tennis, which you mentioned enjoying, can be excellent choices. However, it's crucial to listen to your body. If you experience pain during or after these activities, it may be a sign that you need to modify your approach.
In your case, playing table tennis five times a week for an hour is a significant commitment. While this sport is less impactful than running or jumping, the quick lateral movements and the intensity of play can still provoke discomfort, especially if your knee is already compromised. The use of knee braces is a good preventive measure, but they should not be a substitute for proper technique and body mechanics. Ensuring that you maintain good posture and avoid overexertion during play is vital to prevent further injury.
Regarding your concerns about worsening knee and back pain, it's essential to incorporate rest and recovery into your routine. Adequate rest allows the body to heal and adapt, while heat therapy post-exercise can help alleviate muscle tension and improve circulation to the affected areas. Additionally, consider integrating stretching and strengthening exercises into your routine, focusing on the muscles surrounding the knee and core to provide better support and stability.
As for the supplement "維骨力" (Glucosamine), its efficacy can vary among individuals. Some studies suggest that glucosamine may help reduce joint pain and improve function in some people with osteoarthritis, while others show minimal benefit. It's worth discussing with your healthcare provider whether continuing this supplement is appropriate for you, especially if you have not noticed any improvements.
In summary, managing osteoarthritis pain while remaining active involves a multifaceted approach. Here are some key recommendations:
1. Modify Exercise: Continue with low-impact activities like table tennis, but be mindful of your body's signals. If pain increases, consider reducing the frequency or duration of play.
2. Incorporate Rest and Recovery: Allow adequate time for recovery between exercise sessions, and consider using heat therapy post-activity.
3. Strengthening and Stretching: Engage in exercises that strengthen the muscles around your knees and improve flexibility. This can help stabilize the joint and reduce pain.
4. Consult Healthcare Providers: Regularly discuss your symptoms and exercise regimen with your healthcare provider or a physical therapist. They can provide tailored advice and adjustments based on your progress.
5. Evaluate Supplements: Discuss the continued use of glucosamine or other supplements with your doctor to determine their relevance to your treatment plan.
By taking a proactive and informed approach, you can manage your osteoarthritis symptoms effectively while still enjoying the physical activities you love.
Similar Q&A
Managing Osteoarthritis: Exercise Tips and Knee Care Strategies
Hello, I have osteoarthritis and have always been afraid to engage in any vigorous exercise, only taking medication when I experience pain. Recently, my knee seems to have worsened. After standing for half an hour, I feel some pain in my knee when going down the stairs. I'm ...
Dr. Wang Fangli reply Internal Medicine
Osteoarthritis commonly occurs in adults aged 40 to 50 and older, with some younger patients developing it due to joint injuries. Treatment includes weight loss, physical therapy, and medication. Weight loss can reduce the burden on the knee joints. Daily activities should avoid ...[Read More] Managing Osteoarthritis: Exercise Tips and Knee Care Strategies
Can Rehabilitation Help Manage Osteoarthritis Without Steroids?
Can rehabilitation help solve osteoarthritis without the use of steroids? Thank you!
Dr. Su Hongci reply Rehabilitation
Osteoarthritis, commonly known as degenerative joint disease, primarily aims to alleviate pain, enhance mobility, and prevent disability. Treatment options include: 1. Medications, such as oral non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs) to relieve pain. 2. Intra-articular inj...[Read More] Can Rehabilitation Help Manage Osteoarthritis Without Steroids?
Managing Inflammation of the Knee Cartilage: Care Tips and Follow-Up
If you have inflammation of the knee cartilage (chondromalacia), it is important to pay special attention to the following aspects for care and management: 1. Rest and Activity Modification: Avoid activities that put excessive stress on the knee, such as running or jumping. ...
Dr. Shi Qiming reply Orthopedics
Patellar chondromalacia is typically caused by overuse, such as excessive physical activity or work, leading to softening of the cartilage in the patella, resulting in symptoms like pain and difficulty with stair climbing. It is advisable to consult a sports medicine specialist i...[Read More] Managing Inflammation of the Knee Cartilage: Care Tips and Follow-Up
Effective Exercise Strategies for Weight Loss with Arthritis
Non-smoker; exercises more than three times a week but experiences chest pain during exercise, has skeletal or joint issues that may worsen with activity, and has other discomforts related to activity. Height: 162 cm, Weight: 68 kg, BMI: 25.91 (obesity is very dangerous). Flexibi...
Dr. Xu Zhenrong reply Physical Fitness
The letter is from a 48-year-old woman who is likely approaching menopause. She is at increased risk for osteoporosis and arthritis, and her weight is slightly above the normal range, with a body mass index (BMI) of 25.9, which further increases the load on her lower body, includ...[Read More] Effective Exercise Strategies for Weight Loss with Arthritis
Related FAQ
(Orthopedics)
Degenerative Arthritis(Orthopedics)
Knee(Orthopedics)
Sports Injury(Orthopedics)
Foot Pain(Orthopedics)
Osteoporosis(Orthopedics)
Cartilage(Orthopedics)
Osteomyelitis(Orthopedics)
Ankylosing Spondylitis(Orthopedics)
Rehabilitation(Orthopedics)