Is It Safe to Consider Cancer Recovery After Three Years of Monitoring? - Oncology

Share to:

After three years of monitoring and having the artificial blood vessel removed, can it be considered healed?


Hello: A family member has been diagnosed with stage II peritoneal cancer, has undergone tumor resection, and completed chemotherapy.
It has been three years of follow-up, and all values are within normal ranges (they will continue to visit the outpatient clinic every three months to monitor the values and will not stop).
In September of this year, the artificial blood vessel was removed, and there are no physical discomforts.
Given the ongoing monitoring and stable values, can this be considered a cure? Is there a possibility of sudden recurrence even with normal values? Thank you for your response.

Nìmíng, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2011/09/14

Dr. Chen Sirong reply Oncology


Anonymous / 29 / 1 Hello,
1.
Regarding artificial blood vessels, generally, if there is no recurrence within 2-3 years, they can be removed, regardless of whether it is breast cancer or colorectal cancer.
This aligns with standard treatment protocols; however, the possibility of recurrence still exists, so patients should be monitored indefinitely.
2.
In the case of peritoneal cancer, I refer to other literature indicating that women with primary peritoneal cancer have an average survival of 12-25 months, but some have survived for 92 months or even 7 years.
Generally, this type of cancer has a poor prognosis.
Congratulations to your family for their good fortune.
Whether there will be a recurrence in the future remains uncertain, as there is still a chance of recurrence.
Therefore, whether she can be considered "cured" is a matter of personal belief.
However, the patient should adopt a mindset of having overcome the illness and live each day in the present.
At this moment, she is considered to be in remission.
The future is inherently unpredictable, much like a hurricane or earthquake that can claim many lives.
Cancer survivors should cherish their lives even more and should embrace a mindset of healing.

Signed,
Chen Si-Rong, Taoyuan General Hospital

Reply Date: 2011/09/14

More Info


When considering whether it is safe to regard a patient as "cured" of cancer after three years of monitoring, several factors must be taken into account. In the case of your family member who has undergone treatment for stage II peritoneal cancer, it is important to understand the nuances of cancer recovery and the potential for recurrence.

Firstly, the term "cured" is often used cautiously in oncology. While a patient may be in remission and exhibit no signs of disease for an extended period, such as three years, the possibility of recurrence can never be entirely ruled out. This is particularly true for certain types of cancer, including peritoneal cancer, which can have variable prognoses. The average survival rates for peritoneal cancer can differ significantly based on various factors, including the initial stage of cancer, the completeness of surgical resection, and the effectiveness of subsequent treatments like chemotherapy.

In your family member's case, the fact that they have completed chemotherapy, had the tumor surgically removed, and have been monitored for three years with normal test results is certainly encouraging. The removal of the artificial blood vessel and the absence of any physical discomfort are also positive indicators. However, it is essential to continue regular follow-ups, as the risk of recurrence can persist for many years, even if the patient is currently asymptomatic and has normal lab results.

The monitoring protocol you mentioned, which includes regular check-ups every three months, is a standard practice in oncology. This frequency allows for early detection of any potential recurrence. It is also worth noting that some cancers may have a higher likelihood of recurrence within the first few years post-treatment, while others may have a longer latency period. Therefore, continuous vigilance is necessary.

Regarding the concern about sudden recurrence despite normal values, it is important to understand that cancer can sometimes recur without any prior warning signs. This is why ongoing monitoring is crucial. Regular imaging studies, blood tests, and clinical evaluations are essential components of post-treatment care. These assessments help in identifying any changes that may indicate a return of the disease.

In summary, while three years of monitoring with normal results is a positive sign and may lead to a hopeful outlook, it is prudent to remain cautious. The concept of being "cured" should be approached with care, and ongoing follow-up is essential to ensure any potential recurrence is detected early. Encourage your family member to maintain their follow-up appointments and communicate openly with their healthcare team about any concerns or symptoms that may arise. This proactive approach is vital in managing their health and ensuring the best possible outcomes.

Similar Q&A

Should I Consider Preventive Mastectomy After Previous Breast Cancer?

Hello Dr. Lai, I am 45 years old. In 2012, I was diagnosed with stage 2A breast cancer in my left breast and underwent a total mastectomy. I have been taking Tamoxifen for three years. Recently, during my regular follow-ups every three months, ultrasounds and mammograms have show...


Dr. Lai Yicheng reply Oncology
Dear Ms. Hu, In response to your inquiry, I find it challenging to answer your question. Similar to American actress Angelina Jolie, who underwent prophylactic mastectomy, there are differing opinions within the medical community, and perspectives vary. I recommend discussing th...

[Read More] Should I Consider Preventive Mastectomy After Previous Breast Cancer?


Post-Tumor Removal: Risks of Not Following Up on Malignancy

I had a malignant teratoma at the coccyx when I was 3 years old, but it seems that I haven't had regular follow-ups or check-ups since then. Now that I'm about to graduate from high school, my health has been poor since elementary school and has been getting worse. Is i...


Dr. Chen Sirong reply Oncology
Of course, regarding the completeness of medical records, you can request copies of X-ray films, surgical records, and pathology reports from the hospital where you originally received treatment. It is important to keep these documents, as most medical records older than 10 years...

[Read More] Post-Tumor Removal: Risks of Not Following Up on Malignancy


Understanding Cervical Cancer Treatment Options for Stage 3B Patients

The patient is a 72-year-old mother who has been diagnosed with stage 3B cervical cancer. The gynecologist believes that surgery is not advisable. After undergoing 28 sessions of radiation therapy and 3 sessions of chemotherapy, the tumor has slightly shrunk but still remains. Th...


Dr. Lai Yicheng reply Oncology
Dear Mr. HDJDJKFKD, Thank you for your letter. Here are my responses: 1. After 28 sessions of radiation therapy and 3 sessions of chemotherapy, a PET scan is required. It is important to rest for 6 to 8 weeks to avoid false positives. 2. The effectiveness of the treatment will ...

[Read More] Understanding Cervical Cancer Treatment Options for Stage 3B Patients


Understanding Post-Surgery Follow-Up for Cancer Patients: Concerns and Insights

Hello, I have some questions regarding my experience with my elderly family member. Two years ago, they were diagnosed with stage 3B cancer and underwent surgery and chemotherapy. They have been returning for follow-up appointments every three months, and we are approaching the t...


Dr. Hu Ziren reply Oncology
What type of cancer does your elder relative have? Please note that each type of cancer has different surgical and postoperative chemotherapy follow-up protocols. Generally, follow-up includes blood tests and consultations every 2-3 months, and imaging studies (such as CT scans o...

[Read More] Understanding Post-Surgery Follow-Up for Cancer Patients: Concerns and Insights


Related FAQ

Cancer Treatment

(Oncology)

Cancer Screening

(Oncology)

Rectal Cancer

(Oncology)

Pet Scan Report

(Oncology)

Breast Adenoma

(Oncology)

Lymphadenopathy

(Oncology)

Lung Cancer

(Oncology)

Bile Duct Cancer

(Oncology)

Pancreatic Cancer

(Oncology)

Melanoma

(Oncology)