CT Scans: Radiation Concerns and Alternatives Explained - Radiology

Share to:

Inquire about issues related to CT (Computed Tomography)?


Dear Dr.
Yang,
Recently, I discovered a hard lump in the deeper part of my jaw while touching it.
I visited a nearby medical center's ENT department, and after the doctor performed a physical examination, they ordered a CT scan.
However, I am quite worried because the media often reports that CT scans involve significant radiation exposure, equating one CT scan to the radiation of 100 X-rays, which raises the cancer risk.
I would like to know if radiation accumulates in the body and whether I can opt for an MRI instead of a CT scan, or if a CT scan is sufficient.

Additionally, the following day, I consulted a general surgeon who performed an ultrasound and mentioned that it was just lymphatic tissue and not serious.
The interpretations from the two doctors differ, and I am uncertain if I should get another CT scan at a different hospital.

I would appreciate your guidance on this matter.
Thank you!

Yuning, 40~49 year old female. Ask Date: 2011/10/11

Dr. Yang Jinghua reply Radiology


Dear Ms.
Yuning,
Hello.
Computed tomography (CT) is one of the modern medical imaging techniques.
Due to its rapid examination process and the ability to obtain extensive imaging information, it has become a widely used tool.
Depending on different clinical needs and the varying effects of ionizing radiation on different organs, the radiation dose from a single CT scan is approximately one to several tens of millisieverts (the dose from a single chest X-ray is about 0.1 millisieverts).
The dose is only incurred during the examination and does not accumulate.
Therefore, based on your condition, a single examination will not cause immediate tissue damage nor significantly increase the risk of cancer.
However, in accordance with the principles of ionizing radiation protection, the benefits of aiding in the assessment of your condition are important.
Therefore, I encourage you to discuss this further with your clinical physician.
Wishing you peace and health.
Sincerely,
Dr.
Ching-Hua Yang
Director, Department of Radiology
Taoyuan General Hospital, Ministry of Health and Welfare

Reply Date: 2011/10/11

More Info


Dear Patient,
Thank you for your inquiry regarding the use of CT scans and your concerns about radiation exposure. It’s understandable to feel apprehensive about the potential risks associated with imaging studies, especially given the media coverage surrounding radiation and its implications for health. Let’s break down your concerns regarding CT scans, radiation exposure, and the alternatives available.


Understanding Radiation Exposure from CT Scans
CT scans do involve exposure to ionizing radiation, which is a concern for many patients. The amount of radiation from a single CT scan can indeed be significant compared to traditional X-rays. For example, a single abdominal CT scan can expose a patient to about 10-14 millisieverts (mSv), which is roughly equivalent to the radiation exposure from 3 years of natural background radiation. However, it’s important to note that the risk of developing cancer from a single CT scan is relatively low. According to the International Commission on Radiological Protection (ICRP), the risk of cancer from radiation exposure below 100 mSv is not considered significant.


Cumulative Radiation Exposure
You asked whether radiation exposure accumulates in the body. The body does not retain radiation; rather, it is the total dose of radiation received over time that can increase the risk of potential adverse effects. Therefore, if you have had multiple imaging studies, it is essential to consider the cumulative dose. However, the risk from cumulative doses below 100 mSv remains low, and many medical professionals believe that the benefits of necessary imaging outweigh the risks.


Alternatives to CT Scans
MRI (Magnetic Resonance Imaging) is a radiation-free imaging modality that can be an excellent alternative for certain conditions. It uses magnetic fields and radio waves to create detailed images of organs and tissues. However, MRI is not always suitable for every situation. For example, if your doctor suspects a specific condition that is best visualized with a CT scan, such as certain types of tumors or internal bleeding, an MRI may not provide the necessary information.

If you are concerned about radiation exposure, it is worth discussing with your physician the possibility of using MRI instead of CT, especially if the clinical indications allow for it. However, keep in mind that insurance coverage may vary, and some facilities may have limitations on the types of imaging they can perform based on clinical guidelines.


Seeking a Second Opinion
Regarding the differing opinions between the ENT specialist and the general surgeon, it is not uncommon for different specialists to have varying interpretations based on their areas of expertise. If you feel uncertain about the diagnosis or the necessity of further imaging, seeking a second opinion is a reasonable approach. You can consult another healthcare provider or return to the original physician for clarification on the need for additional imaging.


Conclusion
In summary, while CT scans do involve radiation exposure, the associated risks are generally low, especially when the scans are clinically justified. If you have concerns about cumulative radiation exposure, discussing alternative imaging options like MRI with your healthcare provider is advisable. Always prioritize open communication with your medical team to ensure that you receive the best care tailored to your specific health needs.

Please feel free to reach out if you have further questions or need additional clarification. Your health and peace of mind are of utmost importance.

Best wishes for your health,
Doctor Q&A Teams



Similar Q&A

CT Scans for Liver Tumors: Radiation Risks and MRI Alternatives

Hello Dr. Sun, I recently had an ultrasound during my health check-up that revealed a liver tumor. The doctor has arranged for a CT scan. I would like to know if the radiation exposure from the CT scan poses a cancer risk for my future, or if I can opt for an MRI instead to exami...


Dr. Sun Shengyi reply Radiology
The radiation dose from computed tomography (CT) scans of the liver can vary significantly depending on different factors such as the number of scans, body composition, and the scanning area, with an average dose of approximately 14.0 mSv (ranging from 8.0 to 21.0 mSv). This dose...

[Read More] CT Scans for Liver Tumors: Radiation Risks and MRI Alternatives


Understanding CT Scan Radiation: Safety and Accumulation Concerns

Hello, doctor. 1. I would like to ask if the radiation exposure from a CT scan accumulates in the body. I am scheduled for a head CT scan soon (which requires contrast media). 2. I had an abdominal CT scan last October (also with contrast media), and my health insurance app s...


Dr. Wang Yifen reply Radiology
Hello, radiation is a form of energy that causes exposure during examinations, but it does not accumulate in the human body afterward. It is similar to how sunlight does not accumulate in the body after sun exposure. It is important to be aware of the effects of radiation on the ...

[Read More] Understanding CT Scan Radiation: Safety and Accumulation Concerns


Understanding Radiation Risks from Frequent CT Scans in Cancer Patients

Hello, I would like to ask two questions. 1. A family member, aged 55, was diagnosed with renal cell carcinoma and is currently undergoing immunotherapy. They need to have chest and abdominal CT scans every three months for monitoring, and they have already had six scans. I wou...


Dr. Wang Yifen reply Radiology
Hello, the necessity of X-ray radiation examinations is considered without limiting the radiation dose or the number of examinations. The American Association of Physicists in Medicine issued a public statement in 2011 stating that if a single "radiation examination" ha...

[Read More] Understanding Radiation Risks from Frequent CT Scans in Cancer Patients


Concerns About Radiation Exposure from Multiple CT Scans After a Fall

Hello, doctor. I had an accidental fall from a height on August 13, which was life-threatening at the time. I underwent a full-body CT scan and subsequently had various surgeries that also utilized CT imaging. After being discharged, I felt very uncomfortable and was readmitted t...


Dr. Ye Weicheng reply Radiology
Hello Ms. Lin: Radiation has existed since the formation of the Earth, and both biological evolution and humans have developed a certain level of tolerance to it. Currently, we categorize radiation damage into two types: deterministic effects and stochastic effects. Deterministic...

[Read More] Concerns About Radiation Exposure from Multiple CT Scans After a Fall


Related FAQ

Ct Scan Radiation

(Radiology)

X-Ray Examination

(Radiology)

Contrast Agent

(Radiology)

Computed Tomography

(Pulmonology)

Ct Scan Report

(Cardiology)

Mri Report

(Radiology)

Ct Scan

(Gastroenterology and Hepatology)

Pet Scan

(Nuclear Medicine)

Radiation

(Oncology)

X-Ray

(Orthopedics)