the Psychological Struggles of Alternative Service Members - Psychiatry

Share to:

Alternative service-related psychoneurosis


Hello, doctor.
I previously served in the military, but I have a history of coping mechanisms stemming from a difficult childhood environment.
During my service, a doctor in the southern region diagnosed me with panic disorder, depression, and personality disorder, which causes me to feel anxious and unable to work or interact with others.
I carry a utility knife with me, and whenever I feel the need, I start cutting my wrists.
Each time I cut deeply, I feel a sense of relief, and if it’s not enough, I continue to do so while in the military.
Many of my seniors mocked me and even threw utility knives at me, asking me to cut myself in front of them.
This behavior became a habit for me since middle school, and I started to experience hallucinations, believing I had friends with me.
I am afraid to tell my family about these actions.
After returning to the northern region, I sought medical help, but I am confused.
Besides not having received my exemption certificate yet, I am also terrified of future job prospects and facing crowded places.
I find myself following the hallucinations of these so-called friends, who keep urging me towards suicide.
I am very scared, but no one is helping me.
I fear that taking medication will have side effects.
What should I do? I am also afraid of being labeled as mentally ill and having to confront the terrifying environment of the military again.
Because of the discrimination I face, I feel an even greater need for the utility knife.
The deeper I cut, the safer I feel.
Please help me, doctor.

Nìmíng, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2012/04/26

Dr. Song Chengxian reply Psychiatry


Dear Mr.
Anonymous,
First, I apologize for the delayed response, as I was abroad and unable to receive your inquiry.
Regarding your long-standing method of self-harm as a way to cope with stress, it is indeed not a solution to the problem and has only led you to experience more pressure.
You mentioned your current fear of social interactions and your preference to be with "imaginary friends," but you are aware that this is not a healthy approach, which is why you have sought medical help.
I recommend that you continue to meet regularly with your psychiatrist to address and overcome these issues that have troubled you for many years.
Concerning the potential side effects of medication, it is crucial to have an open and honest discussion with your treating physician.
With the advancements in psychiatric medications, your doctor should be able to prescribe a treatment plan that minimizes side effects while effectively addressing your condition based on your symptoms, needs, and constitution.
In addition to medication, you may also ask your psychiatrist to arrange for psychotherapy to help you find healthier ways to cope with stress without resorting to self-harm.
Wishing you a speedy recovery,
Dr.
Song

Reply Date: 2012/04/26

More Info


It sounds like you are going through an incredibly challenging time, and I want to acknowledge the courage it takes to share your experiences. The psychological struggles you are facing, particularly as a result of your service and the environment you were in, are significant and deserve attention and care.
Firstly, it’s important to understand that the feelings of anxiety, depression, and the urge to self-harm are serious issues that can be addressed with the right support and treatment. You mentioned being diagnosed with panic disorder, depression, and personality disorders, which can create a complex interplay of symptoms that make daily life difficult. The fact that you are experiencing hallucinations and suicidal thoughts is particularly concerning and indicates that you need immediate professional help.

Self-harm, such as cutting, is often used as a coping mechanism to deal with overwhelming emotions or stress. While it may provide temporary relief, it ultimately does not resolve the underlying issues and can lead to more significant emotional and physical harm. It’s crucial to find healthier coping strategies and to work with a mental health professional who can guide you through this process.

Here are some steps you can take to seek help and support:
1. Reach Out to a Mental Health Professional: It’s essential to continue seeing a psychiatrist or psychologist who can provide you with the appropriate therapy and medication management. Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT) is often effective for anxiety and depression, helping you to reframe negative thoughts and develop healthier coping mechanisms.

2. Discuss Medication Concerns: You expressed fear about the side effects of medication. It’s important to have an open dialogue with your doctor about these concerns. Many modern psychiatric medications have fewer side effects than older ones, and your doctor can help you find a treatment plan that minimizes discomfort while addressing your symptoms.

3. Build a Support System: While it may feel isolating, try to connect with trusted friends or family members who can provide emotional support. If you feel comfortable, consider joining a support group for individuals dealing with similar issues. Sharing your experiences with others who understand can be incredibly validating.

4. Develop Coping Strategies: Work with your therapist to develop healthier coping strategies for managing stress and anxiety. This could include mindfulness practices, journaling, physical exercise, or engaging in creative outlets. Finding activities that bring you joy and relaxation can help reduce the urge to self-harm.

5. Emergency Support: If you ever feel that you are in immediate danger of harming yourself or having thoughts of suicide, please seek emergency help right away. This could mean calling a crisis hotline, going to the nearest emergency room, or contacting a trusted person who can help you get the support you need.

6. Educate Yourself: Understanding your conditions can empower you. Learn about panic disorder, depression, and personality disorders. Knowledge can help demystify your experiences and provide you with tools to manage your symptoms.

7. Avoid Isolation: It’s understandable to want to withdraw, especially when feeling overwhelmed. However, try to engage in social activities, even if it’s just small steps at first. Isolation can exacerbate feelings of depression and anxiety.

Remember, healing is a journey, and it’s okay to take it one step at a time. You are not alone in this, and there are people and resources available to help you navigate through these difficult times. Your life is valuable, and seeking help is a strong and positive step forward.

Similar Q&A

Facing Depression in Military Service: Coping with Increased Stress and Isolation

Hello, doctor. I am a conscript, and I have less than three months left until my discharge. Recently, I have been feeling depressed mainly because the number of personnel in my unit has decreased significantly (about one-third of what it used to be), and everyone's workload ...


Dr. Wu Enliang reply Psychiatry
Hello, Xiao Huang: It is recommended to call the "Military 24-Hour Psychological Consultation Hotline" at 0800-395-995 (Help me, please help me) for telephone consultation services. The "Military 24-Hour Psychological Consultation Hotline" is staffed by profes...

[Read More] Facing Depression in Military Service: Coping with Increased Stress and Isolation


Seeking Guidance: A Journey Through Mental Health Challenges

Hello, doctor. I have been seeing a psychiatrist for over 20 years. After experiencing trauma in my youth, I developed a mental illness and have been in treatment ever since. I am a frequent visitor to the e-hospital in Taiwan, where I seek advice whenever I face indecision or fr...


Dr. Wu Enliang reply Psychiatry
As we accumulate life experiences, we all continue to grow together. Keep it up! Dr. Wu En-Liang

[Read More] Seeking Guidance: A Journey Through Mental Health Challenges


Overcoming Fear: A Journey Through Mental Health Challenges

Hello, Doctor: I am a patient with a psychosomatic disorder, and I have the following concerns. 1. I have been suffering from mental illness for almost six years now. I truly hope that one day I can recover and not experience any relapses. This illness torments me, and I long f...


Dr. Lin Yanhong reply Psychiatry
Hello: Based on your four points, here are my responses: 1. There are many types of psychoneurosis; some can be cured while others may easily relapse. I'm not sure what diagnosis your doctor has given you. Regardless, every issue typically has a solution or a way to improve....

[Read More] Overcoming Fear: A Journey Through Mental Health Challenges


Overcoming Mental Struggles: A Soldier's Journey in the Navy

Hello Dr. Cheng, I am currently serving in the 146th Fleet at the Penghu Naval Base, and I am feeling very distressed. Every day, I find myself lost in negative thoughts... On the ship, I experience claustrophobia, and I am also afraid of flying due to acrophobia, which makes me ...


Dr. Zheng Jingming reply Psychiatry
Xiao Wei: Hello, regarding your concerns about "claustrophobia, fear of flying, acrophobia, feeling very anxious, suffering, and nightmares," I suggest you first seek an evaluation from a psychiatrist to confirm the diagnosis and determine whether medication or other tr...

[Read More] Overcoming Mental Struggles: A Soldier's Journey in the Navy


Related FAQ

Ptsd

(Psychiatry)

Others

(Psychiatry)

Work Adaptation

(Psychiatry)

Emotional Instability

(Psychiatry)

Psychological Counseling

(Psychiatry)

Facing Death

(Psychiatry)

Adjustment Disorder

(Psychiatry)

Anorexia Nervosa

(Psychiatry)

Autism

(Psychiatry)

Self-Harm

(Psychiatry)