How to Differentiate Between Pain and Muscle Spasm in Bedridden Patients - Rehabilitation

Share to:

Joint contracture


If I notice that my family member, who is bedridden for a long time, has their arms drawn back towards their body while I am assisting them with exercises, how can I determine whether they are in pain or if their muscle spasms are worsening? I don't visit them often, so I'm not very familiar with their condition.
Could you please help me with this?

Tom, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2015/02/26

Dr. Li Weiqiang reply Rehabilitation


Dear Tom,
Question: If I am exercising with a family member who has been bedridden for a long time and I notice that their hand is retracting towards their body, how can I determine if they are in pain or if their muscle spasms are worsening?
Answer: Generally, a person in pain will react; they may vocalize discomfort or pull their hand back.
If they cannot speak, their natural response would be to retract their hand, and their facial expressions will reflect signs of distress.
Question: Since I do not visit them often, I am not very familiar with their condition.
Could you please help me with this?
Answer: Would it be possible for you to record a video on your phone and send it over?
Wishing you peace and health,
Director of the Rehabilitation Department, Taoyuan Hospital, Ministry of Health and Welfare, Li Wei-Chiang

Reply Date: 2015/02/26

More Info


Differentiating between pain and muscle spasm in bedridden patients can be challenging, especially if you are not frequently monitoring their condition. Understanding the signs and symptoms associated with each can help you make a more informed assessment. Here are some key points to consider:

1. Understanding Pain and Muscle Spasms
- Pain: This is typically a subjective experience that can be sharp, dull, throbbing, or aching. It may be localized to a specific area or more diffuse. Pain can be triggered by movement, pressure, or even at rest, depending on the underlying cause (e.g., injury, inflammation, or nerve compression).

- Muscle Spasm: This refers to an involuntary contraction of a muscle or group of muscles. It often feels like a tight knot and can be accompanied by stiffness. Muscle spasms can occur without any pain or can be painful, depending on the severity and duration of the spasm.


2. Observational Signs
When assessing your bedridden family member, look for the following signs:
- Body Language: If the patient is grimacing, moaning, or showing signs of distress when you move their limbs, this may indicate pain. Conversely, if they seem to be relaxed but have a tight muscle, it may suggest a spasm.

- Muscle Tone: If the muscle appears hard and tense, it may be in spasm. You can gently palpate the muscle to feel for tightness. If the muscle relaxes when you stop moving it, it may indicate a spasm rather than pain.

- Range of Motion: Try to gently move the affected limb. If the patient resists movement or expresses discomfort, it may indicate pain. If the limb moves but the muscle feels tight, it may suggest a spasm.


3. Response to Treatment
- Pain Relief: If you apply gentle stretching or heat to the area and the patient shows improvement in comfort, it may indicate that the discomfort was due to a muscle spasm. If the pain persists despite these interventions, it may be due to another underlying issue.

- Muscle Relaxation: If you notice that the muscle relaxes after a few minutes of gentle stretching or massage, it is likely a spasm. If the muscle remains tense and painful, further evaluation may be necessary.


4. Communication
If the patient is able to communicate, ask them about their discomfort. Questions like "Does this hurt?" or "Do you feel tightness?" can provide valuable insights. However, in cases where the patient has cognitive impairments or is non-verbal, you will need to rely more on observational cues.


5. Consulting Healthcare Professionals
If you are uncertain about the cause of the symptoms, it is essential to consult with a healthcare professional. They can perform a thorough assessment and may recommend imaging studies or other diagnostic tests to determine the underlying cause of the pain or spasms.


Conclusion
Differentiating between pain and muscle spasm in bedridden patients requires careful observation and understanding of the patient's responses. By paying attention to their body language, muscle tone, and response to gentle movements, you can gain insights into their condition. If in doubt, seeking professional medical advice is always the best course of action to ensure appropriate care and management.

Similar Q&A

Understanding Muscle Pain vs. Nerve Compression: A Patient's Journey

Hello, doctor. I would like to consult about my father, who is 64 years old. Symptoms: 1. Areas of soreness: upper back, outer upper arms, lower back, knee and thigh junction, inner calves; (the soreness is not consistent, sometimes it’s here, sometimes there, with the upper bac...


Dr. Zhang Junwei reply Neurosurgery
Hello: Based on the symptoms you described, it is more likely to be a cervical spine issue. Since the MRI of the cervical spine has confirmed nerve compression, and the symptoms are consistent, as a neurosurgeon, I would also recommend surgery. It is possible that your father has...

[Read More] Understanding Muscle Pain vs. Nerve Compression: A Patient's Journey


Understanding Unexplained Body Pain and Numbness: A Neurology Perspective

In the past month, I have experienced body aches that progressed to numbness in my legs and hands. My legs feel weak and painful when standing, and I have intermittent pain or twitching throughout my body. Sometimes my wrists, near my ankles, and knees also hurt. My lower back an...


Dr. Lan Shengxing reply Neurology
Dear Ms. Chen, the symptoms you described are most likely caused by cervical spine issues. It is recommended that you first visit a neurology clinic for a detailed neurological examination to determine the underlying cause. Additionally, it is advised not to use overly soft beddi...

[Read More] Understanding Unexplained Body Pain and Numbness: A Neurology Perspective


Understanding Chronic Pain: How to Identify Causes and Seek Treatment

Dear Dr. Liao, Regarding Symptom 1, during my military service, I experienced a back strain while lifting heavy objects. For a while, I would wake up in the middle of the night due to pain, making it difficult to sleep. I sought treatment at a military hospital and received medi...


Dr. Liao Yaopan reply Family Medicine
Hello, based on your inquiry, it is recommended to consult a neurosurgeon for further evaluation. Thank you for your message, and we appreciate your concern. Changhua Hospital.

[Read More] Understanding Chronic Pain: How to Identify Causes and Seek Treatment


Understanding Muscle Pain and Weakness: A Neurological Perspective

Hello doctor, I started experiencing soreness in my arms and hands at the beginning of February due to working on assignments and frequently using the computer. At first, it didn't affect my daily life, so I didn't pay much attention to it. However, over the past week, ...


Dr. Jiang Junyi reply Neurology
Hello: Regarding the issue of numbness, the first consideration should be peripheral nerve compression symptoms. As for amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS), it primarily involves motor function. This condition refers to problems with motor neurons, which control muscle movement. ...

[Read More] Understanding Muscle Pain and Weakness: A Neurological Perspective


Related FAQ

Muscle Pain

(Rehabilitation)

Muscle Pain

(Neurology)

Cramps

(Rehabilitation)

Electromyography

(Rehabilitation)

Muscle Pain

(Internal Medicine)

Back Soreness

(Rehabilitation)

Involuntary Muscle Movement

(Neurology)

Muscle Cramp

(Orthopedics)

Old Injury Pain

(Rehabilitation)

Foot Pain

(Rehabilitation)