Cholesterol: Good vs. Bad and the Latest Insights - Cardiology

Share to:

High cholesterol


Hello, Director He.
Recently, I had a health check-up, and I noticed that "high-density lipoprotein cholesterol" (HDL-C) and "low-density lipoprotein cholesterol" (LDL-C) are commonly referred to as good and bad cholesterol, respectively.
However, after researching, I found some articles suggesting that cholesterol may not be categorized as good or bad anymore.
The article I found states that cholesterol can be beneficial and harmless.
I'm unsure about the validity of such claims or whether all cholesterol is indeed beneficial.
Thank you.

Awei, 50~59 year old female. Ask Date: 2016/05/29

Dr. He Dongjin reply Cardiology


Currently, low-density lipoprotein (LDL) cholesterol remains a major culprit in atherosclerosis.
Dietary restrictions on cholesterol have been relaxed compared to the past because approximately 80% of cholesterol is produced by the body, with only 20% coming from dietary sources.
For more details, please refer to Dr.
Huang Rui-Ren's health education article at http://www.twhealth.org.tw/index.php?option=com_zoo&task=item&item_id=1029&Itemid=19.

The "Dietary Guidelines for Americans" are established by the U.S.
Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) and the U.S.
Department of Agriculture (USDA), and are updated every five years.
Although the latest version of the guidelines no longer specifies that cholesterol intake should be limited to less than 300 mg per day, it still explicitly recommends that individuals "should minimize the intake of high-cholesterol foods." This is because foods high in cholesterol often also contain higher levels of saturated fats, which are detrimental to health.
Furthermore, the guidelines note that while eggs and shellfish contain higher levels of cholesterol, they are low in saturated fats and can be included in protein choices in moderation.
The rationale behind these recommendations is twofold: first, dietary control has limited effectiveness in lowering cholesterol levels, and second, there are effective cholesterol-lowering medications available.
In fact, about 80% of the total cholesterol in the blood is produced by the body, meaning it is largely independent of dietary intake.
The liver produces 80% of cholesterol, with only 20% influenced by the consumption of high-cholesterol foods, which in turn affects blood cholesterol levels.
This implies that even with strict dietary control, the maximum impact on total blood cholesterol levels is around a 20% reduction.
For example, if the total cholesterol level is 250 mg/dL, strict dietary control may only reduce it to about 200 mg/dL.
Thus, while it is still advisable to reduce the intake of high-cholesterol foods, the effectiveness of dietary control is limited.
There are now effective cholesterol-lowering medications available, which are convenient to take—typically one to two pills a day can achieve ideal cholesterol reduction.
These medications are known as statins, which have revolutionized the management of cardiovascular diseases over the past twenty years.
For individuals with existing cardiovascular diseases, those who have had stents placed, high-risk groups, or diabetic patients, taking statins as prescribed can help maintain LDL cholesterol levels in the ideal range (below 100 mg/dL) and reduce mortality rates by one-third, demonstrating significant efficacy.
Even though the U.S.
Dietary Guidelines have undergone some changes regarding cholesterol intake recommendations, it remains essential for the population to reduce cholesterol intake to lower the risk of cardiovascular diseases and avoid metabolic syndrome.
In Japan, the term "lifestyle diseases" is often used to describe conditions related to high blood pressure, high blood sugar, and high cholesterol, indicating a strong correlation between these conditions and poor lifestyle habits.
Therefore, appropriate dietary control and lifestyle changes remain important.
Regarding egg consumption, it is recommended to eat one egg yolk every two days.
One egg yolk contains about 250 mg of cholesterol, and since the previous recommendation was to limit daily cholesterol intake to no more than 300 mg, consuming one egg yolk per day would leave little room for other cholesterol-containing foods, making it easy to exceed the limit.
Although there is debate about whether cholesterol intake should be strictly limited, from a cardiovascular disease prevention standpoint, it is still advisable to consume one egg yolk every two days, while there is no need to restrict egg white intake.
However, for individuals aged 80 and above, who are considered elderly and long-lived, there is less need for dietary restrictions, as at this age, "not wanting to eat" is a greater concern than "restricting what to eat."
Low-density cholesterol is a primary cause of atherosclerosis.
Cholesterol is synthesized by the liver and is an essential component of cell membranes.
The levels of total cholesterol and LDL cholesterol are parallel; as total cholesterol increases, LDL cholesterol also rises.
The reason for closely monitoring cholesterol, particularly LDL cholesterol, is that it is a health hazard.
Conditions such as cerebrovascular occlusion, angina, and coronary artery atherosclerosis, collectively referred to as cardiovascular atherosclerosis, are primarily caused by LDL cholesterol, which accumulates on the inner walls of blood vessels.
The body's physiological response to oxidized LDL leads to atherosclerosis.
Initially, fatty streaks can be seen in the blood vessels, which gradually accumulate and form atherosclerotic plaques; in severe cases, these can become calcified.
Therefore, the presence of calcification in blood vessels indicates long-term atherosclerosis.
A more alarming situation arises when an atherosclerotic plaque suddenly ruptures or develops a crack, leading to platelet aggregation and the formation of a thrombus, which can obstruct blood vessels.
The timing of such ruptures is unpredictable; for instance, a person with only 50% narrowing of a coronary artery may suddenly experience plaque rupture, resulting in a thrombus that completely blocks the artery, leading to a myocardial infarction.

So, what types of individuals are more likely to experience plaque rupture? Can it be predicted? Is the plaque stable or unstable? Currently, medicine cannot predict this.
Therefore, patients with existing atherosclerotic plaques are advised to undergo medication treatment to reduce the risk of heart attacks.

The commonly used medications fall into two categories:
1.
Antiplatelet medications, with aspirin being the most commonly used.
A low dose (75 to 150 mg) is typically sufficient.
If a coronary artery plaque suddenly ruptures and causes a thrombus, aspirin can prevent platelet aggregation, allowing for medical intervention.
2.
Statins, which can lower the concentration of "bad cholesterol" in coronary artery plaques, stabilizing the plaques and reducing the risk of rupture.
Statins have few side effects, but it is generally recommended to monitor liver function (ALT) for the first 3 to 6 months after starting treatment, as less than 1% of patients may experience elevated liver function.
Additionally, monitoring muscle enzymes (CK or CPK) is advised, as some medications can cause rhabdomyolysis, although this is not common.
Some patients may experience muscle soreness, such as in the arms or thighs, and a small number may have lower back pain.
If any of these side effects occur, patients should consult their physician for possible dosage adjustments or medication changes.

It is important to note that statins should not be combined with red yeast rice or supplements containing red yeast rice, as red yeast rice also contains small amounts of statin-like compounds, which can lead to overdose and cause rhabdomyolysis, kidney disease, or even be fatal if not handled carefully.

Reply Date: 2016/05/29

More Info


Understanding cholesterol and its implications for health is a topic that has evolved significantly over the years. Traditionally, cholesterol has been categorized into "good" and "bad" types based on the lipoproteins that carry it in the bloodstream. High-density lipoprotein (HDL) is often referred to as "good" cholesterol because it helps transport cholesterol away from the arteries and back to the liver, where it can be processed and eliminated. Conversely, low-density lipoprotein (LDL) is known as "bad" cholesterol because high levels of it can lead to plaque buildup in the arteries, increasing the risk of cardiovascular diseases such as heart attacks and strokes.

Recent research, however, has begun to challenge the simplistic good vs. bad dichotomy of cholesterol. Some studies suggest that the relationship between cholesterol levels and heart disease is more complex than previously thought. For instance, while high levels of LDL cholesterol are indeed associated with an increased risk of heart disease, not all LDL particles are created equal. There are small, dense LDL particles that are more harmful and larger, more buoyant LDL particles that may not pose the same risk. This has led to a more nuanced understanding of cholesterol, where the focus is shifting from merely lowering LDL levels to understanding the overall lipid profile and the specific types of LDL present.

Moreover, HDL cholesterol has also been scrutinized. While higher levels of HDL are generally considered protective against heart disease, some recent studies have indicated that simply having high HDL levels does not necessarily confer a lower risk of cardiovascular events. This has prompted researchers to investigate the functionality of HDL particles, as not all HDL is equally effective in its role of cholesterol transport and removal.

The article you referenced suggests that cholesterol may not be as harmful as once believed, which aligns with some emerging perspectives in the field. However, it is essential to approach such claims with caution. While cholesterol is indeed vital for various bodily functions, including hormone production and cell membrane integrity, the context of its levels and the types of lipoproteins involved cannot be overlooked. Elevated levels of LDL cholesterol and low levels of HDL cholesterol are still significant risk factors for cardiovascular disease.

In conclusion, while cholesterol is necessary for health, its impact on cardiovascular risk is influenced by various factors, including the types of lipoproteins present and individual metabolic responses. It is crucial to have a comprehensive understanding of one's lipid profile and to consult healthcare professionals for personalized advice. Regular health check-ups, including lipid panels, can help monitor cholesterol levels and assess cardiovascular risk more accurately. As research continues to evolve, staying informed about the latest findings will be essential for making informed health decisions.

Similar Q&A

Understanding Cholesterol: LDL vs. HDL and Their Health Impacts

Hello! I would like to ask about the difference between low-density lipoprotein (LDL) cholesterol and high-density lipoprotein (HDL) cholesterol. What are the effects of having high cholesterol? What are the implications of having low cholesterol? What is considered a standard ch...


Dr. Cai Xiuwen reply Nutrition
Hello! Cholesterol is a type of lipid in the body that serves as a building block for hormones and bile acids, which are essential for digestion. It is a crucial substance in the human body. However, if cholesterol levels are too high, it can lead to vascular issues such as ather...

[Read More] Understanding Cholesterol: LDL vs. HDL and Their Health Impacts


Understanding Good vs. Bad Cholesterol: What You Need to Know

My mother went to the hospital for a cholesterol check. The doctor said there are good and bad cholesterols, and that my mother's bad cholesterol is close to 100. For a normal person, the bad cholesterol level is about 150. The doctor advised her to pay attention to it, but ...


Dr. Yang Guojun reply Internal Medicine
Good cholesterol refers to HDL, which should ideally be above 35 mg/dL, while bad cholesterol refers to LDL, which should ideally be below 130 mg/dL. To increase good cholesterol, it is beneficial to consume more deep-sea fish oil, while bad cholesterol can be reduced through reg...

[Read More] Understanding Good vs. Bad Cholesterol: What You Need to Know


Understanding High Cholesterol Levels: Impacts of Elevated HDL and TC/HDL Ratio

Hello, let me explain my cholesterol changes. I underwent health check-ups from 2019 to 2022, with total cholesterol values of 181 mg/dL, 188 mg/dL, 212 mg/dL, and 222 mg/dL. The low-density lipoprotein (LDL) levels were 105 mg/dL, 96 mg/dL, 106 mg/dL, and 114 mg/dL, while the hi...


Dr. Hou Angting reply Family Medicine
Hello: Cholesterol levels can be influenced by diet and exercise habits. Generally speaking, higher levels of high-density lipoprotein (HDL) cholesterol are associated with a protective effect against cardiovascular diseases, while higher levels of low-density lipoprotein (LDL) c...

[Read More] Understanding High Cholesterol Levels: Impacts of Elevated HDL and TC/HDL Ratio


Cholesterol and Eggs: How Often Can You Eat Eggs with High Cholesterol?

Hello, I would like to ask why individuals with high cholesterol levels in health check-ups should not eat eggs every day, considering that low-density lipoprotein (LDL) is the "bad" cholesterol and high-density lipoprotein (HDL) is the "good" cholesterol? How...


Dr. Shi Guimei reply Nutrition
Dear QQ, Hello! The human body has two main sources of cholesterol. A significant portion is synthesized by the body, particularly in the liver. The other source is dietary intake, which can influence the liver's cholesterol production to some extent. Cholesterol in food is...

[Read More] Cholesterol and Eggs: How Often Can You Eat Eggs with High Cholesterol?


Related FAQ

Cholesterol

(Cardiology)

Cholesterol

(Internal Medicine)

Atherosclerosis

(Cardiology)

Cholesterol

(Family Medicine)

Angina

(Cardiology)

Cholesterol

(Nutrition)

Coronary Artery Stenosis

(Cardiology)

Hypertension

(Cardiology)

Afib

(Cardiology)

Axis Deviation

(Cardiology)