Your Symptoms: Disc Herniation vs. Piriformis Syndrome

I would like to inquire whether it is a herniated disc or piriformis syndrome?

Hello, doctor.
My symptoms started in early October.
Initially, I felt tightness in the left side of my lower back and hip joint.
One day, I did some stretching and leg lifts while lying down, and I'm not sure if I used the wrong force, but the next day I felt some asymmetry and tightness in my lower back and back, so I went to see a doctor.
At first, the doctor said it was due to improper muscle weakness and advised me to take muscle relaxants and pain relief medication and to rest.
However, after finishing the medication, I still haven't improved, and more uncomfortable symptoms have begun to appear.

For instance, after sitting for a while, I feel soreness and tightness from the lower lumbar region near the tailbone, radiating along the buttocks to the inner groin area (on both sides).
Sometimes, when sitting on a harder chair, I start to feel discomfort within just a few minutes, as if the bone in the area where my buttocks contact the chair is pressing directly on the muscles.
I often experience numbness that travels from the outer side of my calves to my ankles and the top of my feet.
My left foot, in particular, experiences numbness on the outer sides of both the big toe and little toe (the big toe feels like it’s being tightly held by a rubber band).

When I stand up, the numbness and tightness usually improve a bit, but when I sit down again, the discomfort returns.
Lying flat, I also feel soreness and tightness in the lower lumbar region and buttocks.
The numbness in my left big toe becomes more pronounced when I lie down with my legs straight, but it eases when I sleep on my side with my knees bent.
In the morning, the symptoms are usually not very noticeable, but after working and sitting for a few hours throughout the day, even if I get up to walk around occasionally, the discomfort worsens by the evening.

Even when standing and walking, I often find it hard to relieve the discomfort.
When I bend down to pick something up, it doesn’t hurt yet, but I feel tightness on both sides of my back and hips, making it difficult to bend down.
Additionally, I often feel like I’m walking like a penguin because my lower back and both hip joints are very tight.

I would like to ask the doctor if my symptoms resemble a herniated disc or piriformis syndrome.
Previously, a doctor had taken X-rays of my spine, which appeared normal, but I haven’t had X-rays of my pelvis and hip joints.
Another doctor arranged for an electromyography (EMG) test, but I later learned that it requires needle insertion, and since I have a history of fainting with needles, I would like to know if I can first undergo an MRI.
If the MRI does not reveal any issues, then I can proceed with the EMG test.
Thank you!

yeezy, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2016/11/04

Dr. Yin Xinbei reply Rehabilitation

Is it a herniated disc or piriformis syndrome? Both are possible.
An electromyography (EMG) test with needle insertion may help differentiate between the two, but if the nerve root is not injured, it may not provide a clear distinction.
MRI is more expensive, and physicians may have concerns when prescribing it under health insurance; typically, it is ordered only after medication or physical therapy has proven ineffective.
However, if one is willing to pay out-of-pocket, it can be ordered directly.
It's important to note that herniated discs and piriformis syndrome require imaging of different areas, with each area costing approximately $6,000 to $8,000.
In fact, a clinical physical examination can generally help in making a preliminary distinction, but it is also possible for both areas to have issues, making it difficult to determine the primary problem.
Physical therapy can treat both areas simultaneously; if one prefers to avoid the cost of an MRI, they can opt for treatment first and reassess later.

Reply Date: 2016/11/04

More Info

Based on your symptoms and the information you've provided, it seems you are experiencing a complex interplay of musculoskeletal issues that could potentially involve either a herniated disc or piriformis syndrome. Let's break down the characteristics of both conditions to help clarify your situation.

Disc Herniation
A herniated disc occurs when the soft inner gel of the disc protrudes through a tear in the outer layer. This can lead to compression of nearby nerves, resulting in pain, numbness, or weakness in the affected areas. Common symptoms of a herniated disc include:
- Localized Pain: Pain in the lower back that may radiate down the leg (sciatica).

- Numbness or Tingling: Often felt in the legs or feet, particularly in the areas innervated by the affected nerve root.

- Weakness: Muscle weakness in the legs, which can affect mobility.

- Pain with Movement: Increased pain when sitting, bending, or lifting.

In your case, the tightness and discomfort in your lower back and hips, along with the radiating sensations down your legs, could suggest a herniated disc, especially if the pain worsens with certain movements or prolonged sitting.

Piriformis Syndrome
Piriformis syndrome occurs when the piriformis muscle, located in the buttock region, spasms and causes pain in the buttocks. This muscle can also irritate the nearby sciatic nerve, leading to symptoms similar to sciatica. Key features of piriformis syndrome include:
- Buttock Pain: Pain in the buttock that may radiate down the leg.

- Pain with Sitting: Discomfort when sitting for extended periods, particularly on hard surfaces.

- Numbness or Tingling: Often felt in the back of the leg or foot, similar to sciatica.

- Relief with Movement: Symptoms may improve with certain movements or positions, such as stretching or changing posture.

Given that you experience tightness and discomfort in the hips and buttocks, along with the numbness in your toes, piriformis syndrome is also a possibility.

Diagnostic Approach
You mentioned that you have already undergone X-rays and electromyography (EMG) testing. While X-rays can rule out significant bony abnormalities, they are not effective in diagnosing soft tissue issues like disc herniation or muscle-related problems. An MRI (Magnetic Resonance Imaging) is a more sensitive imaging modality that can provide detailed images of the soft tissues, including discs and muscles. It is a valuable tool for diagnosing herniated discs and can also help assess the condition of the piriformis muscle.

If you have concerns about the EMG due to your history of fainting, discussing these with your healthcare provider is essential. They can help determine the best course of action, which may include prioritizing an MRI before proceeding with the EMG.

Treatment Options
Regardless of the diagnosis, initial treatment for both conditions typically includes:
1. Physical Therapy: A tailored program focusing on stretching and strengthening exercises can help alleviate symptoms and improve mobility.

2. Medications: Nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs) can help reduce pain and inflammation.

3. Activity Modification: Avoiding prolonged sitting and incorporating regular movement can help manage symptoms.

4. Injections: In some cases, corticosteroid injections may be recommended to reduce inflammation around the affected nerves.

If conservative treatments fail, further interventions may be considered, including surgical options for herniated discs or, in rare cases, surgery for piriformis syndrome.

Conclusion
In summary, your symptoms could be indicative of either a herniated disc or piriformis syndrome. An MRI would be a prudent next step to clarify the diagnosis and guide appropriate treatment. It’s essential to maintain open communication with your healthcare provider regarding your symptoms and any concerns about diagnostic procedures. With the right diagnosis and treatment plan, many patients experience significant relief and can return to their normal activities.

Similar Q&A

Is It Piriformis Syndrome or Herniated Disc? Understanding Your Pain

Hello, about a month ago, I accidentally sat down on a small stool without paying attention to its height. I was sitting on a chair, and the drop was about 10-15 cm. I had an X-ray done, but the doctors said there was no issue. I continued to run and exercise afterward, but my ri...

Dr. Li Yongheng reply Orthopedics
Hello, based on your symptoms, both piriformis syndrome and herniated disc are possible. In addition to performing a lumbar MRI for differential diagnosis, local injection of corticosteroids and anesthetics into the piriformis muscle can also be considered. If the local injection...

Self-Testing for Piriformis Syndrome vs. Disc Issues: A Guide

Hello doctor, I have a problem with lower back pain, but I'm not sure if it's related to a disc issue or the piriformis muscle. I would like to self-test. I have previously undergone X-rays, ultrasound, and MRI at Pingtung Christian Hospital, where the doctor mentioned ...

Dr. Hong Ximing reply Orthopedics
Based on your description, MRI scans have been conducted, and it seems that the nerve compression is not severe. Only the nerve roots in the left buttock and the outer side of the left calf are affected, while the piriformis muscle is not involved. Therefore, it is more likely to...

Understanding Leg Pain: Disc Issues or Piriformis Syndrome?

Hello Doctor, last February I was hospitalized for rehabilitation for a year due to an acute lumbar spine injury from sports, and I did not undergo surgery. After being discharged in March this year, I resumed work and continued exercising. Around July this year, I started experi...

Dr. Wang Zhaomin reply Rehabilitation
Herniated discs, piriformis syndrome, and other soft tissue lesions may all potentially trigger related symptoms. Please visit a neurologist, neurosurgeon, orthopedic specialist, or rehabilitation physician for an accurate diagnosis and appropriate treatment.

Understanding Sciatica: Causes, Symptoms, and Treatment Options

Hello, doctor. I am overweight and also have issues with muscle tightness (the therapist mentioned they have never encountered such tight muscles). Ten days ago, I suddenly rode a motorcycle for 90 minutes (I haven't ridden one in 20 years). After returning home, I started e...

Dr. Jiang Junyi reply Neurology
Hello, based on your description, it is important to consider symptoms of nerve compression due to a herniated disc, which may also result from sudden injuries such as twisting the waist, bending to lift heavy objects, or experiencing excessive force, for example, falling from a ...