PTSD: Why Traumatic Memories Are Often Repressed - Psychiatry

Share to:

Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD)


Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) can lead to the forgetting of certain memories due to psychological factors.
This phenomenon can be explained by Freud's theory of repression, which suggests that individuals often unconsciously avoid recalling traumatic experiences that cause them distress.
As a result, these types of memories may be suppressed and become inaccessible.
Regarding your aunt, who is a survivor of the 921 earthquake and struggles to remember her traumatic memories, treatment options may include psychotherapy, such as cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT) or eye movement desensitization and reprocessing (EMDR).
Medication, such as selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors (SSRIs), may also be prescribed to help manage symptoms of PTSD.
Repressed memories refer to memories that are unconsciously blocked from awareness, often because they are too painful or distressing to confront.
This mechanism involves the mind's effort to avoid thinking about certain events or experiences.

Mengfeng, 10~19 year old female. Ask Date: 2017/12/15

Dr. Wu Enliang reply Psychiatry


The September 21 earthquake caused severe disasters across Taiwan, resulting in numerous casualties and the destruction of many homes.
Survivors faced the devastation of their communities, the loss of loved ones, and various difficulties in daily life, housing, and transportation, leading to immediate and ongoing negative impacts on their mental and physical well-being.
The shadow of aftershocks further exacerbated the situation.
As the frontline rescue efforts gradually came to a close, it became crucial to focus on post-disaster psychological rehabilitation and the treatment of related mental health disorders to prevent a secondary crisis (mental illness).
While homes can be rebuilt, the damage to the psyche can leave lasting scars.
Survivors are not merely a distinction between the living and the deceased; they often find themselves repeatedly recalling the events of the earthquake, trapped in traumatic experiences, grappling with feelings of guilt, psychological numbness, fatigue, avoidance of external support, and questioning the value and meaning of life.
These are potential psychological responses, but individual differences should also be acknowledged.
Common psychological symptoms following a disaster may include irritability, self-blame, blaming others, isolation, withdrawal, fear, shock, numbness, daze, feelings of helplessness, emotional instability, sadness, denial, difficulty concentrating, and memory impairment.
Physical symptoms may manifest as decreased appetite, dizziness, headaches, a sensation of choking in the throat, chest discomfort, gastrointestinal issues, diarrhea, fatigue, musculoskeletal pain, changes in activity levels, insomnia, and nightmares.
When significant traumatic events lead to persistent feelings of fear, helplessness, confusion, or agitation within four weeks, accompanied by numbness, detachment, loss of self-identity, difficulty recalling certain events, and dizziness, along with re-experiencing the trauma through dreams or memories, avoidance of trauma-related stimuli, and heightened alertness (such as irritability, hypervigilance, and startle responses), these symptoms may indicate acute stress disorder if they last from two days to four weeks.
If symptoms persist for more than one month, it may develop into post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), which can be classified as acute or chronic based on the duration (three months or less, or more than three months).
PTSD often coexists with other mental health disorders, such as depression, panic disorder, phobias, anxiety disorders, obsessive-compulsive disorder, mood disorders, and substance abuse or dependence.
Research following past earthquakes has shown that the prevalence of post-traumatic stress disorder is between 32% to 60% in adults and 26% to 95% in children.
Other potential psychological issues and mental disorders include grief reactions, sleep disorders, adjustment disorders, dissociative disorders, conversion disorders (hysteria), and reactive psychosis.
Individuals with pre-existing mental health conditions may experience a significant worsening of symptoms.
The psychological changes and mental health issues in disaster responders, children, and adolescents require immediate and proactive intervention to prevent the spread of severe psychological distress.
Therefore, there is an urgent need for prevention, early assessment, and diagnosis.
Effective coping strategies for individuals include not suppressing feelings, appropriately expressing emotions; not forcing oneself to forget; engaging in discussions about the disaster with others to allow for understanding and expressions of care; seeking opportunities to talk with family and children; striving to restore normal routines; ensuring adequate rest, sleep, nutrition, and exercise; and being particularly cautious about potential accidents post-disaster.
It is important not to hesitate to seek help from others and to consult professionals immediately when experiencing physical or mental health issues.
Children often become anxious, withdrawn, expressionless, sensitive, exhibit regressive behaviors, have sleep disturbances, feel guilt, and may present physical symptoms after an earthquake.
They particularly need adult support, and caregivers should provide them with a sense of safety through comforting words and physical contact to alleviate feelings of fear and loneliness.
Encouraging children to express their fears, pain, and grief through play, drawing, language, writing, and music is essential, as is showing concern and spending time with them in play with other children.
Older children should be encouraged to participate in community rebuilding efforts to foster a sense of family unity.
If mental health disorders unfortunately arise, prompt medical attention should be sought, and treatment should include medication and various psychosocial interventions (such as mental health education, relaxation training, breathing exercises, individual therapy, group therapy, cognitive therapy, and behavioral therapy).

Reply Date: 2017/12/15

More Info


Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) is a complex psychological condition that can arise after experiencing or witnessing a traumatic event. One of the most intriguing aspects of PTSD is the phenomenon of memory repression, where individuals may find it difficult or even impossible to recall certain memories associated with the trauma. This can be attributed to a combination of psychological mechanisms, including Freud's concept of repression, as well as neurobiological factors.

Freud's theory of repression suggests that individuals unconsciously block out memories that are too distressing to confront. This defense mechanism serves as a protective function, allowing individuals to avoid the emotional pain associated with traumatic experiences. In the case of your aunt, who is a survivor of the 921 earthquake in Taiwan, her inability to recall specific traumatic memories may be a manifestation of this psychological defense. The mind often prioritizes survival and emotional well-being over the recollection of painful experiences, leading to a selective forgetting of traumatic events.

From a neurobiological perspective, trauma can significantly affect the brain's functioning, particularly areas involved in memory processing, such as the hippocampus and the amygdala. The hippocampus is responsible for forming new memories and retrieving old ones, while the amygdala plays a crucial role in processing emotions, especially fear. During traumatic events, the brain may become overwhelmed, leading to alterations in how memories are encoded and stored. This can result in fragmented memories or complete amnesia regarding the traumatic event.

In terms of treatment, addressing repressed memories and the symptoms of PTSD often requires a multifaceted approach. Medication can be beneficial for managing symptoms such as anxiety and depression, which frequently accompany PTSD. Commonly prescribed medications include selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors (SSRIs) like Paroxetine, which can help alleviate anxiety and improve mood. However, medication alone may not be sufficient for everyone.

Psychotherapy, particularly trauma-focused therapies, is essential in helping individuals process and integrate their traumatic memories. Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT) and Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing (EMDR) are two effective therapeutic approaches for PTSD. These therapies aim to help individuals confront their traumatic memories in a safe and controlled environment, gradually reducing the emotional charge associated with those memories. Through these therapeutic processes, individuals can work towards understanding their trauma, developing coping strategies, and ultimately reclaiming their lives.

Regarding the concept of repressed memories, it is indeed related to the conscious avoidance of certain thoughts or feelings. Repression can manifest as a lack of awareness of specific memories or as a general numbing of emotional responses. However, it is important to note that repressed memories can sometimes resurface unexpectedly, often triggered by reminders of the trauma or through therapeutic interventions.

In summary, the repression of traumatic memories in PTSD is a complex interplay of psychological defense mechanisms and neurobiological changes. Treatment typically involves a combination of medication and psychotherapy to help individuals process their trauma and regain control over their lives. If your aunt continues to struggle with her memories and the emotional aftermath of the earthquake, encouraging her to seek professional help from a mental health provider could be a crucial step towards healing.

Similar Q&A

Understanding Intrusive Memories: Coping with PTSD and Selective Amnesia

I previously experienced psychogenic amnesia, and I don't remember how much I forgot or what caused the forgetfulness. Recently, fragmented images have begun to surface, leading me to believe that my amnesia may be related to family conflicts. However, the images I recall ar...


Dr. Wu Enliang reply Psychiatry
Your psychologist refers to a "psychiatrist"? It is advisable to ask him or her for a referral to receive individual psychotherapy, which would allow for more time to address and process these internal psychological conflicts. Wishing you a speedy recovery.

[Read More] Understanding Intrusive Memories: Coping with PTSD and Selective Amnesia


Understanding and Managing Stress-Induced Hallucinations and Memory Loss

About four years ago, during middle school, I experienced similar issues when under significant stress, such as auditory hallucinations and mild amnesia. I often heard chain-like sounds and two overlapping musical notes (similar to a police siren but much lower and slower). The a...


Dr. Wu Enliang reply Psychiatry
If you are not keen on seeking medical treatment, you might consider the free psychological counseling services provided by the health bureaus in various counties and cities. It's a good idea to talk to a professional psychologist to find solutions. - Dr. Wu En-Liang

[Read More] Understanding and Managing Stress-Induced Hallucinations and Memory Loss


Overcoming Psychological Trauma: Healing Your Mind and Emotions

Hello Dr. Tsai, I have been troubled by the emotional scars from past psychological trauma, which continue to affect my current emotions and thoughts. This has severely impacted my daily life and routines. How can I prevent past injuries from binding my heart and release the pain...


Dr. Cai Qijin reply Psychiatry
Hello, psychological trauma can severely impact daily life. It is important to assess whether the criteria for "Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) or Acute Stress Disorder" are met. Sometimes the symptoms can be quite distressing and cannot be overcome by willpower a...

[Read More] Overcoming Psychological Trauma: Healing Your Mind and Emotions


Understanding Disturbing Thoughts: Coping with Mental Health Struggles

Hello Doctor, I previously inquired about the subsequent developments for someone with PTSD. Due to certain circumstances, my father is no longer coming back, so I temporarily no longer have that concern. A few months have passed since then, and everything seemed normal, but rece...


Dr. Ding Shuyan reply Psychiatry
Hello, when faced with uncontrollable thoughts that keep arising, our first reaction is often to reject them. In fact, while these thoughts may be uncomfortable, it is our interpretation of these thoughts and the subsequent feelings of aversion that increase our suffering. Since ...

[Read More] Understanding Disturbing Thoughts: Coping with Mental Health Struggles


Related FAQ

Ptsd

(Psychiatry)

Amnesia

(Psychiatry)

Nightmares

(Psychiatry)

Fear

(Psychiatry)

Heartbreak

(Psychiatry)

Dissociative Identity Disorder

(Psychiatry)

Neurogenic Shock

(Psychiatry)

Negative Thoughts

(Psychiatry)

Involuntary Psychiatric Treatment

(Psychiatry)

Emotional Instability

(Psychiatry)