Emotional Turmoil: Signs of Personality Disorders in Relationships - Psychiatry

Share to:

Dissociative identity disorder, irritability, depressive mood, apathy?


Hello Dr.
Huang, I have been in a relationship with a girlfriend who is 35 years old for two years now.
During the first year, arguments between us were normal.
However, our relationship has not been good in the past six months; she often threatens to break up after a fight, and I have been trying hard to win her back.
During the reconciliation process (via video calls), there are moments when she loses control, screams, throws her phone, and even seems to transform into a different person, coldly looking at me and saying, "I want to show you how I can commit suicide with a knife," or when I call, she just laughs coldly, or doesn't answer the phone and only communicates through LINE, where she sends nonsensical messages, often saying things like, "I know you want to take revenge on me," "I want to kill this bad woman!!!," "Hahaha, I want to destroy this bad woman!!!," "You better leave, or you will see her die a terrible death," and similar statements (which sound like they are coming from a different person).
Then, when her mood stabilizes a bit, she says, "Please stop pushing me, I'm so scared of her appearing," "Every time she shows up, I am really scared," "She really will kill me," and so on.
She also seems to be thinking about ending her life every day and appears very depressed.
Is it really possible for such a terrifying personality to emerge? How can I help her? She has been in this state for a year now.
Although she broke up with me last month, I still want to win her back.
Or is she just acting to leave me?

shui, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2018/02/02

Dr. Huang Weiqin reply Psychiatry


To the inquiring netizen: Based on your description, your girlfriend may be experiencing mental health issues such as depression, bipolar disorder, or dissociative identity disorder.
It is advisable to have her accompanied by friends or family to a psychiatric (or psychosomatic) outpatient clinic for an evaluation and treatment by a psychiatrist.
If she is willing to accept help, these conditions typically improve gradually with medication or psychotherapy.
Thank you for your question.
Wishing you both peace and health.

Reply Date: 2018/02/02

More Info


It sounds like you are in a very challenging situation with your girlfriend, who is exhibiting signs of significant emotional distress and possibly a personality disorder. Based on your description, her behavior includes extreme emotional reactions, threats of self-harm, and erratic communication patterns, which can be indicative of several underlying psychological issues.


Understanding the Signs
1. Emotional Dysregulation: Your girlfriend's intense emotional responses, such as screaming, throwing her phone, and making threats of self-harm, suggest she may be struggling with emotional regulation. This can be a hallmark of conditions like Borderline Personality Disorder (BPD), where individuals often experience intense emotions and have difficulty managing them.

2. Impulsivity and Threats: The threats of suicide and self-harm are serious and should not be taken lightly. These behaviors can indicate a crisis point in her mental health. It's crucial to understand that when someone expresses a desire to harm themselves, it may be a cry for help rather than a genuine intent to follow through.

3. Disassociation: The way she describes feeling like another person is present ("that she is afraid of") could suggest dissociative symptoms. This can occur in various mental health conditions, including severe trauma responses or personality disorders.

4. Paranoia and Distrust: Statements like "I know you want to get revenge on me" and "I want to kill this bad woman" indicate a level of paranoia or distorted thinking, which can also be associated with certain personality disorders or severe mood disorders.


How to Help
1. Encourage Professional Help: The most important step you can take is to encourage her to seek professional help. A mental health professional can provide a proper diagnosis and treatment plan. If she is resistant, you might suggest that therapy could help her understand and manage her feelings better.

2. Be Supportive but Set Boundaries: While it’s important to be supportive, you also need to protect your own mental health. If her behavior becomes too overwhelming or threatening, it’s okay to set boundaries. Let her know that you care about her but cannot engage in conversations that are harmful or threatening.

3. Emergency Situations: If she threatens to harm herself or others, it is critical to take those threats seriously. You may need to contact emergency services or a crisis hotline for immediate assistance. Safety is the priority.

4. Communicate Openly: When she is calm, try to have an open conversation about her feelings and behaviors. Express your concern without judgment. Use "I" statements to communicate how her actions affect you, such as "I feel scared when you talk about hurting yourself."
5. Educate Yourself: Understanding more about personality disorders and emotional dysregulation can help you empathize with her situation. Resources such as books, articles, or support groups for partners of individuals with mental health issues can provide valuable insights.

6. Consider Couples Therapy: If she is open to it, couples therapy can be a safe space to address relationship dynamics and communication issues. A therapist can help both of you navigate these challenges together.


Conclusion
Your girlfriend's behavior is concerning and suggests that she may be experiencing significant psychological distress. While your desire to help her is commendable, it is essential to recognize the limits of what you can do as a partner. Encouraging her to seek professional help and ensuring your own well-being should be your priorities. Remember, mental health issues are complex, and professional intervention is often necessary for effective treatment.

Similar Q&A

Understanding Emotional Instability: Is It a Personality Disorder?

Dr. Chen: Hello, I often find myself unable to control my emotions and easily lose my temper during arguments with my boyfriend. I tend to say hurtful things, as if that is the only way to express my feelings. However, I regret my words afterward. In contrast, I do not exhibit th...


Dr. Chen Wenke reply Psychiatry
Hello, Xiao Yi. It is generally not easy to directly determine if someone has a personality disorder based solely on your letter. However, the emotional reactions you experience during conflicts with your boyfriend may not necessarily indicate abnormal behavior or a mental illnes...

[Read More] Understanding Emotional Instability: Is It a Personality Disorder?


Understanding Emotional Turmoil: Signs of Mood Disorders in Relationships

Hello, doctor: I have been in a relationship with my boyfriend for over a year, and we have been living together for six months. I tend to struggle with expressing myself, so I often keep my feelings to myself, believing that speaking up won’t change anything. We are together wit...


Dr. Wang Zhenbang reply Psychiatry
Hello, based on your description (the information is insufficient), it is not possible to determine a specific emotional disorder. It may be related to personality traits or simply issues in the interaction between the two individuals. If this situation is causing you distress, i...

[Read More] Understanding Emotional Turmoil: Signs of Mood Disorders in Relationships


Navigating Emotional Crises in Relationships: Seeking Help and Understanding

Hello, doctor. I often face situations where my girlfriend experiences emotional breakdowns, characterized by loud crying, hysterical wall-pounding, gripping her head tightly, crying out that she wants to disappear from the world, followed by difficulty breathing and collapsing t...


Dr. Ding Shuyan reply Psychiatry
Hello, emotional outbursts can stem from various reasons: personality traits, anxiety, high stress levels, or even mental illness. Your girlfriend has a history of mental illness, and it might be beneficial for her to consult a doctor to see if her symptoms of depression or anxie...

[Read More] Navigating Emotional Crises in Relationships: Seeking Help and Understanding


Understanding Changes in Your Partner's Behavior: A Guide for Concerned Partners

My girlfriend used to have a very lively personality. However, since we started dating, I sometimes impose restrictions on her, which has caused her some pressure. She once told me that she felt quite stressed. As our relationship progressed, I gradually imposed fewer restriction...


Dr. Liu Guangqi reply Psychiatry
The process of losing one's temper is often a way to mask underlying anxiety, which stems from stress, and that stress arises from uncertainty about the future. There are many factors to be accountable for this uncertainty regarding the future. Typically, it is important to ...

[Read More] Understanding Changes in Your Partner's Behavior: A Guide for Concerned Partners


Related FAQ

Emotional Instability

(Psychiatry)

Relationships

(Psychiatry)

Neurotic Disorder

(Psychiatry)

Dissociative Identity Disorder

(Psychiatry)

Negative Emotions

(Psychiatry)

Stress

(Psychiatry)

Heartbreak

(Psychiatry)

Psychological Counseling

(Psychiatry)

Family Interaction

(Psychiatry)

Introverted Personality

(Psychiatry)