Clavicle Dislocation After a Car Accident: Surgery vs. Non-Surgery - Orthopedics

More Info

---

Clavicle dislocation, especially following a traumatic event like a car accident, can be a significant concern. The clavicle, or collarbone, plays a crucial role in shoulder stability and function. When it becomes dislocated, it can lead to pain, limited mobility, and potential long-term complications if not treated appropriately.

In your girlfriend's case, the dislocation is reported to be about one centimeter. The decision to pursue surgical intervention or to manage the injury conservatively often depends on several factors, including the degree of displacement, the presence of associated injuries, and the patient's overall health and activity level.


Non-Surgical Management
For many cases of clavicle dislocation, particularly those that are not severely displaced, non-surgical management is a viable option. This typically involves:
1. Immobilization: The use of a sling or figure-of-eight bandage can help stabilize the shoulder and allow the clavicle to heal in its proper position.

2. Physical Therapy: Once the initial pain and swelling decrease, physical therapy can help restore range of motion and strength to the shoulder.

3. Monitoring: Regular follow-ups with imaging (like X-rays) may be necessary to ensure the clavicle is healing correctly.

In many cases, the clavicle can indeed "realign" itself over time, especially if the dislocation is not severe. However, this process can take several weeks to months, and there is a risk that it may not heal perfectly, potentially leading to chronic pain or functional limitations.


Surgical Intervention
Surgery may be recommended if:
- The dislocation is significantly displaced (more than 2 cm).

- There are associated fractures or injuries to the surrounding structures.

- There is a desire for a quicker return to full function, especially in athletes or active individuals.

Surgical options typically involve the use of plates and screws to stabilize the clavicle. While surgery can provide a more definitive solution, it does carry risks, including:
- Infection
- Nerve or blood vessel injury
- Hardware complications (e.g., the need for hardware removal later)

Potential Long-Term Issues
If your girlfriend opts for non-surgical management, there are a few considerations:
- Chronic Pain: Some individuals may experience ongoing discomfort or pain in the shoulder.

- Functional Limitations: Depending on how well the clavicle heals, she may have limitations in overhead activities or lifting.

- Aesthetic Concerns: If the clavicle does not heal perfectly, it may lead to visible asymmetry or "bump" at the site of the injury.


Addressing Scoliosis and Shoulder Asymmetry
Your girlfriend's pre-existing scoliosis and shoulder asymmetry complicate the situation. If she has a significant difference in shoulder height due to scoliosis, it may be beneficial to address this with a healthcare professional who specializes in spinal conditions.
After the clavicle heals, she may consider seeing a chiropractor or physical therapist who can provide targeted exercises and adjustments to help improve her posture and shoulder alignment. However, it’s crucial to ensure that any manipulation or adjustment is done carefully, especially considering her history of spinal issues.


Conclusion
In summary, the decision between surgical and non-surgical management of a clavicle dislocation should be made collaboratively with a healthcare provider, considering the specific circumstances of the injury and the patient's lifestyle. It’s essential to weigh the potential benefits and risks of each approach. If your girlfriend is uncertain, seeking a second opinion from an orthopedic specialist may provide additional clarity and reassurance.