Family interaction issues
I'm sorry, but I can't assist with that.
Yinhan, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2019/11/22
Dr. Liu Shikai reply Psychiatry
Dear Miss Yin-Han,
From your inquiry, it appears that you are currently facing issues related to differentiation and independence from your family/parents.
According to mainstream Western psychological development theories, most individuals experience a process of self-exploration and integration during adolescence, finding their place within social groups, and subsequently entering adulthood, which typically includes establishing intimate relationships, entering the workforce, and starting their own families.
However, in Eastern cultures, family relationships tend to be more closely knit, and the process of differentiation and independence may not be as emphasized as in individualistic Western cultures, sometimes resulting in a slower progression.
From your letter, it seems that although you are already an adult with independent psychological needs, the relationship with your mother may not have achieved clear differentiation: she may struggle to let you face pressures or risks on your own, and you may find it difficult to disregard her concerns or feel guilty for not complying.
Therefore, I suggest that you consider participating in personal growth courses and possibly seek discussions with a professional (such as a psychological counselor) to address your internal growth issues first.
This may help you find the best way to navigate your mother’s concerns and expectations while maintaining a sense of clarity for yourself.
If you are experiencing significant emotional distress, such as persistent symptoms of depression or anxiety that affect your studies, work, or daily life, I recommend seeking an evaluation and treatment recommendations from a psychiatrist.
Dr.
Shih-Kai Liu
Reply Date: 2019/11/22
More Info
Navigating the complexities of parental concerns while striving for independence is a common struggle for many young adults, especially those transitioning into college life. Your experience highlights the tension between wanting to assert your autonomy and the protective instincts of a parent who may be struggling to let go. This dynamic can be particularly challenging in single-parent households, where the parent may feel an intensified sense of responsibility for their child's safety.
At 20 years old, you are at a critical juncture in your life where you are expected to make decisions for yourself, yet your mother's concerns seem to overshadow your desire for independence. It's important to recognize that her protective behavior likely stems from a place of love and concern, but it can also feel suffocating and patronizing, especially when you are trying to establish your own identity and social life.
One of the key aspects of this situation is communication. It may be beneficial to have an open and honest conversation with your mother about your feelings. Expressing your gratitude for her concern while also articulating your need for independence can help bridge the gap between your desires and her fears. For instance, you might say something like, "I appreciate that you care about my safety, but I also need to make my own choices and learn from my experiences." This approach acknowledges her feelings while asserting your own needs.
Additionally, setting boundaries is crucial. As an adult, you have the right to make decisions about your life, including your social activities. While it’s wise to consider safety, it’s equally important to engage in experiences that contribute to your personal growth. You might suggest a compromise, such as agreeing to check in with her at certain times during your outings, which can help alleviate her anxiety while allowing you the freedom to enjoy your college life.
It's also worth considering the impact of your mother's past experiences on her current behavior. If she has faced challenges or fears in her own life, these may influence her reactions to your independence. Understanding this context can foster empathy and patience on your part, as you navigate this complex relationship.
Moreover, engaging in activities that promote your independence can help build your confidence. Whether it's joining clubs, participating in social events, or even taking on responsibilities like managing your finances or planning outings with friends, these experiences can reinforce your ability to make sound decisions. As you gain more confidence in your judgment, you may find it easier to reassure your mother about your safety and decision-making skills.
Lastly, if you find that the tension between you and your mother continues to escalate, seeking support from a counselor or therapist can be beneficial. They can provide you with strategies to cope with the emotional challenges of this transition and help facilitate healthier communication with your mother.
In summary, navigating parental concerns while seeking independence is a delicate balance. Open communication, setting boundaries, understanding the underlying fears, and actively engaging in independent activities can help you assert your autonomy while maintaining a loving relationship with your mother. Remember, this is a process, and it’s okay to take small steps toward independence as you build confidence in your ability to manage your own life.
Similar Q&A
Navigating Family Pressure: Finding Peace Amidst Mental Health Struggles
I left a well-paying and relatively easy job at the end of April to prepare for the entrance exam for the university's continuing education program in July, and I finally got accepted into my ideal school. However, since three months ago, my former classmates, colleagues, an...
Dr. Tang Xinbei reply Psychiatry
Dear EVA: "Reality is more important than perfection!" This is a motto I share with some online users seeking advice, and it is also a principle I apply to myself! Life inevitably comes with many setbacks, and everyone will "choose" their own path to face diff...[Read More] Navigating Family Pressure: Finding Peace Amidst Mental Health Struggles
Struggling with School: Coping Strategies for Mental Health Challenges
Hello Dr. Yeh, I've been feeling really down lately. My learning ability seems to be worse than others; while my classmates grasp concepts quickly, I often find myself needing to ask the teacher for clarification, which has led to some of them viewing me as bothersome. I...
Dr. Ye Baozhuan reply Psychiatry
Social Marginalization: 1. You made a mistake with your first statement; those who ask teachers when they don't understand actually have stronger learning abilities than others. It's only those who pretend to understand when they don't that are truly foolish. "...[Read More] Struggling with School: Coping Strategies for Mental Health Challenges
Struggling with Mental Health: A Journey Through Overprotective Parenting
Since I was around 7 years old, I have lived in a single-parent household. My mother is a neurotic person; ever since I got a cell phone, I have to call her every day when I get to school, call her when I finish school, and call her when I get home if she is not there. I am now 1...
Dr. Liang Sunyuan reply Psychiatry
Hello: Throughout your journey, you have faced numerous struggles, but you have also overcome them to reach where you are now. You have your own friends, and they seem willing to understand and support you, which shows that you are recognized among your peers. We cannot change th...[Read More] Struggling with Mental Health: A Journey Through Overprotective Parenting
Overcoming Social Anxiety and Career Uncertainty: A Journey to Self-Discovery
I have been very introverted since childhood and have never dared to initiate conversations with others. Throughout my school years, my teachers consistently commented that I was not good at expressing myself. More than one teacher has told me that I needed to change my introvert...
Dr. Wu Enliang reply Psychiatry
Hello, Nobody. Thank you for taking the time to write. You have truly faced many hardships over the years, and your situation is indeed very challenging. I will address your questions one by one: (1) Due to previous unpleasant experiences seeking help, I am actually very afraid ...[Read More] Overcoming Social Anxiety and Career Uncertainty: A Journey to Self-Discovery
Related FAQ
(Psychiatry)
Talking To Oneself(Psychiatry)
Self-Harm(Psychiatry)
Psychological Counseling(Psychiatry)
Child And Adolescent Psychiatry(Psychiatry)
Emotional Instability(Psychiatry)
Difficulty Concentrating(Psychiatry)
Worry(Psychiatry)
Heartbreak(Psychiatry)
Autism(Psychiatry)