I would like to ask if low-frequency wave devices truly have therapeutic effects in medicine?
My mother has been experiencing weakness in her legs since a car accident two years ago.
Recently, she has been visiting a store that offers free trials of a low-frequency wave device (Wave X Health) every day.
According to her, this device is different from regular electrotherapy and has miraculous effects, such as stimulating deep cellular regeneration, and there are even reports of patients recovering facial nerve function.
Ultimately, she purchased a low-frequency wave device for over NT$100,000 to use at home.
I would like to inquire: Based on my understanding, low-frequency waves primarily help relieve pain.
Are there any medical studies that indicate low-frequency waves have other therapeutic effects? The company's website only claims to reduce pain, which does not seem to violate any medical regulations.
I have seen similar products on the market priced around a few thousand NT dollars.
What should we pay attention to when selecting a low-frequency wave device for our loved ones?
mbkbn, 30~39 year old female. Ask Date: 2020/04/01
Dr. Yin Xinbei reply Rehabilitation
Low-frequency devices (Transcutaneous Electrical Nerve Stimulation, TENS) are used in medicine to alleviate pain.
By adjusting the frequency and intensity, they can also improve peripheral nerve paralysis, prevent muscle atrophy, and promote blood circulation.
However, there is no evidence to support claims of stimulating cell regeneration.
If exaggerated claims of efficacy can be substantiated, they should be reported to the Ministry of Health and Welfare's Food and Drug Administration.
For considerations when purchasing low-frequency devices, please refer to https://www.mohw.gov.tw/cp-2632-14701-1.html.
Reply Date: 2020/04/01
More Info
Low-frequency devices, often referred to as transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation (TENS) units, have gained popularity in rehabilitation settings for their purported benefits in pain relief and muscle stimulation. However, it is essential to approach the claims surrounding these devices with a critical eye, particularly when it comes to their effectiveness beyond pain management.
The primary function of low-frequency devices is indeed to alleviate pain. They work by delivering electrical impulses through the skin, which can help to block pain signals from reaching the brain and stimulate the release of endorphins, the body's natural painkillers. This mechanism has been supported by various studies, indicating that TENS can be effective for managing acute and chronic pain conditions, such as arthritis, back pain, and postoperative discomfort.
However, the claims that low-frequency devices can stimulate deep cellular regeneration or significantly improve conditions like nerve recovery are less substantiated in the scientific literature. While some studies suggest that electrical stimulation can promote tissue healing and improve blood circulation, the evidence is not robust enough to support claims of miraculous recovery or cellular regeneration. It is crucial to differentiate between anecdotal reports and scientifically validated outcomes. If a device or treatment claims to have extraordinary effects, it is advisable to seek peer-reviewed studies or clinical trials that support such claims.
When considering the purchase of a low-frequency device, especially one that is marketed with extraordinary claims, there are several factors to keep in mind:
1. Clinical Evidence: Look for devices that have been studied in clinical trials. Check if the manufacturer provides references to scientific research that supports their claims. Be wary of devices that lack substantial evidence or rely heavily on testimonials.
2. Regulatory Approval: Ensure that the device has been approved by relevant health authorities, such as the FDA in the United States or similar organizations in other countries. This approval indicates that the device has met certain safety and efficacy standards.
3. User Experience: Consider the experiences of other users, but remember that individual results can vary widely. What works for one person may not work for another, and personal testimonials should not replace scientific evidence.
4. Consult Healthcare Professionals: Before purchasing a device, consult with a healthcare provider, such as a physical therapist or a physician. They can provide guidance on whether such a device is appropriate for your mother's specific condition and needs.
5. Cost vs. Benefit: Evaluate whether the potential benefits of the device justify its cost. Many low-frequency devices are available at various price points, and more expensive does not always mean better.
6. Alternative Treatments: Consider other rehabilitation options that may be more effective or have a stronger evidence base, such as physical therapy, occupational therapy, or other modalities like ultrasound or laser therapy.
In summary, while low-frequency devices can be beneficial for pain relief, their claims of promoting deep cellular regeneration and miraculous recoveries should be approached with skepticism. It is essential to rely on scientific evidence and professional advice when considering such treatments. Your mother's health and well-being should always be the priority, and informed decisions based on credible information will lead to better outcomes in her rehabilitation journey.
Similar Q&A
Are Long Wave Magnetic Devices Beneficial for Low Blood Pressure?
Hello, Doctor: Recently, I encountered a product being sold called the "Ultra Long Wave Magnetic Health Device." I have low blood pressure, and the salesperson told me that "ultra long waves" are very beneficial for the human body, claiming that after four mon...
Dr. Wang Fangli reply Internal Medicine
Hello, Mimi: I'm not familiar with long-wave therapy. If you have chronic low blood pressure, it's best to get checked at a major hospital. Internal Medicine, Dr. Wang Fangli.[Read More] Are Long Wave Magnetic Devices Beneficial for Low Blood Pressure?
Magnetic Field Therapy: Who Can Benefit from This Rehabilitation Treatment?
Dear Expert: What types of rehabilitation patients can benefit from magnetic field therapy? Can my mother, who experiences soreness in her limbs, lower back pain, and difficulty sleeping, use this treatment? Thank you for your response!
Dr. Chen Xianchang reply Rehabilitation
Ms. Midi: Here are my responses to your questions and suggestions: 1. If general electrical therapy and heat therapy do not improve soreness, consider magnetic field therapy. 2. The magnetic field can adjust the treatment frequency; low frequency is suitable for treating insomnia...[Read More] Magnetic Field Therapy: Who Can Benefit from This Rehabilitation Treatment?
Post-Surgery Rehabilitation for Femoral Neck Fractures: Key Considerations
Two years ago, my mother suffered a femoral neck fracture in her right leg. Although she has recovered, her postoperative rehabilitation was not very effective, resulting in a noticeable limp and difficulty walking. If she wants to use a medium-frequency electrotherapy machine to...
Dr. Wang Zhaomin reply Rehabilitation
General home electrotherapy devices do not adversely affect internal fixation devices, but this may vary by model. Please refer to the user manual for specific instructions. Pay attention to the condition of the skin; do not use the device if there are wounds or infections. Avoid...[Read More] Post-Surgery Rehabilitation for Femoral Neck Fractures: Key Considerations
Improving Sleep Quality: Rehabilitation Solutions for Sleep Disorders
Dear Dr. Chen, Since getting older, I have been very troubled by my sleep issues. I am hesitant to take sedatives because I worry that it will only worsen my condition. I am sensitive to light, noise, and any sound can affect my mood. Sometimes, even after finally falling asleep...
Dr. Chen Xianchang reply Rehabilitation
(1) Simple stretching exercises can be performed before bedtime, focusing on gentle stretches for the neck and lower back. (2) Drinking a glass of milk before bed can help stabilize mood. (3) Rehabilitation may include magnetic field therapy, which can be beneficial for insomnia.[Read More] Improving Sleep Quality: Rehabilitation Solutions for Sleep Disorders
Related FAQ
(Rehabilitation)
Electromyography(Rehabilitation)
Lower Back(Rehabilitation)
Ultrasound Therapy(Rehabilitation)
Family Medicine(Rehabilitation)
Falls(Rehabilitation)
Sleep(Rehabilitation)
Leg(Rehabilitation)
Flat Feet(Rehabilitation)
Wrist(Rehabilitation)