Flatfoot X-ray imaging issues?
A few days ago, I went to the hospital to get an X-ray of my foot to confirm a flatfoot issue.
The radiologist placed a wooden box for me to stand on and asked me to keep the side of my little toe pressed against a side panel while standing on one foot to take the X-ray.
However, during the process, in an attempt to maintain my balance (with my center of gravity shifting outward), I arched the bottom of my foot (with my little toe curling inward and my big toe lifting up), so the sole of my foot did not fully contact the surface.
Instead, it appeared tense and in a backward C shape to maintain balance.
I would like to know if this positioning would affect the assessment of the arch angle in determining flatfoot.
Jian, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2024/03/14
Dr. Chen Yongxue reply Orthopedics
This still needs to be evaluated based on the actual imaging results and the physician's judgment.
Thank you.
Reply Date: 2024/03/14
More Info
The positioning of the foot during an X-ray examination can significantly impact the assessment of the arch angle in flatfoot (pes planus) evaluations. When assessing flatfoot, the arch angle is typically measured using lateral X-ray images of the foot. The angle is determined by the intersection of lines drawn from the heel bone (calcaneus) to the first metatarsal bone and the line along the surface of the foot.
In your case, standing on one foot while trying to maintain balance can lead to an altered foot position, which may not accurately reflect the natural arch of your foot. If your foot is not fully flat against the imaging surface—due to the arch being raised or the toes being positioned in a way that alters the foot's natural alignment—this can lead to a misleading representation of the arch angle. The "C" shape you described, where the small toe side is pulled inward and the big toe side is elevated, indicates that the foot is not in a neutral position. This misalignment can result in an inaccurate measurement of the arch angle, potentially leading to an incorrect diagnosis of the severity of flatfoot.
Moreover, the interpretation of X-ray images is highly dependent on the radiologist's expertise and the quality of the imaging technique used. If the foot is not positioned correctly, the radiologist may misinterpret the results, which could affect treatment recommendations. For instance, if the arch angle appears less severe due to the altered positioning, it may lead to a conservative treatment approach when a more aggressive intervention might be necessary.
In clinical practice, it is crucial to ensure that the foot is positioned correctly during imaging to obtain accurate measurements. This often involves instructing the patient on how to stand properly, ensuring that the foot is flat and that the weight is evenly distributed. In some cases, additional imaging techniques, such as weight-bearing X-rays or 3D imaging, may be employed to provide a more comprehensive view of the foot's structure and function.
If you have concerns about the accuracy of your X-ray results, it is advisable to discuss this with your healthcare provider. They may recommend a repeat X-ray with proper positioning or additional assessments to ensure an accurate diagnosis. Understanding the implications of foot positioning during X-ray imaging is essential for effective management and treatment of flatfoot and related conditions.
In summary, the way your foot was positioned during the X-ray can indeed affect the assessment of the arch angle. Proper positioning is critical for accurate diagnosis and treatment planning. If you suspect that your X-ray results may not accurately reflect your condition due to the positioning, it would be prudent to seek further evaluation.
Similar Q&A
Understanding Flat Feet: Diagnosis and Treatment Options
Several months ago, I learned from the Department of Health's website that flat feet should be evaluated by a rehabilitation specialist. Therefore, I went to Keelung Chang Gung Memorial Hospital to see a rehabilitation physician. Initially, I consulted Dr. Hsu Chih-Chin, who...
Dr. Chen Xianchang reply Rehabilitation
Hello, sir: Thank you for your inquiry. Here are my responses and suggestions: 1. Generally speaking, the measurement of flatfoot angles is primarily done using X-rays (lateral view of the foot). The measurement is determined by the angle formed between the line connecting the ...[Read More] Understanding Flat Feet: Diagnosis and Treatment Options
Understanding Flatfoot: The Impact of 150 vs. 165 Degrees in Orthopedics
Hello, doctor: I would like to ask, is there a significant difference between a flat foot curvature of 150 and 165? How is this measured? If someone is currently active and has just been measured this year, can they be re-evaluated next year?
Dr. Shi Qiming reply Orthopedics
Hello, Xiao Qiao: The measurement of the arch angle in flatfoot is performed by having the subject stand for a lateral X-ray. The arch angle is defined as the angle formed by the line connecting the inferior edge of the fifth metatarsal and the inferior edge of the calcaneus. Acc...[Read More] Understanding Flatfoot: The Impact of 150 vs. 165 Degrees in Orthopedics
Understanding Flat Feet and Related Orthopedic Concerns
Hello Dr. Li, 1. I would like to ask if the measurement of the arch in flat feet can vary due to the physician's technique (such as drawing lines). Additionally, can both standing X-rays and lateral X-rays be used to assess the arch? During a previous health check, my arch ...
Dr. Li Wenlin reply Orthopedics
Hello, Lai: 1. Indeed, there are many factors that can affect the interpretation, but there is a standardized method for taking X-rays of flat feet. Public hospitals (those involved in military service physical examinations) tend to be more reliable. However, the standard for t...[Read More] Understanding Flat Feet and Related Orthopedic Concerns
How to Correct Prominent Foot Bones for a Narrower Foot Appearance
If the bones in your feet are protruding (specifically under the big toe on the inner side of both feet), resulting in a wide foot structure, is there a way to improve this condition? Thank you!
Dr. Luo Qihua reply Plastic Surgery
Hello: An X-ray examination must be performed first to assess the alignment of the toe bones and metatarsals, as well as the angles between adjacent toe bones and metatarsals. Further discussions on treatment options will follow, and if necessary, surgical intervention such as os...[Read More] How to Correct Prominent Foot Bones for a Narrower Foot Appearance
Related FAQ
(Orthopedics)
Hallux Varus(Orthopedics)
Plantar Fasciitis(Orthopedics)
Toe(Orthopedics)
Flat Feet(Rehabilitation)
Metatarsal Fracture(Orthopedics)
Dorsal Foot Pain(Orthopedics)
O-Shaped Legs(Orthopedics)
Dislocation(Orthopedics)
Foot Numbness(Orthopedics)