Regarding health foods?
Recently, the adults in my household have become obsessed with a series of products that resemble health foods.
I checked online and found that they are not registered as health foods.
I have advised my parents not to consume unverified health products, but they seem to be infatuated, purchasing hundreds of thousands of dollars' worth of these products.
They consume them themselves and promote them to friends, even feeding them to my daughter who is not yet one year old.
They claim that these products are healthy and beneficial with no adverse effects, pointing to the label that states it is approved by the Department of Health, insisting that it is legitimate.
The company is a multi-level marketing (MLM) organization, encouraging members to recruit others to join and purchase products.
Their advertisements and website do not mention any therapeutic effects, yet during member recruitment, they promote the products as highly effective, claiming that those with ailments will naturally recover after consuming them.
Are these products truly beneficial for health? Below is the website of the company: http://www.ghkbio.com.tw/package/product.asp
Qing Shuo, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2004/03/02
Dr. Hou Fangmin reply Pharmacology
Hello: Regarding the issue of health supplements, I often receive inquiries about various health products.
My response is that without a physician's diagnosis, taking medications indiscriminately will only increase the burden on the liver and kidneys, potentially causing adverse effects on the body.
We have seen cases in our hospital where individuals have taken unknown medications, leading to the need for dialysis.
Therefore, it is crucial to be very cautious with medications.
Generally, one should check for the label indicating approval from the health authority.
If there are any uncertainties, it is advisable to contact the health department for clarification.
Concerning your mention of children taking medications, this requires extra caution, as children's liver and kidney functions are not fully developed, which can lead to poor metabolism of drugs and accumulation in their bodies.
Thus, extreme care is necessary.
Reply Date: 2004/03/02
More Info
When it comes to health supplements, the safety and efficacy of these products can often be a source of confusion and concern. Your situation highlights a common issue where individuals, including your family members, may be drawn to health supplements that are not properly registered or regulated. This can lead to potential health risks, especially when these products are marketed aggressively, often with misleading claims about their benefits.
First and foremost, it is crucial to understand that not all health supplements are created equal. In the United States, the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) does not regulate dietary supplements as strictly as it does pharmaceuticals. This means that manufacturers are not required to prove the safety or efficacy of their products before they are marketed. As a result, some supplements may contain harmful ingredients, may not contain the ingredients they claim, or may not be manufactured under safe conditions.
In your case, the fact that the health supplements your family members are consuming do not have an official health food registration number raises a red flag. Without proper registration, there is no guarantee that these products have been evaluated for safety or efficacy. It's important to be cautious, especially when it comes to products that claim to have health benefits without scientific backing.
Moreover, the marketing strategies employed by multi-level marketing (MLM) companies can be particularly concerning. These companies often rely on personal testimonials rather than scientific evidence to promote their products. While some individuals may report positive experiences, these anecdotes do not constitute reliable evidence of effectiveness. The pressure to recruit others into the business can also lead to a cycle of misinformation, where the focus shifts from product safety to profit.
When it comes to your one-year-old daughter, it is especially critical to be vigilant. Infants and young children have different nutritional needs and may be more susceptible to adverse effects from unregulated supplements. The immune system of a child is still developing, and introducing unverified products can pose unnecessary risks.
To ensure safety, consider the following steps:
1. Research the Product: Look for any available scientific studies or reviews regarding the specific health supplement. Check if it has been tested for safety and efficacy by reputable organizations.
2. Consult Healthcare Professionals: Speak with a pediatrician or a registered dietitian before introducing any supplements to your child's diet. They can provide guidance based on evidence-based practices.
3. Report Concerns: If you suspect that the products are harmful or misleading, consider reporting them to the FDA or your local health department. They can investigate and take appropriate action if necessary.
4. Educate Your Family: Share information about the importance of using only registered and scientifically backed health products. Encourage them to be skeptical of claims that sound too good to be true.
5. Seek Alternatives: Instead of relying on supplements, focus on a balanced diet rich in fruits, vegetables, whole grains, and lean proteins. This is often the best way to ensure adequate nutrition and support overall health.
In conclusion, while some health supplements can be beneficial, it is essential to approach them with caution, especially when they lack proper regulation and scientific backing. The safety of your family, particularly your young child, should always be the top priority. By taking proactive steps to verify the safety and efficacy of health products, you can help protect your loved ones from potential harm.
Similar Q&A
Do Health Supplements Really Have Therapeutic Effects?
Hello, a friend mentioned that taking health supplements can cause reactions, such as itching of the scalp or rashes on the skin, indicating that there might be an issue with that part of the body. Is this correct? Can foods have such therapeutic effects? If I want to send someth...
Dr. Shi Guimei reply Nutrition
Hello! I do not agree that taking health supplements can lead to adverse reactions. Health supplements must be approved by the Department of Health before they can make any claims. The Department of Health's "Food Information Network" website publishes a list of ap...[Read More] Do Health Supplements Really Have Therapeutic Effects?
Are There Side Effects from Mixing Health Supplements?
Hello, doctor! I usually take various health supplements, including grape seed extract, soy isoflavones, collagen, seal oil, spirulina, cranberry, and vitamin B complex. I would like to ask if there are any interactions or contraindications among these supplements. What precautio...
Dr. Lai Hexian reply Family Medicine
Hello, the item you mentioned is classified as a "food," which means that the health authorities in the country have determined it is not a drug. This implies that it should not cause interactions similar to those associated with medications. Therefore, the remaining co...[Read More] Are There Side Effects from Mixing Health Supplements?
Are Plant-Based Supplements from Cheng Yan International Trustworthy?
Hello, doctor. Recently, an elder in my family purchased nutritional supplements from Cheng Yan International. This company claims that their products are made from pure plant ingredients, beneficial for the body, and can enhance immunity, even stating that doctors are consuming ...
Dr. Shi Guimei reply Nutrition
Dear Ms. Chang, Hello! Although Cheng Yan International's products claim to be made from pure plant ingredients, they are not approved by the Ministry of Health and Welfare as special nutritional foods and can only be classified as food. The Ministry of Health and Welfare p...[Read More] Are Plant-Based Supplements from Cheng Yan International Trustworthy?
Understanding the Safe Dosage of Dietary Supplements: Expert Insights
Hello, Doctor. There are many health supplement stores appearing in the market. I have been using Herbalife for a year, following my coach's instructions to take a large amount of vitamins, fish oil, krill oil, and effervescent tablets daily. Recently, I saw in online news t...
Dr. Shi Guimei reply Nutrition
Dear yt.chan, Hello! At your age, a balanced diet is sufficient, and there is no need to supplement with the health products you mentioned, especially since you indicated that you consume them in large quantities, which could potentially pose health risks. In Taiwan, health food...[Read More] Understanding the Safe Dosage of Dietary Supplements: Expert Insights
Related FAQ
(Pharmacology)
Medication Safety(Pharmacology)
Contraceptive Pills(Pharmacology)
Health Supplements(Pediatrics)
Health Supplements(Internal Medicine)
Health Supplements(Family Medicine)
Weight Loss Products(Pharmacology)
Dietary Supplements(Orthopedics)
Health Supplements(Traditional Chinese Medicine)
Health Supplements(Obstetrics and Gynecology)