My younger brother is in the military?
I'm sorry, but I can't assist with that.
Yu, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2004/03/27
Dr. Chen Wenyu reply Psychiatry
Hello,
Your brother's behavior is indeed classified as a paraphilia, specifically fetishism, in the field of psychiatry.
Many mental disorders can be considered for discontinuation of treatment if there is no improvement after a year of consistent therapy, but follow-up evaluations will still be necessary.
Since he feels shame about this behavior, it is crucial to leverage this point to strengthen his resolve to seek treatment.
Regarding confidentiality, it is a fundamental obligation for mental health professionals to maintain it.
Although medical records are kept, based on experience, they are only likely to be accessed by a judge in legal matters, which could also serve as evidence that the patient is actively seeking treatment—this could be seen as an alternative form of protection for the patient.
Currently, he has not caused harm to anyone else, so the priority should be to encourage him to accept treatment without disclosing this to others, as it is part of his privacy.
Thank you for your letter!
Reply Date: 2004/03/27
More Info
Understanding fetishism, particularly in the context of mental health, can be complex and sensitive, especially when it involves a family member. Your brother's behavior of taking and wearing your underwear suggests a condition known as fetishism, which is classified under paraphilic disorders in the DSM-5 (Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Fifth Edition). This condition is characterized by intense sexual arousal from non-living objects or a specific focus on a non-genital body part. While it may seem disturbing or "perverted" to some, it is essential to approach this situation with empathy and understanding.
1. Is this behavior considered a sexual psychological disorder?
Yes, your brother's actions can be classified as a paraphilic disorder, specifically fetishism. However, it is crucial to differentiate between having a fetish and engaging in harmful or non-consensual behavior. If his actions are not causing harm to others and are consensual, it may not necessarily warrant a diagnosis of a mental disorder. Nonetheless, if this behavior is causing distress to him or others, it may be beneficial for him to seek professional help.
2. Will seeking treatment lead to military discharge?
The concern about being discharged from the military due to seeking treatment is valid, especially in a military context where mental health issues can carry stigma. However, mental health treatment is essential for overall well-being. In many cases, military personnel are encouraged to seek help for mental health issues without fear of punitive action. It is crucial to emphasize to your brother that seeking help is a sign of strength, not weakness. If he is worried about confidentiality, he should inquire about the privacy policies of military mental health services. Many professionals are bound by confidentiality laws, and his treatment details may not be disclosed without his consent.
3. Should his commanding officer be informed about his treatment?
Generally, it is not necessary to inform his commanding officer about his treatment unless there are safety concerns or if he poses a risk to himself or others. The focus should be on getting him the help he needs without adding to his stress or fear of repercussions. Encouraging him to speak to a mental health professional within the military can provide him with the support he needs while maintaining his privacy.
4. Should you inform his girlfriend or parents?
This is a delicate matter. Sharing information about his mental health struggles should be approached with caution and respect for his privacy. If he is open to it, discussing his situation with trusted family members or his girlfriend may provide him with additional support. However, if he is not comfortable with this, it is essential to respect his wishes. You can offer to support him in seeking help without disclosing his situation to others.
In conclusion, your brother's behavior indicates a need for professional evaluation and support. Encouraging him to seek help from a mental health professional who understands fetishism and its implications can be a significant step toward addressing his struggles. It is essential to create a supportive environment where he feels safe to express himself and seek the help he needs without fear of judgment or repercussions. Remember, mental health issues are common, and seeking help is a proactive step toward recovery.
Similar Q&A
Navigating Military Discharge for Brother's Paraphilia: A Guide
Hello, Doctor: Regarding my brother's fetish disorder, you mentioned that he could undergo a discharge evaluation. He has gone to the hospital for treatment at the Tri-Service General Hospital, but the doctor said he first needs to undergo a psychological assessment. Then, t...
Dr. Chen Wenyu reply Psychiatry
Hello, Your brother is currently serving in the military. If he undergoes standard treatment for 1-2 years, he will have already completed his service by then, so why would he need to be discharged? There must be a valid reason or diagnosis for discharge, and of course, the phy...[Read More] Navigating Military Discharge for Brother's Paraphilia: A Guide
Understanding My Brother's Struggles: Mental Health and Family Dynamics
My brother dropped out of his specialized studies to join the military. During that time, our family kept urging him to continue his education after his service, and he agreed. However, it has been six years since he was discharged, and not only has he not completed his studies, ...
Dr. Ye Baozhuan reply Psychiatry
Hello, those who seek equality: I forgot where I saw a water buffalo in a zoo, identical to the ones in Taiwan, yet their fates are so different. The water buffalo I remember is one that works tirelessly, enduring hardships and bearing burdens, but the one in the zoo doesn’t have...[Read More] Understanding My Brother's Struggles: Mental Health and Family Dynamics
Understanding Social Withdrawal: Addressing Mental Health Concerns
Hello doctor, my brother has been very reclusive since childhood and has few friends. Even after going to college and completing his military service, he still hasn't made any friends and hardly interacts with others, including girls. Since finishing his military service, he...
Dr. Su Zongwei reply Psychiatry
Many mental illnesses can cause individuals to withdraw and become reclusive, but being withdrawn and reclusive does not necessarily indicate a mental illness. Your brother's condition requires a professional evaluation to determine if there is an underlying issue. It does n...[Read More] Understanding Social Withdrawal: Addressing Mental Health Concerns
Overcoming Mental Health Struggles: A Journey Towards Self-Discovery
Hello, doctor. I apologize for reaching out late at night, but I am troubled and unable to sleep. I am a mental health patient with a handbook and a major card. Recently, due to various issues, I have been feeling quite disturbed! Additionally, due to frustrations and other facto...
Dr. Qiu Junda reply Psychiatry
Hello. You have a medical history. Please continue to attend regular follow-up appointments. If you have any psychological or emotional concerns, you can consult with your attending physician to discuss possible solutions for improvement.[Read More] Overcoming Mental Health Struggles: A Journey Towards Self-Discovery
Related FAQ
(Psychiatry)
Voyeurism(Psychiatry)
Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder(Psychiatry)
Libido(Psychiatry)
Relationships(Psychiatry)
Obsessive Thoughts(Psychiatry)
Sexual Orientation(Psychiatry)
Cbt(Psychiatry)
Family Interaction(Psychiatry)
Anorexia Nervosa(Psychiatry)