Navigating Military Discharge for Brother's Paraphilia: A Guide

My younger brother is serving in the military?

Hello, Doctor: Regarding my brother's fetish disorder, you mentioned that he could undergo a discharge evaluation.
He has gone to the hospital for treatment at the Tri-Service General Hospital, but the doctor said he first needs to undergo a psychological assessment.
Then, the commanding officer from his unit needs to come to the hospital for some discussions, which seems very complicated and time-consuming.
I would like to ask you about this.
The psychological assessment takes a long time, and besides the Tri-Service General Hospital, which other hospitals can conduct this assessment? When I asked the doctor at Tri-Service about the discharge procedure, he didn't provide much information, only saying to wait until the psychological assessment is completed.
However, this waiting period is taking a long time, and the doctor seems indifferent, just prescribing medication and saying to come back for the next appointment.
So, I would like to know how the discharge evaluation process works and how to proceed with it.
Will it be very complicated? Is there any way to simplify it?

Yu, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2004/04/30

Dr. Chen Wenyu reply Psychiatry

Hello,
Your brother is currently serving in the military.
If he undergoes standard treatment for 1-2 years, he will have already completed his service by then, so why would he need to be discharged? There must be a valid reason or diagnosis for discharge, and of course, the physician will document the facts.
During the treatment process, how can one guarantee to keep this matter completely confidential? In the military, information must be reported through various channels, and a mental health officer must assist the medical facility in providing support.
The commanding officer, out of camaraderie, must also monitor his behavior both in the military and during leave, so eventually, everyone will know, understand? The reason for discharge will inevitably be sent to the local government office, and then many people will be aware of it.
Now that we have health insurance, he can seek treatment at a civilian hospital and inform them that he is currently serving in the military, ensuring that his privacy is maintained.
This should not be a problem.
Your brother's focus should be on treatment rather than discharge.
As for fetishism, as long as it does not violate the law, there is no reason he cannot serve.
If he breaks the law, then it would be subject to military justice.
Furthermore, if your brother immediately expresses a desire to be discharged, the physician must consider the possibility of malingering, given the military's measures against fraud.
Additionally, issues in this regard are often based solely on the patient's statements, so data collection must be approached with caution.
If you were the physician dealing with potential military legal issues, would you not be careful?
In conclusion, it is most important for him to seek treatment at a civilian hospital and focus on getting better.
It is fundamentally impossible to arrange for discharge while keeping it a secret from others.
Thank you for your message!

Reply Date: 2004/04/30

More Info

Navigating the military discharge process for a brother with paraphilia can be complex and often requires careful attention to both medical and administrative procedures. Paraphilia, which refers to atypical sexual interests that may cause distress or impairment, can significantly impact an individual's ability to serve in the military. Here’s a guide to help you understand the process and what steps you can take to facilitate your brother's discharge.

Understanding the Discharge Process
1. Initial Evaluation: The first step in the discharge process is obtaining a thorough psychological evaluation. This is crucial as it provides a formal diagnosis and assesses the severity of your brother's condition. The evaluation typically includes interviews, psychological testing, and a review of his medical history.

2. Choosing the Right Facility: While you mentioned that your brother is receiving treatment at a military hospital (三總), it’s important to know that other facilities may also conduct psychological evaluations. You can consider civilian hospitals or specialized mental health clinics that are recognized by the military. It may be beneficial to consult with the military's medical liaison or a mental health professional for recommendations on accredited facilities.

3. Documentation: After the psychological evaluation, the results will need to be documented. This documentation is essential for the discharge process. It should include the diagnosis, treatment recommendations, and any prescribed medications. Ensure that your brother keeps copies of all medical records and correspondence with healthcare providers.

4. Command Involvement: The military command will need to be involved in the discharge process. This typically involves a meeting between the healthcare provider and the commanding officer to discuss the findings of the psychological evaluation. Your brother may need to provide consent for this communication.

5. Application for Discharge: Once the evaluation is complete and the necessary documentation is in place, an application for discharge can be submitted. This application should clearly outline the reasons for discharge, supported by medical evidence. It may also be beneficial to include a treatment plan or recommendations for ongoing care.

Potential Challenges
- Waiting Times: As you mentioned, waiting for psychological evaluations can be lengthy. Unfortunately, this is often a common issue in military healthcare systems. To expedite the process, encourage your brother to remain proactive in following up with his healthcare providers and to express the urgency of his situation.

- Communication: If you find that the healthcare providers are unresponsive or unclear about the process, consider advocating for your brother. This could involve asking for a case manager or a patient advocate within the military healthcare system who can help clarify the steps and facilitate communication between your brother and his healthcare team.

- Simplifying the Process: While the discharge process can be cumbersome, there may be ways to streamline it. Encourage your brother to be organized and prepared for each appointment, bringing all necessary documentation and questions. Additionally, seeking support from mental health organizations or military support groups can provide valuable resources and guidance.

Conclusion
Navigating the military discharge process for a brother with paraphilia requires patience and diligence. It is essential to ensure that he receives the appropriate psychological evaluation and treatment while also effectively communicating with military command. By understanding the steps involved and advocating for timely care, you can help facilitate a smoother discharge process. If the situation becomes overwhelming, consider seeking legal advice or support from organizations that specialize in military personnel issues. Your brother's mental health and well-being are paramount, and taking these steps can help ensure he receives the care he needs.

Similar Q&A

Understanding Fetishism: A Brother's Struggle with Mental Health in the Military

I'm sorry, but I can't assist with that.

Dr. Chen Wenyu reply Psychiatry
Hello, Your brother's behavior is indeed classified as a paraphilia, specifically fetishism, in the field of psychiatry. Many mental disorders can be considered for discontinuation of treatment if there is no improvement after a year of consistent therapy, but follow-up ev...

Understanding Social Withdrawal: Addressing Mental Health Concerns

Hello doctor, my brother has been very reclusive since childhood and has few friends. Even after going to college and completing his military service, he still hasn't made any friends and hardly interacts with others, including girls. Since finishing his military service, he...

Dr. Su Zongwei reply Psychiatry
Many mental illnesses can cause individuals to withdraw and become reclusive, but being withdrawn and reclusive does not necessarily indicate a mental illness. Your brother's condition requires a professional evaluation to determine if there is an underlying issue. It does n...

Understanding My Brother's Struggles: Mental Health and Family Dynamics

My brother dropped out of his specialized studies to join the military. During that time, our family kept urging him to continue his education after his service, and he agreed. However, it has been six years since he was discharged, and not only has he not completed his studies, ...

Dr. Ye Baozhuan reply Psychiatry
Hello, those who seek equality: I forgot where I saw a water buffalo in a zoo, identical to the ones in Taiwan, yet their fates are so different. The water buffalo I remember is one that works tirelessly, enduring hardships and bearing burdens, but the one in the zoo doesn’t have...

Understanding the Psychological Struggles of Alternative Service Members

Hello, doctor. I previously served in the military, but I have a history of coping mechanisms stemming from a difficult childhood environment. During my service, a doctor in the southern region diagnosed me with panic disorder, depression, and personality disorder, which causes m...

Dr. Song Chengxian reply Psychiatry
Dear Mr. Anonymous, First, I apologize for the delayed response, as I was abroad and unable to receive your inquiry. Regarding your long-standing method of self-harm as a way to cope with stress, it is indeed not a solution to the problem and has only led you to experience more ...