the Truth About Milk Powder Additives and Their Effects - Family Medicine

Share to:

I'm sorry, I still don't quite understand (Quaker High-Speed Rail Zero Fat Milk Powder)?


Hello, Doctor: You mentioned that 1.
The additives in milk powder do not necessarily indicate their effectiveness (for example, adding L-ascorbic acid does not guarantee skin whitening or anti-aging effects; adding calcium does not necessarily increase bone density).
Therefore, even if the additives in milk powder are suitable for women, it does not mean that men cannot consume it.
If additives like L-ascorbic acid do not guarantee skin whitening, anti-aging, or probiotic benefits, then what is the point of purchasing them? (Buying those is merely for maintenance.) Furthermore, lacking those benefits could involve deceiving consumers, which could be reported under consumer protection laws! As far as I know, calcium in regular milk powder is not fully absorbed after consumption; regardless of how much is consumed, it is mostly excreted.
2.
You stated that it is not inappropriate for men to choose that type of milk powder? I am concerned whether it might affect male hormone levels or even various bodily functions.
Please respond, thank you, Doctor.

Xiao Jie, 30~39 year old female. Ask Date: 2010/01/25

Dr. Lai Junlong reply Family Medicine


Hello: In response to your questions.
1.
According to medical and health regulations, food containing additives or health supplements cannot claim therapeutic effects.
Therefore, if the additives in milk are classified as food, it cannot be advertised as having whitening or anti-aging effects.
Currently, there are no oral medications approved for whitening or anti-aging.
While food manufacturers may claim to add L-ascorbic acid (Vitamin C) or calcium, they will not state that consuming this milk can whiten skin or increase bone density.
Making such claims would be illegal and can be reported.
2.
Women's formula milk does not indicate the addition of sex hormone components and should not affect male hormone levels.
If the consumption of this formula leads to pronounced feminization, it should be regulated under pharmaceutical laws rather than being freely bought and sold.
Dr.
Lai Jun-long, Family Medicine.

Reply Date: 2010/01/25

More Info


When it comes to milk powder additives and their effects, it's essential to understand both the nutritional science behind these products and the marketing claims often associated with them. Your concerns about the efficacy of certain additives, such as L-ascorbic acid (Vitamin C) and calcium, are valid and reflect a broader conversation about how we interpret nutritional information.

Firstly, it is crucial to recognize that not all additives in milk powder are created equal. While some may have scientifically supported benefits, others may not deliver the promised effects. For instance, the addition of Vitamin C is often marketed for its antioxidant properties, which can theoretically support skin health and overall wellness. However, the extent to which it can "whiten" or "anti-age" is often overstated. The body requires a balanced diet for optimal skin health, and relying solely on supplements or fortified products may not yield the desired results.

Similarly, calcium is a vital nutrient for bone health, but the absorption of calcium from milk powder can vary based on several factors, including the presence of other nutrients, the individual's digestive health, and the form of calcium used in the product. It's true that not all calcium consumed is absorbed; studies suggest that only about 30-40% of dietary calcium is typically absorbed by the body. Therefore, while milk powder can be a good source of calcium, it should not be the sole source of this nutrient in one's diet.

Regarding the concern about whether certain milk powder additives could affect male hormones or bodily functions, it's important to note that most milk powders are formulated to be safe for all consumers, including men. However, some additives, particularly those derived from soy (like soy protein isolate), have been scrutinized for their phytoestrogen content, which can mimic estrogen in the body. While moderate consumption of soy products is generally considered safe for most individuals, excessive intake may lead to hormonal imbalances in sensitive populations. Therefore, moderation is key, and individuals should be mindful of their overall dietary patterns.

Moreover, the regulatory environment surrounding food additives is designed to ensure consumer safety. In many countries, food products must undergo rigorous testing before they can be marketed. If a product makes claims that are misleading or unsubstantiated, consumers have the right to report these claims to consumer protection agencies. This is an important aspect of maintaining transparency and accountability in the food industry.

In conclusion, while milk powder with additives can provide certain nutritional benefits, it is essential to approach these products with a critical eye. Understanding the science behind the additives, their actual benefits, and how they fit into a balanced diet is crucial. For individuals, including men, considering milk powder as part of their diet, it is advisable to consult with a healthcare provider or a registered dietitian. They can provide personalized advice based on individual health needs and dietary goals. Ultimately, a varied diet rich in whole foods is the best approach to achieving optimal health and nutrition.

Similar Q&A

Why Does Milk Cause Diarrhea While Formula Doesn't?

Why do I get diarrhea after drinking milk but not after consuming milk powder?


Dr. Shi Guimei reply Nutrition
Hello! Drinking fresh milk may cause diarrhea, while reconstituted milk powder does not. There are several possible reasons for this: 1. The fresh milk you selected is whole milk, which has a high fat content, whereas the milk powder you are using is low-fat or non-fat, resulting...

[Read More] Why Does Milk Cause Diarrhea While Formula Doesn't?


Can Casein in Milk Really Help Alleviate Spiciness?

I am someone who is very sensitive to spicy food. Recently, I heard from a friend that drinking milk can help alleviate the spiciness because milk contains a component called casein. Could you explain what casein is and why it can reduce spiciness? Also, I have another question: ...


Dr. Hu Yuqing reply Nutrition
Dietitian Hu Yu-Ching responded: Adjusting the pH of milk to 4.6 results in precipitation, with the precipitate being casein (which has an isoelectric point of 4.6). Casein precipitates when the pH drops below 4.6 or when it interacts with rennet, forming a coagulated state, whil...

[Read More] Can Casein in Milk Really Help Alleviate Spiciness?


Understanding Acidified Infant Formula: Who Needs It?

Hello, Dietitian Hsieh: I saw a medical supply store selling a type of acidified infant formula. What is acidified infant formula? Which type of babies need to consume this kind of formula? Thank you for your response.


Dr. Xie Huimin reply Nutrition
Acidified milk powder is produced by adding citric acid to milk powder. It is claimed to lower the intestinal pH, aiding in digestion and absorption. Currently, it is commonly used for infants experiencing diarrhea and bloating. However, it may not have the same effect on every i...

[Read More] Understanding Acidified Infant Formula: Who Needs It?


Can Breast Enhancement Supplements Be Safely Used?

Ingredients: Flaxseed powder, bee pollen powder (royal jelly powder), white high pearl extract (Pueraria mirifica), green papaya extract, maca extract, elastin (fish scale source), collagen, shea butter powder, soybean extract (containing isoflavones), grape extract (containing r...


Dr. Huang Yuande reply Obstetrics and Gynecology
This falls under the category of health supplements, and moderate consumption should not pose significant issues.

[Read More] Can Breast Enhancement Supplements Be Safely Used?


Related FAQ

Drug Side Effects

(Family Medicine)

Health Supplements

(Family Medicine)

Saliva

(Family Medicine)

Accidental Ingestion

(Family Medicine)

Urine Report

(Family Medicine)

Digestion

(Family Medicine)

Heavy Metal Poisoning

(Family Medicine)

Nausea

(Family Medicine)

Blood Sugar

(Family Medicine)

Medication Safety

(Pharmacology)