Is It Safe to Drink Milk on an Empty Stomach? Debunking Common Myths

Q: Is It Safe to Drink Milk on an Empty Stomach? Debunking Common Myths

Hello, Miss： Milk does not harm the stomach; however, the lactose in milk often causes bloating and diarrhea in Taiwanese people. <br>The rest is just for your reference. <br>Changhua Hospital cares about your health. <br>Chen Shidian.

Is it okay to drink milk on an empty stomach right after waking up?

Milk is not necessarily harmful for healthy individuals.
There was a news report about an 85-year-old doctor who has been drinking milk with every meal since he was 45, and he remains healthy and fit.
However, there are conflicting opinions online regarding whether it is advisable to drink milk on an empty stomach.
Some doctors warn that drinking milk on an empty stomach or mixing it with acidic juices can be harmful to the stomach.
The nutritional value of milk is high, and consuming it daily can indeed be beneficial for health.
However, there is a myth circulating online that one should drink plain water immediately after consuming milk to avoid throat irritation.
Doctors have debunked this claim, emphasizing that it is best not to drink milk on an empty stomach.
Additionally, they advise against consuming acidic juices, such as orange juice, immediately after drinking milk, as this can also irritate the stomach.
Many people rush to work or school in the morning and often substitute breakfast with a glass of milk.
This practice of drinking milk on an empty stomach, followed by acidic juices, is considered incorrect by medical professionals.
It can stimulate gastric acid secretion and lead to bloating and gastrointestinal discomfort.
Dr.
Huang Liqi, an endocrinologist at Cathay General Hospital, notes that milk can stimulate gastric acid secretion, which may cause discomfort for some individuals.
Furthermore, when gastric acid is secreted, it can combine with milk to form curds, potentially leading to bloating and gastrointestinal issues.
It is generally accepted that drinking milk on an empty stomach is not problematic unless one has lactose intolerance, which would cause discomfort after consuming milk.
When the stomach is empty, there is little gastric acid present.
Upon drinking milk, gastric acid is secreted to partially digest the protein, and this process can stimulate further gastric acid secretion for protein digestion.
This is a normal digestive process, and gastric acid secretion is not unlimited; it will cease when the pH level drops below 2.5.
Therefore, for healthy individuals, there should not be any significant risk of developing gastric ulcers.
Moreover, the notion that milk rapidly enters the colon and produces toxins is unfounded.
Everyone has a long small intestine, and milk is emptied from the stomach into the small intestine, where proteins undergo further digestion and absorption.
Only undigested remnants will enter the colon.
The rapid intestinal motility on an empty stomach refers to certain reflexes, such as the gastrocolic reflex, which indicates that food in the stomach can promote rapid movement in the colon, leading to the urge to defecate, but it does not mean that recently consumed food is expelled immediately.
There are also claims that drinking milk can acidify the body, causing calcium ions to be released from bones to maintain acid-base balance, potentially leading to osteoporosis.
This is also unfounded.
The body's acid-base balance primarily involves bicarbonates and phosphates, and calcium is not needed for this regulation.
Furthermore, milk contains not only protein but also water, carbohydrates, vitamins, and fats, so having only milk for breakfast does not lead to nutritional imbalances.
In conclusion, for healthy individuals, drinking milk on an empty stomach is generally not an issue.

tza, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2010/11/13

Dr. Chen Shidian reply Gastroenterology and Hepatology

Hello, Miss: Milk does not harm the stomach; however, the lactose in milk often causes bloating and diarrhea in Taiwanese people.
The rest is just for your reference.
Changhua Hospital cares about your health.
Chen Shidian.

Reply Date: 2010/11/13

More Info

Drinking milk on an empty stomach has been a topic of debate, with varying opinions on its safety and health implications. To address your question, it is generally safe for healthy individuals to consume milk on an empty stomach, but there are some nuances to consider.

Milk is a nutrient-rich beverage that provides essential nutrients such as protein, calcium, vitamins, and fats. For many, it serves as a good source of energy and nutrition, especially when consumed as part of a balanced diet. However, some individuals may experience gastrointestinal discomfort when drinking milk on an empty stomach, particularly if they are lactose intolerant. Lactose intolerance is a condition where the body lacks the enzyme lactase, which is necessary to digest lactose, the sugar found in milk. For these individuals, consuming milk can lead to symptoms such as bloating, gas, and diarrhea.

One common concern is that drinking milk on an empty stomach may stimulate excessive gastric acid production, leading to discomfort or even gastritis. While it is true that milk can stimulate gastric acid secretion, this is a normal part of the digestive process. When milk enters the stomach, it can combine with gastric acid to form curds, which may cause some individuals to feel bloated or uncomfortable. However, this reaction varies from person to person. For those without underlying gastrointestinal issues, drinking milk on an empty stomach is unlikely to cause significant problems.

Another point of contention is the idea that consuming milk immediately before or after acidic beverages, such as orange juice, can harm the stomach. This is based on the premise that the combination may lead to increased acidity and discomfort. While it is advisable to wait a bit between consuming milk and acidic drinks, the concern is more about individual tolerance rather than a universal rule.

Moreover, there are myths surrounding the idea that milk consumption can lead to an acidic body environment, which could potentially cause osteoporosis. This claim lacks scientific backing. The body maintains its acid-base balance primarily through the kidneys and lungs, and dietary calcium from milk actually supports bone health rather than detracting from it.

In summary, for most healthy individuals, drinking milk on an empty stomach is safe and can be part of a nutritious diet. However, if you have a history of lactose intolerance or gastrointestinal issues, it may be wise to monitor your body's response to milk consumption. If discomfort arises, consider consuming milk with food or opting for lactose-free alternatives.

For those who are concerned about their overall nutrition, it's important to remember that milk should not be the sole component of a meal. A balanced breakfast that includes a variety of food groups—such as whole grains, fruits, and proteins—will provide a more comprehensive nutrient profile. If you have specific health concerns or dietary restrictions, consulting with a healthcare professional or a registered dietitian can provide personalized guidance tailored to your needs.

Similar Q&A

Is It Safe to Drink Milk on an Empty Stomach in the Morning?

Hello, may I ask if it's okay to drink milk on an empty stomach after waking up in the morning? Thank you!

Dr. Hu Yuqing reply Nutrition
Xiao Qing Tian: Good morning! It is generally fine to drink milk on an empty stomach; however, some people may experience increased gastrointestinal motility, which could lead to diarrhea. Wishing you good health. Response from Nutritionist Hu Yuqing. 940718 Monday.

Is It Safe to Eat Chocolate on an Empty Stomach?

Since I work at a breakfast shop and sometimes eat very late, I would like to ask the doctor if I can eat a little chocolate first thing in the morning after I wake up. Will eating chocolate on an empty stomach be harmful to my stomach?

Dr. Shi Guimei reply Nutrition
Dear Aru: Hello, consuming sweets on an empty stomach can easily stimulate gastric acid secretion, leading to stomach discomfort. If due to work-related reasons, for the convenience and nutritional value of breakfast, you may consider having milk with soda crackers or toast. Wish...

Can You Drink Milk with Acid Reflux? Myths and Facts Explained

Can people with gastroesophageal reflux disease (GERD) drink milk? Is GERD caused by excessive stomach acid? If so, milk could neutralize stomach acid, but it's often said that milk should be avoided. What is the correct information?

Dr. Chen Qifeng reply Gastroenterology and Hepatology
Hello, gastroesophageal reflux occurs primarily due to insufficient contraction of the lower esophageal sphincter at the junction of the esophagus and stomach, leading to incomplete closure of the lower esophagus. When there is an increased secretion of gastric acid, it can flow ...

Is It Safe to Drink Fresh Milk After Breakfast? Nutritional Insights

So if I have a Taiwanese egg pancake for breakfast and then immediately go to a convenience store to drink about 300cc of fresh milk, that should be fine, right? My weight and BMI are within the normal range, and I am generally healthy with normal digestion, so I can drink it at ...

Dr. Cai Xiuwen reply Nutrition
Hello, your current body position is standard. If there are no other symptoms, it indicates that drinking fresh milk does not have a significant impact on you. Wishing you peace and health. This response is from Dietitian Tsai Hsiu-Wen at Nantou Hospital, Ministry of Health and W...