Can Traditional Chinese Medicine Cure Severe Herniated Discs?

Q: Can Traditional Chinese Medicine Cure Severe Herniated Discs?

Question 1： Aconite-based medications (such as Chuanwu and Caowu) are effective in treating wind-cold bi syndrome, but they have a pungent and warm nature and can be highly toxic. <br>Caution should be exercised with dosages, and it is safest to have them prescribed by a qualifie

Can severe herniated discs be cured with traditional Chinese medicine?

Dear Doctors,
Recently, I came across information online suggesting that certain Aconitum-based medications can cure severe lumbar disc herniation, even in cases where Western medicine has recommended surgery due to the severity of the condition.
The pain management with Western medications has been ineffective, and the patient has experienced muscle atrophy in the limbs, leading to an inability to walk.
The reported efficacy of these treatments is quite remarkable and has piqued my interest.

As I am not a specialist in Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM), and I have friends and family members who are experiencing similar issues, I am eager to explore this option but am concerned about being misled by inappropriate medical information.
Therefore, I would like to consult with professional physicians regarding the following questions:
1.
Besides anti-inflammatory and analgesic effects, can Aconitum-based medications actually reposition a herniated disc and achieve a cure?
2.
Is it possible for current TCM treatments to cure such severe disc herniation without the need for surgical decompression?
Thank you for your responses.

Sha Ou, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2012/01/04

Dr. He Yujun reply Traditional Chinese Medicine

Question 1: Aconite-based medications (such as Chuanwu and Caowu) are effective in treating wind-cold bi syndrome, but they have a pungent and warm nature and can be highly toxic.
Caution should be exercised with dosages, and it is safest to have them prescribed by a qualified physician.
When used appropriately, they may achieve the effects of dispelling wind, eliminating dampness, and relieving pain; however, these medications cannot reposition a herniated disc.
Question 2: Traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) diagnoses and treats based on the patient's constitution and the syndrome of the disease.
Herniated discs are a term used in Western medicine, and the symptoms and severity can vary from person to person, as can their tolerance for pain.
The pain caused by a herniated disc may be attributed to damp-heat, wind-cold, or wind-damp in TCM, leading to different treatment approaches.
TCM can also utilize acupuncture, with acupoint selection determined by syndrome differentiation.
Tui Na (Chinese therapeutic massage) and spinal manipulation can also be effective.
In summary, TCM treatment for herniated discs does not directly aim to reposition the disc but rather addresses the potential causes of the herniation, alleviating pressure on the surrounding muscles and ligaments of the spine, improving blood circulation in the area, and reducing the pressure on the disc to alleviate symptoms.

Reply Date: 2012/01/04

More Info

When it comes to the treatment of severe herniated discs, particularly in cases where conventional Western medicine has suggested surgical intervention, it is essential to approach the situation with a comprehensive understanding of both Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM) and Western medical practices.

Question 1: Can Aconite (Wu Tou) and similar herbal medicines not only relieve inflammation and pain but also reposition the herniated disc?
Aconite, particularly varieties like Chuan Wu (川烏) and Cao Wu (草烏), is known in TCM for its warming properties and ability to alleviate pain, especially in conditions characterized by cold and dampness. However, it is crucial to note that while these herbs may provide symptomatic relief, they do not have the capability to physically reposition a herniated disc. The mechanism of a herniated disc involves the displacement of the intervertebral disc material, which cannot be corrected through herbal treatments alone.
In severe cases, where there is significant nerve compression leading to symptoms such as limb weakness or atrophy, surgical intervention may be necessary to relieve pressure on the affected nerves. While TCM can play a supportive role in managing pain and improving overall well-being, it should not be viewed as a substitute for surgical options when they are indicated.

Question 2: Can TCM effectively treat severe herniated discs without the need for surgical decompression?
TCM approaches the treatment of herniated discs by focusing on the underlying imbalances in the body. Practitioners assess the individual's constitution and the specific nature of their symptoms. For instance, a herniated disc may be viewed through the lens of various TCM patterns such as damp-heat, wind-cold, or qi stagnation, each requiring a tailored treatment strategy.

While TCM modalities such as acupuncture, herbal medicine, and tuina (Chinese therapeutic massage) can help alleviate pain, reduce inflammation, and improve circulation, they do not directly address the mechanical aspect of a herniated disc. Acupuncture can be particularly effective in managing pain and improving mobility, while herbal formulas may help reduce inflammation and promote healing.

It is important to recognize that TCM can be beneficial as an adjunct therapy, especially for pain management and rehabilitation post-surgery. However, for severe cases where there is significant nerve involvement or loss of function, relying solely on TCM without considering surgical options could lead to further complications.

In conclusion, while TCM offers valuable tools for managing symptoms associated with herniated discs, it is not a cure-all, especially in severe cases. Patients should consult with healthcare professionals who are knowledgeable in both TCM and Western medicine to create a comprehensive treatment plan that addresses their specific needs. This integrative approach can help ensure that all aspects of the condition are managed effectively, leading to better outcomes and improved quality of life.

Similar Q&A

Can Traditional Chinese Medicine Effectively Treat Herniated Discs?

Hello~ I would like to ask if herniated discs can be treated with traditional Chinese medicine? How long does it usually take to see results? Can you recommend a traditional Chinese medicine practitioner near Daya? Thank you!

Dr. Lin Qingzhong reply Traditional Chinese Medicine
Dear Mr. Cheng / Online User 22, 1. Herniated discs can be treated with Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM). A herniated disc may result from prolonged heavy lifting or standing, leading to excessive pressure on the lower back, known as "lumbar degenerative syndrome." ...

Exploring Traditional Chinese Medicine for Cervical Disc Issues

Hello Dr. Huang: My condition is a cervical disc herniation that is compressing the nerves. I sometimes experience soreness in the shoulder area of my left arm, and occasionally my fingers feel numb. This situation has been ongoing for about 10 years. Recently, after visiting a n...

Dr. Huang Zhongzhun reply Traditional Chinese Medicine
Hello, Pfhsieh: If the cervical intervertebral disc herniation causes mild pain, numbness, or weakness, it is generally manageable with medication or rehabilitation. Traditional Chinese medicine treats this condition with acupuncture and chiropractic adjustments. However, if th...

Can Traditional Chinese Medicine Fully Heal Pelvic Inflammatory Disease?

Doctor, can pelvic inflammatory disease be completely cured with traditional Chinese medicine? A Western doctor told me that pelvic inflammatory disease will not fully heal, and I have had this condition for three years. I have intermittently taken antibiotics during this time, a...

Dr. Wu Xuanzhang reply Traditional Chinese Medicine
Dear Ruby, Pelvic inflammatory disease in gynecology can be treated with traditional Chinese medicine. TCM can help enhance your immune system, assist your body in healing, and improve blood circulation in the pelvic area. As for the issues related to scoliosis and sciatica, acu...

Effective Traditional Chinese Medicine Remedies for Sciatica Relief

I'm sorry! It has been over ten days since my last inquiry, and I have not seen any relevant responses. I am unsure if my previous upload was unsuccessful, which may have caused you not to receive my questions. Therefore, I must ask again. Thank you for taking the time to re...

Dr. Lin Qingzhong reply Traditional Chinese Medicine
Dear user seeking urgent treatment, Your questions are answered briefly as follows: 1. Sciatica is a condition commonly encountered by both Western and Traditional Chinese Medicine practitioners. It is primarily caused by overexertion or injuries such as herniated discs that le...