the Differences Between Electrolyzed Water and Energized Water - Nutrition

Share to:

Energy water and electrolyzed water?


Hello, what is the difference between electrolyzed water and energized water? What are the advantages and disadvantages of each? Does long-term use have any effects on the human body? Thank you~~Ann

Ann, 30~39 year old female. Ask Date: 2003/03/31

Dr. Tang Weili reply Nutrition


Ann: The human body has the ability to regulate pH levels and osmotic pressure, so as long as the drinking water is sourced from sanitary tap water that has not been contaminated a second time, it can be safely consumed after boiling.
Many households use water filtration systems to enhance the removal of impurities and microorganisms, and it is reasonable to also pay attention to the cleanliness and maintenance of these filtration systems.
As for commercial gimmicks like electrolyzed water or energy water, they are not credible.

Reply Date: 2003/03/31

More Info


Electrolyzed water and energized water are two terms often encountered in discussions about water treatment and health benefits, but they refer to different processes and have distinct characteristics.
Electrolyzed Water:
Electrolyzed water is produced through the process of electrolysis, where an electric current is passed through water containing dissolved salts (usually sodium chloride). This process separates the water into two components: an alkaline solution (often referred to as electrolyzed reduced water or ERW) and an acidic solution (often referred to as electrolyzed oxidizing water or EOW). The alkaline water is believed to have antioxidant properties, while the acidic water is often used for disinfection purposes.

Advantages:
1. Antioxidant Properties: Proponents claim that alkaline electrolyzed water can neutralize free radicals in the body, potentially reducing oxidative stress.

2. Disinfection: The acidic electrolyzed water is effective in killing bacteria and viruses, making it useful for sanitizing surfaces and food.

3. Hydration: Some users report better hydration levels when consuming electrolyzed water, although scientific evidence supporting this claim is limited.

Disadvantages:
1. Limited Scientific Evidence: Many claims surrounding the health benefits of electrolyzed water lack robust scientific backing.

2. Taste and pH Levels: The taste of electrolyzed water can be different from regular water, and its high pH may not be suitable for everyone.

3. Cost and Accessibility: Electrolyzed water systems can be expensive and may not be practical for everyday use.

Energized Water:
Energized water, on the other hand, refers to water that has been treated with various methods (such as magnetic fields, sound waves, or other energy forms) to enhance its properties. The idea is that this treatment can increase the water's energy, making it more beneficial for health.

Advantages:
1. Enhanced Taste: Some users find that energized water tastes better, which may encourage increased water consumption.

2. Potential Health Benefits: Advocates suggest that energized water can improve hydration and nutrient absorption, although scientific evidence is limited.

3. Convenience: Energized water can often be produced using simple devices, making it more accessible than electrolyzed water systems.

Disadvantages:
1. Lack of Regulation: The methods used to energize water are often not standardized or regulated, leading to variability in quality and effectiveness.

2. Skepticism in the Scientific Community: Many health claims associated with energized water are viewed skeptically due to insufficient scientific validation.

3. Cost: Similar to electrolyzed water, energized water systems can also be costly.

Long-term Effects on Health:
Regarding the long-term consumption of either type of water, it is essential to consider that the human body is quite adept at regulating its internal environment, including pH levels. Drinking water that is safe and free from contaminants is the most critical factor. While both electrolyzed and energized waters may offer some benefits, they should not replace regular hydration practices with clean, potable water.

For individuals considering the long-term use of these waters, it is advisable to consult with a healthcare professional, especially if there are underlying health conditions or concerns. Additionally, maintaining a balanced diet and ensuring adequate hydration with safe drinking water should remain the priority.

In summary, while both electrolyzed water and energized water have their proponents and potential benefits, they also come with limitations and a lack of comprehensive scientific support. It is crucial to approach these products with a critical mindset and prioritize overall health and safety when it comes to hydration.

Similar Q&A

Can Electrolyzed Water Improve Health for Diabetics and Chronic Patients?

Can electrolysis of water change body constitution? Is it beneficial for patients with diabetes (or chronic diseases)?


Dr. Cai Xiuwen reply Nutrition
Hello! Electrolyzed water refers to changing the concentration of ions in water to adjust its pH level. Many people believe that drinking electrolyzed water can adjust the body's acid-base balance; however, the human body automatically regulates and maintains acid-base homeo...

[Read More] Can Electrolyzed Water Improve Health for Diabetics and Chronic Patients?


Understanding the Composition of Water from Live Water Dispensers

Hello, recently there was an email stating that "reverse osmosis water and distilled water are the least drinkable." We have switched to drinking water filtered by a living water dispenser. We conducted a simple experiment: we planted the same type of flowers in three c...


Dr. Tang Weili reply Nutrition
Ms. Shui: The reasons against drinking RO (reverse osmosis) water and distilled water are primarily due to the lack of natural minerals such as calcium and magnesium that are present in natural water. Proponents of "living water" claim that it contains beneficial minera...

[Read More] Understanding the Composition of Water from Live Water Dispensers


Understanding the Differences Between Electrolytes and Ions: Nutritional Insights

Dear Nutritionist: What is the difference between potassium ions and sodium ions, and from which foods can they be absorbed? What happens if a person lacks potassium ions or sodium ions? Additionally, if a person tends to have sticky stools, what foods should they eat? Thank you ...


Dr. Shi Guimei reply Nutrition
Hello! Electrolytes refer to certain salts, acids, and bases that, when dissolved in water, dissociate into ions. Since ions can conduct electricity, they are called electrolytes. This explanation might still be unclear, so let me provide some examples: electrolytes include sodiu...

[Read More] Understanding the Differences Between Electrolytes and Ions: Nutritional Insights


Is Ionized Water Safe for Dialysis Patients with Diabetes?

I would like to ask if my mother, who is a diabetic patient and currently undergoing dialysis, can drink alkaline water. Will it cause electrolyte imbalance or have any adverse effects on her body?


Dr. Wu Jiyu reply Internal Medicine
You can consider "negative ion water" as regular water, because your mother is undergoing dialysis and has diabetes. Generally speaking, patients on dialysis tend to require the removal of more fluid (as fluid can accumulate easily), so fluid intake needs to be carefull...

[Read More] Is Ionized Water Safe for Dialysis Patients with Diabetes?


Related FAQ

Body Weight

(Nutrition)

Kidney

(Nutrition)

Stroke Diet

(Nutrition)

Anemia

(Nutrition)

Bulimia

(Nutrition)

Infant Nutrition

(Nutrition)

Fruit And Vegetable Juice

(Nutrition)

Elderly

(Nutrition)

Food Safety

(Nutrition)

Exercise And Weight Loss

(Nutrition)