Which type of dietary supplements is more suitable for the elderly?
Currently, my grandfather is 80 years old, has a poor appetite, easily fatigues, and experiences weakness in his legs, often leading to falls.
Despite multiple suggestions, he is reluctant to see a doctor and is considering purchasing dietary supplements but is unsure which ones are more suitable.
He has come across Silver Star and Coenzyme Q10.
Could you please explain the differences between these two?
Momo, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2021/08/13
Dr. Xie Peiru reply Nutrition
Hello: Based on your description, it is possible that your grandfather has long-term poor appetite, leading to nutritional deficiencies; it may also be due to an unbalanced diet, resulting in protein (muscle) loss.
It is recommended to consult a family medicine physician.
Dietary supplements may not be suitable for your grandfather's current condition, and taking the supplements you mentioned may not necessarily improve his situation.
It is still advisable to see a doctor.
Regarding the supplements: 1.
Silver Star is a multivitamin.
2.
Aritamin contains B vitamins and vitamin E.
Wishing you good health! Nutrition Department, Qiy Medical Center.
Reply Date: 2021/08/13
More Info
When considering the best supplements for seniors, particularly for an 80-year-old individual who is experiencing poor appetite, fatigue, and weakness, it's important to understand the differences and potential benefits of Silver Star (often referred to as colloidal silver) and Coenzyme Q10 (CoQ10).
Coenzyme Q10 (CoQ10) is a fat-soluble antioxidant that is naturally present in the body, particularly in the mitochondria of cells, where it plays a crucial role in energy production. As we age, the levels of CoQ10 in our bodies tend to decrease, which can contribute to fatigue and decreased energy levels. Supplementing with CoQ10 may help improve energy levels, enhance physical performance, and support heart health. It has also been studied for its potential benefits in managing conditions such as heart disease, hypertension, and even neurodegenerative diseases like Parkinson's and Alzheimer's. Additionally, CoQ10 has antioxidant properties, which can help protect cells from oxidative stress and damage.
On the other hand, Silver Star, or colloidal silver, is a supplement that has been marketed for various uses, including as an antimicrobial agent. However, its efficacy and safety are subjects of considerable debate. The FDA has issued warnings against the use of colloidal silver due to potential side effects, including argyria (a condition that causes the skin to turn blue-gray) and other health risks. There is limited scientific evidence supporting its use for health benefits, and it is not recommended as a treatment for any specific condition.
Given the context of your grandfather's health concerns, CoQ10 would likely be the more beneficial supplement. It can help address fatigue and support overall energy levels, which is particularly important for seniors who may be experiencing weakness and a decline in physical activity. Furthermore, CoQ10 is generally well-tolerated with few side effects, making it a safer option compared to colloidal silver.
In contrast, the use of colloidal silver should be approached with caution. The potential risks and lack of proven benefits make it a less favorable choice, especially for an elderly individual who may already be dealing with multiple health issues.
In summary, for your grandfather, Coenzyme Q10 would be the recommended supplement due to its established benefits for energy production and heart health, along with its safety profile. It is advisable to consult with a healthcare professional before starting any new supplement regimen, especially considering your grandfather's age and health status. This will ensure that any supplements taken do not interfere with existing medications or conditions.
In conclusion, while both Silver Star and Coenzyme Q10 are marketed as health supplements, CoQ10 stands out as the more appropriate choice for seniors, particularly for enhancing energy levels and supporting overall health.
Similar Q&A
Are Co-Q10 and Q10 the Same Supplement? Understanding Their Differences
Are the commercially available oral Co-Q10 and Q10 referring to the same substance? Are they both vitamin Q? Thank you.
Dr. Hou Fangmin reply Pharmacology
Hello: Coenzyme Q10 (Co-Q10) and Q10 belong to the same class of compounds and are fat-soluble vitamins that are not water-soluble. Co-Q10 is closely related to at least three mitochondrial enzyme complexes, which are the main enzymes involved in ATP formation. Additionally, Co-Q...[Read More] Are Co-Q10 and Q10 the Same Supplement? Understanding Their Differences
Managing Heart Failure: Is GNC Co-Q10 Safe for My Mother?
Hello: My mother is 65 years old and has rheumatic heart disease. Between 1976 and 2000, she underwent three heart surgeries to replace heart valves. Currently, she has a titanium valve for the mitral valve and a porcine valve for the tricuspid valve. She is experiencing symptoms...
Dr. Xiao Yiqing reply Pharmacology
1. Coenzyme Q10 (Co-Q10) is classified as a dietary supplement rather than a medication. 2. Co-Q10 is a fat-soluble nutrient with antioxidant and anticoagulant properties (similar to Vitamin K). It acts as a coenzyme in the human body and can be synthesized endogenously, as wel...[Read More] Managing Heart Failure: Is GNC Co-Q10 Safe for My Mother?
How to Properly Combine Nutritional Supplements for Optimal Health
1. Iron supplement with enhanced formula for blood nourishment 2. L-ascorbic acid (Vitamin C) + Vitamin E tablets 3. Grape seed extract Vitamin C tablets 4. Collagen PLUS tablets 5. Coenzyme Q10 capsules How should these be distributed for healthy consumption? (Before ...
Dr. Shi Guimei reply Nutrition
Hello: Generally, healthy adults who follow a balanced and nutritious diet do not need to supplement with any nutritional supplements. If dietary adjustments are necessary due to health conditions, it is best to provide relevant test reports to a nutritionist for appropriate diet...[Read More] How to Properly Combine Nutritional Supplements for Optimal Health
Can GABA and CoQ10 Be Taken Together for Better Sleep and Energy?
Dear Pharmacist: I have poor sleep quality, and my doctor recommended that I supplement with GABA. Additionally, since I started taking Coenzyme Q10, my fatigue has decreased and my energy levels have improved! Can you please tell me if there are any interactions or concerns with...
Dr. Chen Yuemei reply Pharmacology
Hello: After reviewing relevant literature and clinical studies, there is no evidence showing the advantages or disadvantages of long-term use of these two dietary supplements. However, regardless of which dietary supplements are taken, they must undergo hepatic and renal metabol...[Read More] Can GABA and CoQ10 Be Taken Together for Better Sleep and Energy?
Related FAQ
(Nutrition)
Health Supplements(Nutrition)
Health Supplements(Internal Medicine)
Dietary Supplements(Pharmacology)
Health Supplements(Traditional Chinese Medicine)
Health Supplements(Pediatrics)
Vitamins(Family Medicine)
Gastrointestinal(Nutrition)
Lutein(Nutrition)
Vitamins(Obstetrics and Gynecology)