Taking too many calcium supplements can hinder growth?
My mom keeps complaining about my height, saying that it's because I took too many calcium supplements in the past, which stunted my growth.
However, I remember that cartilage growth is stimulated by hormones, which is what affects height.
Yet, I found articles online claiming that excessive calcium intake can lead to calcification and hinder growth.
So, I would like to ask the doctor: does taking too many calcium supplements really prevent growth?
Nìmíng, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2024/01/02
Dr. Shi Guozheng reply Orthopedics
Height is usually more related to genetic factors, but nutrition and exercise also play a significant role.
Reply Date: 2024/01/02
More Info
Excessive calcium supplementation is a concern that many parents have when it comes to their children's growth and development. However, the relationship between calcium intake and height is not as straightforward as one might think. While calcium is essential for bone health and growth, particularly during childhood and adolescence, the idea that too much calcium can stunt growth is not supported by strong scientific evidence.
First, it is important to understand that growth in height is primarily influenced by genetics, hormonal factors, and overall nutrition. The growth plates in bones, which are areas of developing cartilage, are responsible for height increase. These growth plates close after puberty, and once they are closed, further height increase is not possible. Hormones, particularly growth hormone and sex hormones, play a significant role in regulating the growth process.
Calcium is crucial for bone development and density. It helps in the formation of bone tissue and is vital for the proper functioning of various bodily processes. The recommended dietary allowance (RDA) for calcium varies by age, but for children aged 9-18 years, it is generally around 1,300 mg per day. This amount can typically be obtained through a balanced diet that includes dairy products, leafy greens, and fortified foods.
Regarding the concern about excessive calcium intake, it is true that taking too much calcium can lead to health issues, such as kidney stones or hypercalcemia (high levels of calcium in the blood). However, the body has mechanisms to regulate calcium levels, and it is rare for someone to reach excessive levels through diet alone. Most cases of hypercalcemia are associated with medical conditions or excessive supplementation.
In your case, if you were taking calcium supplements as a child, it is unlikely that this would have stunted your growth. Instead, factors such as genetics and hormonal changes during puberty are more likely to have influenced your final height. The notion that calcium supplements could lead to "calcium deposits" that inhibit growth is a misunderstanding. Calcium deposits typically refer to calcification in tissues, which is different from the growth process in bones.
Moreover, it is essential to maintain a balanced intake of other nutrients, including vitamin D, which is crucial for calcium absorption, and magnesium, which also plays a role in bone health. A well-rounded diet that includes a variety of nutrients is vital for optimal growth and development.
In conclusion, while it is important to monitor calcium intake to avoid excessive supplementation, it is unlikely that taking calcium supplements in moderation would stunt growth in children. If there are concerns about growth or nutrition, it is advisable to consult with a healthcare provider or a registered dietitian who can provide personalized guidance based on individual health needs and dietary habits.
Similar Q&A
Long-Term Calcium Supplementation in Children: Risks and Recommendations
Hello Doctor: My child is in a developmental stage and has been found to have insufficient bone density. If we take calcium supplements long-term, could this lead to hypercalcemia? Additionally, the varicella vaccine was administered at the age of five. Now that my child is thirt...
Dr. Xiao Kaiwen reply Pediatrics
Supplementing with calcium tablets in moderation is acceptable, but excessive intake may lead to hypercalcemia, which can affect kidney function and the absorption of other minerals. Therefore, it should be used under medical guidance. The varicella vaccine should be administered...[Read More] Long-Term Calcium Supplementation in Children: Risks and Recommendations
Is Daily Calcium Citrate Safe for Kids? Long-Term Effects on Growth
Hello, my son is in the second grade, and he really enjoys the powdered calcium citrate sold at Costco. He consumes one packet daily as recommended on the packaging for children. Can children consume this product long-term? Will it have any impact on his growth? Thank you!
Dr. Cai Xiuwen reply Nutrition
Hello Mr. Lin! Calcium is an essential nutrient for growth, and calcium citrate has a higher absorption rate, making it a suitable supplement. However, for children's growth, it is also important to increase caloric intake, protein, vitamins, and other minerals. According to...[Read More] Is Daily Calcium Citrate Safe for Kids? Long-Term Effects on Growth
Concerns About Height Growth: Nutrition and Lifestyle Tips for Teens
Hello, doctor. I am currently a ninth-grade student, with a height of 164.1 cm and a weight of around 108 lbs. I usually go to bed quite late, sometimes until 1 AM, with an average bedtime around midnight, and I exercise about once a week. I would like to ask if fasting would aff...
Dr. Li Wenhong reply Orthopedics
Hello: It is not recommended for adolescents in their developmental stage to use fasting for weight control. Instead, a low-carbohydrate diet (reducing starch) and appropriate exercise are advised. Calcium supplements are just nutritional supplements, and any brand of calcium can...[Read More] Concerns About Height Growth: Nutrition and Lifestyle Tips for Teens
Do Calcium Supplements Really Benefit Young Adults?
Recently, when I went to the pharmacy to buy calcium supplements, the pharmacist said, "It's great that someone your age understands the importance of taking calcium." They also mentioned that bone health should be built from a young age... Is this true?
Dr. Shi Qiming reply Orthopedics
Dr. Wang Zikang replied: Calcium is a major component of the human skeleton, and the required amount varies with age. The absorption of calcium is a complex process involving hormones, gastrointestinal absorption functions, vitamins, and other related substances. It is important ...[Read More] Do Calcium Supplements Really Benefit Young Adults?
Related FAQ
(Orthopedics)
Calcium Absorption(Orthopedics)
Dietary Supplements(Orthopedics)
Osteogenesis Imperfecta(Orthopedics)
Osteoporosis(Orthopedics)
Skeletal Development(Orthopedics)
Height(Orthopedics)
Bone Spur(Orthopedics)
Bone Density Test(Orthopedics)
Infant Growth(Pediatrics)