Can You Drink Milk? Debunking Myths About Calcium Absorption - Nutrition

Share to:

Is it not possible to drink milk?


I would like to ask the doctor: Some people say that milk should not be consumed because it hinders calcium absorption.
Is this true? Are there any individuals who should avoid drinking milk?

zi se, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2004/09/17

Dr. Cai Xiuwen reply Nutrition


Hello! A recent study from Harvard University has indicated that women who consume more than two cups of milk daily have a significantly higher risk of fractures compared to those who drink less than one cup of milk per week.
This has sparked discussions about whether milk hinders calcium absorption.
When such headlines appear in the news, they can indeed be shocking! But why is this the case?
There are many factors that affect calcium absorption, including fat, fiber, oxalates, and phosphates, all of which can reduce calcium uptake.
While Western populations consume a lot of milk, they also tend to have high intakes of protein, fat, and carbonated beverages.
Many scholars suggest that the reason for calcium loss is not solely due to the amount of milk consumed, but rather the consumption of high-protein, high-fat, fiber-rich, oxalate, and phosphate foods, as well as the impact of physical activity on bone health.
Therefore, to maintain bone health, it is essential not only to consume calcium-rich foods but also to limit the intake of foods that hinder calcium absorption, such as cola and soda.
Additionally, one should be mindful of avoiding high-fat diets, excessive meat consumption, and processed foods, while also engaging in regular physical activity.
This approach can help reduce the risk of bone loss.
Wishing you peace and health! Response from Dietitian Tsai Hsiu-Wen, Nantou Hospital, Department of Health.

Reply Date: 2004/09/17

More Info


The question of whether milk can be consumed and its impact on calcium absorption is a topic that has garnered much attention and debate. Many people have heard conflicting information regarding milk's role in calcium absorption, leading to confusion about its health benefits. Let's delve into the facts surrounding this issue.

First and foremost, milk is widely recognized as an excellent source of calcium, which is essential for maintaining strong bones and overall health. Calcium is a critical mineral that plays a vital role in various bodily functions, including muscle contraction, nerve transmission, and blood clotting. For individuals, especially children and adolescents, who are in their growth phases, adequate calcium intake is crucial for developing a healthy skeletal system.

The concern that milk might hinder calcium absorption primarily stems from the presence of certain proteins and compounds in milk that some believe could interfere with calcium's bioavailability. However, the majority of scientific evidence supports the idea that milk and dairy products are beneficial for calcium absorption rather than detrimental. Studies have shown that the calcium in milk is highly bioavailable, meaning that it is easily absorbed by the body. The presence of lactose, the sugar found in milk, can also enhance calcium absorption in the intestines.

Moreover, it is essential to consider that while some foods contain oxalates and phytates, which can bind to calcium and inhibit its absorption, milk does not contain significant amounts of these compounds. Therefore, the notion that milk would obstruct calcium absorption is largely unfounded. In fact, the protein in milk, particularly casein, has been shown to promote calcium absorption.

However, there are specific populations that may need to limit or avoid milk consumption. Individuals with lactose intolerance, a condition where the body cannot effectively digest lactose, may experience gastrointestinal discomfort when consuming milk. In such cases, lactose-free milk or dairy alternatives fortified with calcium can be excellent substitutes. Additionally, individuals with a milk allergy should completely avoid milk and dairy products, as they can trigger allergic reactions.

For those who are vegan or choose not to consume animal products, there are numerous plant-based sources of calcium, such as fortified almond milk, soy milk, leafy greens, and tofu. It is crucial for these individuals to ensure they are meeting their calcium needs through alternative sources or supplements.

In conclusion, the idea that milk should be avoided due to its potential to hinder calcium absorption is largely a myth. On the contrary, milk is a rich source of calcium that is beneficial for bone health and overall nutrition. While certain individuals may need to limit their milk intake due to lactose intolerance or allergies, for the general population, consuming milk can be a healthy choice that supports calcium intake. As always, it is advisable to consult with a healthcare professional or a registered dietitian for personalized dietary recommendations, especially if there are concerns about calcium intake or bone health.

Similar Q&A

Chocolate vs. Milk: How Chocolate Affects Calcium Absorption

It is well known that chocolate can reduce calcium absorption. However, when consuming certain breakfast cereals (such as chocolate-flavored cereals or chocolate milk), will calcium still be absorbed? Additionally, what is the extent of this reduction? Is it a 1:1 ratio? For exam...


Dr. Cai Xiuwen reply Nutrition
Hello! Chocolate contains a higher amount of oxalic acid, which binds with calcium to form calcium oxalate, thereby "reducing" calcium absorption. This is a matter of absorption levels, and it does not mean that calcium cannot be absorbed at all. The extent to which cho...

[Read More] Chocolate vs. Milk: How Chocolate Affects Calcium Absorption


Milk and Health Foods: Debunking Myths and Clarifying Nutrition for Seniors

In the media, we often hear various experts expressing different opinions about milk, leading to confusion and making it difficult for people to understand. There is a book that interviews renowned doctors from major hospitals about their daily health habits, and none of them enc...


Dr. Cai Xiuwen reply Nutrition
Hello Kiki, this is a very good question. Much of the scientific and medical knowledge comes from years of experience and research experiments. In the past, many studies have shown that various arguments have both pros and cons, and after further research, a consensus has been re...

[Read More] Milk and Health Foods: Debunking Myths and Clarifying Nutrition for Seniors


Calcium Sources: Milk vs. Soy Milk and Probiotics for Gut Health

Hello, Doctor: I have a few questions I would like to ask you. During my military service, I was educated that bone density starts to decline around the age of 35, so it's important to supplement calcium by drinking more milk. However, with the current food safety issues, I&...


Dr. Lin Minghui reply Gastroenterology and Hepatology
Hello: 1. Drinking milk can supplement calcium, and the Department of Health recommends 1 to 2 cups daily; however, excessive milk consumption may lead to bone loss, so it is important to avoid overconsumption. 2. Soy milk falls under the category of legumes and fish, while mi...

[Read More] Calcium Sources: Milk vs. Soy Milk and Probiotics for Gut Health


Understanding Bone Meal: Is It the Right Calcium Supplement for You?

Hello! I cannot drink milk and I'm afraid to eat fish. The pharmacist suggested that I buy calcium tablets and bone meal to supplement my calcium intake. Could you please explain what bone meal is? My doctor advised me to increase my calcium intake due to a spinal injury, an...


Dr. Chen Yuemei reply Pharmacology
Hello: I haven't heard of the medication "Bone Granules." I asked a pharmacist at a local pharmacy, but they couldn't provide much information, as there are many domestic pharmaceutical companies and products available. If the pharmacy doesn't carry this ...

[Read More] Understanding Bone Meal: Is It the Right Calcium Supplement for You?


Related FAQ

Calcium Absorption

(Nutrition)

Calcium Absorption

(Orthopedics)

Infant Nutrition

(Nutrition)

Eating Habits

(Nutrition)

Kidney

(Nutrition)

Fracture

(Nutrition)

Fish Bone Ingestion

(Otolaryngology)

Lutein

(Nutrition)

Vegetarian Nutrition

(Nutrition)

Fiber

(Nutrition)