Navigating Guilt and Selfishness: A Guide for Students in Need - Psychiatry

Share to:

Conscience~


Hello, doctor.
Recently, I've been troubled by my conscience regarding sharing study materials.
A classmate asked me for a recording of an entire subject, but he didn't record it himself.
I feel reluctant to share it because I worked hard to attend every class, and it seems unfair to give it away.
However, I also worry that if I don't share it, I might face consequences, like performing poorly on exams.
My conscience feels heavy, and I think it makes me selfish.

I often struggle with essay questions and when I ask others for help, they either forget or say they don't have it, or they expect something in return.
It seems like everyone can act this way naturally, and to some extent, everyone is selfish.
In the past, when I asked for help, I often received refusals, which left me disappointed in people.
A friend told me that I shouldn't feel guilty; if they succeed and I don't, what do I gain from it? What does friendship mean? Is that a true friend?
I feel like I should selflessly give to others, but I need to be skilled enough to do so.
I don't want to be foolish.
I've realized that only those without conflicting interests can be true friends.
When conflicts arise, it's rare to find someone willing to sacrifice for you.
Perhaps my expectations lead me to hope for kindness in return, which makes it hard for me to accept that I can also be selfish.

I find it difficult to share the recording because it makes me sad.
Maybe it's due to my lack of confidence; if I truly believed I had absorbed everything the teacher said, I wouldn't worry.
What's even more disheartening is realizing that my classmate's gradual conversations with me were just to confirm that I had the recording to ask for it later.
This makes me feel like I should avoid getting to know people to prevent feeling hurt.

This situation keeps bothering me.
If I know that sharing will make me unhappy, can I avoid doing things that upset me? People should prioritize themselves, but how do I find balance? I feel like everyone is selfish, which makes my mind feel overwhelmed.
Should I also become a selfish person since everyone else is? I wouldn't have to feel guilty towards anyone.
I really hope to overcome these emotions.
Please give me some advice.
Thank you.

ia, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2008/06/09

Dr. Chen Wenyu reply Psychiatry


Hello, IA: You have stirred my memories! In college, there was always a quiet group of classmates who not only focused on the lectures but also recorded them to listen to repeatedly at home, extracting key points and compiling them into handouts for all the students in the department to prepare for exams...
As it turns out, these classmates have all developed well and have great interpersonal relationships.
After all, before they wrote the handouts, they truly understood what the teachers taught; how could they possibly perform poorly on exams? By selflessly providing materials to their peers, how could their relationships be bad? What you have is just a recording; to be honest, being generous with it doesn’t matter.
If others want to do well, they still need to listen carefully, right? Your recordings will eventually reach your close friends, right? And there’s a chance that your close friends might share them, right? In that case, those you don’t want to give it to will still end up with it, won’t they? The outcome is the same, but the feelings of the recipients when they receive the recording will surely differ; they might feel grateful, or perhaps resentful, right? Many of the feedback from others may not be immediate.
Perhaps it will come years later! Or maybe when you are in need of help! And just at the moment you forget about these recordings! Thank you for your letter!

Reply Date: 2008/06/09

More Info


Navigating feelings of guilt and selfishness, especially as a student, can be quite challenging. It’s commendable that you are reflecting on these emotions and seeking to understand them better. The internal conflict you’re experiencing is common among students, particularly in competitive environments where academic performance and peer relationships are intertwined.

Firstly, it’s important to recognize that feeling guilty for not wanting to share your resources, such as your recorded lessons, is a natural response. You’ve invested time and effort into your studies, and it’s understandable to feel protective of what you’ve worked hard to achieve. This sense of ownership over your academic materials is not selfish; it’s a reflection of your dedication to your education.

On the other hand, the pressure to conform to social expectations can lead to feelings of guilt when you choose not to share. Your friend’s advice about the nature of friendships and the expectation of reciprocity in relationships is insightful. It’s true that many friendships can be transactional, where support is often contingent upon mutual benefit. However, this doesn’t mean that all friendships are devoid of genuine care and support. It’s crucial to find a balance between being generous and protecting your own interests.

Here are some strategies to help you navigate these feelings:
1. Set Boundaries: It’s okay to say no. Establish clear boundaries about what you are comfortable sharing. You can express your willingness to help while also protecting your own resources. For example, you might say, “I can share some notes, but I can’t provide the entire recording.”
2. Reflect on Your Values: Consider what you value in friendships. Do you prioritize loyalty, support, or mutual respect? Understanding your values can help you navigate relationships more effectively and make decisions that align with your beliefs.

3. Communicate Openly: If you feel comfortable, discuss your feelings with your classmates. They may not realize the pressure you’re under or how their requests affect you. Open communication can foster understanding and potentially lead to more supportive interactions.

4. Practice Self-Compassion: Acknowledge that it’s okay to prioritize your own needs. Being kind to yourself during this process is essential. Remind yourself that everyone has their own struggles, and it’s normal to feel conflicted about sharing.

5. Seek Support: If these feelings become overwhelming, consider talking to a counselor or therapist. They can provide a safe space to explore your emotions and help you develop coping strategies.

6. Focus on Personal Growth: Instead of comparing yourself to others, concentrate on your own academic journey. Celebrate your achievements and recognize that everyone has their own path. This shift in focus can reduce feelings of inadequacy and guilt.

7. Evaluate Friendships: Reflect on the quality of your friendships. Are they supportive and understanding? If certain relationships consistently leave you feeling drained or guilty, it may be worth reevaluating their importance in your life.

Ultimately, it’s about finding a balance between being a supportive friend and taking care of your own needs. It’s perfectly acceptable to prioritize your well-being while still being a good friend. Remember, self-care is not selfish; it’s necessary for maintaining healthy relationships and a positive mindset. As you navigate these complex emotions, be patient with yourself and recognize that it’s a process. You’re not alone in this journey, and seeking support is a sign of strength.

Similar Q&A

Navigating Friendship Dilemmas: Understanding Emotional Exhaustion and Self-Care

My mind is filled with conflicting thoughts, and I feel like I'm always engaging in people-pleasing behaviors. When someone sends me a message asking for research papers, I feel pressured to help them complete their request. If I say I can't, they might respond with, &q...


Dr. Chen Yuying reply Psychiatry
Hello Sine: You can choose to change or choose to remain the same. Change comes with its own advantages and disadvantages; for example, you may no longer be as popular as before, and classmates who only wanted to take advantage of you may drift away, but you can gain more persona...

[Read More] Navigating Friendship Dilemmas: Understanding Emotional Exhaustion and Self-Care


Helping Your Daughters Navigate School Social Challenges

Hello Dr. Chen. I have two daughters, one in fourth grade and the other in second grade. My eldest daughter has been feeling down lately because she overheard some classmates talking behind her back and even expressing a desire to hit her. When I asked her what bad things they sa...


Dr. Chen Meizhu reply Psychiatry
Hello: Regarding the issues with your eldest daughter, please first empathize with her discomfort from being spoken poorly of by classmates. For your youngest daughter, it’s important to acknowledge her feelings of disappointment from not being chosen and her jealousy towards her...

[Read More] Helping Your Daughters Navigate School Social Challenges


Understanding Self-Harm in Middle School: A Mental Health Perspective

Hello Doctor, after entering junior high school, although the academic pressure has increased, my parents tell me, "Just don't make the same mistakes next time." However, I often overhear them chatting with relatives, saying, "This is all because of playing on...


Dr. Qiu Junda reply Psychiatry
Hello. Your situation has caused significant distress both physically and mentally. It is important to inform a trusted adult to assist you in seeking an appointment with a pediatric mental health specialist as soon as possible. During this time, if you experience feelings of sad...

[Read More] Understanding Self-Harm in Middle School: A Mental Health Perspective


Understanding Intrusive Thoughts: Why We Struggle to Control Negative Thinking

I am currently a fourth-year student, and I feel that I study very hard. However, I also feel a lot of pressure and am constantly tense in everything I do. I hope to achieve good grades, but since the third year of junior high, I have been unable to overcome my psychological barr...


Dr. Ding Shuyan reply Psychiatry
Hello! First of all, I want to encourage you; you are a good person with a delicate mindset and the ability for self-reflection. The competitive mentality is something everyone experiences and is not pathological. The struggle between opposing thoughts is the source of our suffer...

[Read More] Understanding Intrusive Thoughts: Why We Struggle to Control Negative Thinking


Related FAQ

Self-Harm

(Psychiatry)

Psychological Counseling

(Psychiatry)

Emotions

(Psychiatry)

Heartbreak

(Psychiatry)

Binge Eating

(Psychiatry)

Cbt

(Psychiatry)

Bullying

(Psychiatry)

Talking To Oneself

(Psychiatry)

Ocd

(Psychiatry)

Child Psychology

(Psychiatry)