Are Wholesome Supplements Food or Medicine? Regulations - Pharmacology

Share to:

Is it food or medicine!?


Hello, I would like to ask whether the products "Ke Bu + Iron" and "Ke Bu + Zinc" produced by Wyeth in Taiwan are classified as food or medicine? I see that there are people reselling them online.
Is that permissible? If there are any issues, what channels can I seek assistance from? Thank you for taking the time to answer.

Sisi, 30~39 year old female. Ask Date: 2009/08/12

Dr. Huang Shenggang reply Pharmacology


The products "Ke Bu + Iron" and "Ke Bu + Zinc" produced by Wyeth in Taiwan are prescription medications (to be taken as directed by a physician, pharmacist, or licensed pharmacist).
They should be purchased from qualified pharmacies, and please do not buy medications from unknown sources.

Reply Date: 2009/08/12

More Info


In the context of dietary supplements and their classification as either food or medicine, it is essential to understand the regulatory frameworks that govern these products in different regions, including Taiwan. The classification of a product as a food or a medicine significantly affects how it is marketed, sold, and regulated.

In Taiwan, dietary supplements, such as the products you mentioned (e.g., 惠氏克補+鐵 and 克補+鋅), are generally classified as "health foods" or "nutritional supplements." These products are designed to provide specific nutrients that may be lacking in a person's diet or to support overall health. They are not classified as medicines unless they are specifically intended to treat, prevent, or diagnose a disease. This distinction is crucial because it determines the claims that can be made about the product and the regulatory requirements it must meet.

Health foods in Taiwan must comply with the regulations set forth by the Ministry of Health and Welfare. They are required to undergo safety assessments and must not make therapeutic claims unless they have been approved as a drug. Therefore, while these supplements can be beneficial for health, they should not be viewed as substitutes for medications prescribed by healthcare professionals.

Regarding the sale of these products online, it is generally permissible as long as the sellers comply with local regulations concerning labeling, advertising, and safety. However, consumers should be cautious when purchasing supplements from unverified sources, as the quality and safety of these products can vary significantly. It is advisable to purchase from reputable retailers or directly from manufacturers to ensure that the products meet safety standards.

If you encounter any issues with dietary supplements, such as adverse effects or concerns about their efficacy, you can seek guidance from several avenues:
1. Healthcare Professionals: Consulting with a doctor, pharmacist, or registered dietitian can provide personalized advice based on your health status and dietary needs.

2. Consumer Protection Agencies: In Taiwan, the Consumer Protection Committee can assist with complaints about misleading advertisements or unsafe products.

3. Health Authorities: The Ministry of Health and Welfare can provide information on regulations and safety standards for dietary supplements.

4. Online Resources: Websites of health organizations often provide valuable information about dietary supplements, including their benefits, risks, and regulatory status.

In summary, dietary supplements like 惠氏克補+鐵 and 克補+鋅 are classified as health foods in Taiwan, not medicines, unless they have been specifically approved for therapeutic use. They can be sold online, but consumers should ensure they are purchasing from reputable sources. If issues arise, various channels are available for seeking assistance and information. Understanding these distinctions and regulations is crucial for making informed decisions about dietary supplements and their role in health and wellness.

Similar Q&A

Understanding Dietary Supplements: Benefits and Drawbacks of Regulations

What are health supplements? What are the advantages and disadvantages of the related regulations?


Dr. Shi Guimei reply Nutrition
Hello! I believe the dietary supplements you mentioned refer to health foods. Health foods are defined as foods that provide specific nutrients or have particular health benefits, which are specially labeled or advertised, and are not intended for the treatment or correction of h...

[Read More] Understanding Dietary Supplements: Benefits and Drawbacks of Regulations


Are Health Supplements Safe? Understanding Risks and Misleading Claims

Recently, the adults in my household have become obsessed with a series of products that resemble health foods. I checked online and found that they are not registered as health foods. I have advised my parents not to consume unverified health products, but they seem to be infatu...


Dr. Hou Fangmin reply Pharmacology
Hello: Regarding the issue of health supplements, I often receive inquiries about various health products. My response is that without a physician's diagnosis, taking medications indiscriminately will only increase the burden on the liver and kidneys, potentially causing adv...

[Read More] Are Health Supplements Safe? Understanding Risks and Misleading Claims


Understanding Health Food Claims: How Are They Regulated and Verified?

Could you please explain how the unique functions of health supplements are recognized in the market? How does the government determine the validity of these health supplements? What recognized functions do health supplements currently have? There are many health supplements avai...


Dr. Cai Xiuwen reply Nutrition
Hello! According to the regulations of the Health Food Management Act, health foods must meet the following requirements: 1. They must have clearly defined health-promoting ingredients, and the reasonable intake levels of these products must be scientifically substantiated. The...

[Read More] Understanding Health Food Claims: How Are They Regulated and Verified?


Exploring the Benefits and Risks of Whey Protein for Health

My sister suffers from insomnia and emotional instability. Although she is on medication, a friend has strongly recommended "whey protein," claiming that this supplement can enhance the immune system, boost resistance, and repair bodily functions. I am skeptical about t...


Dr. Liao Lingmei reply Pharmacology
Dear Yu-Zai: Regarding your issues with insomnia and mental instability, it is important to determine whether these conditions are classified as specific medical disorders by a physician. In general, in addition to medication, psychological support from family and friends, as wel...

[Read More] Exploring the Benefits and Risks of Whey Protein for Health


Related FAQ

Dietary Supplements

(Pharmacology)

Regulations

(Pharmacology)

Herbal Medicine

(Pharmacology)

Medication Safety

(Pharmacology)

Weight Loss Products

(Pharmacology)

Health Care

(Pharmacology)

Health Supplements

(Internal Medicine)

Medication Consultation

(Nutrition)

Health Supplements

(Pediatrics)

Health Supplements

(Nutrition)