Treatment in nursing homes?
The family member is elderly and has been living in a nursing home for a long time, with limited mobility and spending most of the time in bed.
They require assistance from medical staff to turn from side to side.
According to the medical staff, the family member tends to bend their arms and rest them on their chest, so they have tied their hands with a rope.
I would like to understand what kind of medical condition the family member has and whether this practice in the nursing home is appropriate.
Most importantly, are there alternative methods, such as pharmacological treatment or other approaches, to avoid tying the hands with a rope? It seems inappropriate to restrain the hands in this manner, so I would like to consult a physician.
Thank you.
ar4031b, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2009/09/13
Dr. Yin Xinbei reply Rehabilitation
Medical restraints are implemented to prevent agitated patients from pulling out their tubes (such as nasogastric tubes or IV lines), which is a necessary measure.
Typically, patients are fitted with restraint gloves that have fabric straps, which are then tied to the bed rails.
The description in the question regarding "tying both hands with a rope" is unclear; it should specify what type of rope is used and where it is tied.
At a minimum, fabric strips should be used, and the wrist should not be tightly bound to avoid injury to the patient.
If the purpose is to prevent flexion contractures of the arms, currently, there are only two medical approaches: immobilization and rehabilitation (joint mobility exercises).
Pharmacological treatment cannot prevent contractures.
In situations where adequate rehabilitation cannot be provided in nursing homes, family members can purchase restraint gloves from medical supply stores or pharmacies for use in the nursing home.
However, unless the patient is agitated, the restraint period should ideally be limited to eight hours per day, and it should not be continuous; there should be breaks to allow the patient to move their hands.
If restraints are not used, custom splints can be ordered from the rehabilitation department (which is covered by health insurance) to help prevent contractures.
Reply Date: 2009/09/13
More Info
When dealing with bedridden patients in nursing homes, it is crucial to understand the underlying medical conditions that may lead to such a situation, as well as the appropriate care practices that should be employed to ensure their comfort and dignity. In your case, it seems that your family member has been unable to move independently for an extended period, which can lead to a range of complications, including muscle atrophy, pressure ulcers, and psychological distress.
The practice of restraining a patient's hands, as described in your situation, raises significant ethical and medical concerns. Restraining a patient, especially with something as harsh as ropes, can lead to feelings of helplessness, anxiety, and even aggression. It is essential to consider the reasons behind the behavior that led to the use of restraints. If the patient is bending their arms and placing their hands on their chest, it may be a natural response to discomfort or a way to seek security. Instead of using restraints, healthcare providers should explore alternative methods to manage such behaviors.
One approach is to conduct a thorough assessment of the patient's physical and psychological needs. This assessment can help identify any underlying pain, discomfort, or anxiety that may be causing the patient to adopt certain positions. Addressing these issues through appropriate pain management, physical therapy, or psychological support can often reduce the need for restraints.
In terms of medication, there are various options available that can help manage anxiety or agitation in patients without resorting to physical restraints. Medications such as anxiolytics or antipsychotics may be prescribed, but they should be used judiciously and under the guidance of a healthcare professional. It is essential to monitor the patient closely for any side effects or adverse reactions to these medications.
Additionally, implementing a more person-centered care approach can significantly improve the quality of life for bedridden patients. This approach involves engaging the patient in their care plan, providing them with choices whenever possible, and ensuring that their preferences and dignity are respected. For example, using soft restraints or adaptive devices designed for comfort can be a more humane alternative to traditional restraints. These devices can help prevent the patient from inadvertently harming themselves while still allowing for some degree of movement.
Furthermore, regular repositioning is vital to prevent pressure ulcers and promote circulation. Nursing staff should be trained in proper techniques for turning and repositioning patients to minimize discomfort and risk of injury. Utilizing specialized mattresses or cushions can also help alleviate pressure points and enhance comfort.
In summary, the use of restraints, particularly in the form of ropes, is generally not considered an appropriate practice in nursing homes. Instead, healthcare providers should focus on understanding the patient's needs, exploring alternative management strategies, and fostering a supportive environment that prioritizes the patient's dignity and well-being. If you have concerns about the care your family member is receiving, it may be beneficial to discuss these issues with the nursing home staff or seek a second opinion from a medical professional who specializes in geriatric care.
Similar Q&A
Stroke Rehabilitation for Bedridden Patients: Options and Air Mattress Benefits
My grandfather has been bedridden for five years after a stroke. How can he undergo rehabilitation? Is it possible to apply for an air mattress?
Dr. Chen Xianchang reply Rehabilitation
1. You can obtain educational pamphlets from the rehabilitation department, which provide guidance on various rehabilitation exercises, especially positioning and joint mobility. 2. Patients who are bedridden for an extended period should be frequently repositioned and have the...[Read More] Stroke Rehabilitation for Bedridden Patients: Options and Air Mattress Benefits
How to Manage Bedsores in Long-Term Care Patients?
Hello Dr. Liu: My sister has been bedridden for 20 years due to cerebellar ataxia, and she has always been cared for by our mother. Recently, a wound similar to a "pressure ulcer" has appeared near her knee, and despite applying medication on her own, it seems to be wor...
Dr. Liu Jinyong reply Family Medicine
Hello: Regarding Ling Shu's issue with pressure ulcers, it is recommended that you visit a general surgeon at a hospital near your residence under the Ministry of Health and Welfare. Since Ling Shu has been bedridden for a long time, it is advised to reposition her every two...[Read More] How to Manage Bedsores in Long-Term Care Patients?
Rehabilitation Strategies for Elderly Patients with Osteoporosis
Hello, doctor. My grandmother is currently 93 years old and has osteoporosis. Last year, she underwent a vertebroplasty, but due to unsatisfactory results, she can only lie in bed now and is unable to get up, although she can still turn herself. However, there are some issues: ...
Dr. Xu Zhenrong reply Rehabilitation
Hello, Li Li's online friend: Based on your description, your grandmother has osteoporosis and has been bedridden for a long time. Regarding osteoporosis, it is generally understood that bone density begins to gradually decline after the age of 35, with a significant loss oc...[Read More] Rehabilitation Strategies for Elderly Patients with Osteoporosis
Understanding Care Options for Patients with Mental Health and Mobility Issues
Hello, I would like to inquire about the target population for your nursing home services. Our family has a member with a mental illness who experienced a crisis last year, resulting in lower limb paralysis and bowel function issues. Currently, he is able to move around in a whee...
Dr. Wang Zhenyang reply Psychiatry
Hello, Sweet Potato: You have a family member with a mental illness and lower limb paralysis, which I believe has affected the quality of life for you and your family. Regarding your concerns, here are a few suggestions: (1) You should first visit a nearby hospital with a psychia...[Read More] Understanding Care Options for Patients with Mental Health and Mobility Issues
Related FAQ
(Rehabilitation)
Flat Feet(Rehabilitation)
Sleep(Rehabilitation)
Old Injury Pain(Rehabilitation)
Torticollis(Rehabilitation)
Dislocation(Rehabilitation)
Leg(Rehabilitation)
Bone Spur(Rehabilitation)
Medication Consultation(Rehabilitation)
Family Medicine(Rehabilitation)