Is Spinach Really a Good Source of Iron? Debunking Common Myths - Nutrition

Share to:

Spinach


Hello, I would like to ask a question about spinach: For a long time, newspapers, magazines, and even teachers have taught that "spinach is rich in iron." However, recently I have come across several health websites reporting the opposite, stating that "the iron content in spinach is not particularly high," "the iron in spinach is not easily absorbed by the body," or "spinach tends to produce oxalates," among other claims.
These articles completely contradict the common knowledge I had.
Could you please clarify which statement is correct? As a vegetarian (lacto-vegetarian), I rely on consuming a large amount of spinach to supplement my iron intake, but I am really, really confused right now.
Please help me, thank you!

Tsuyoshi, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2002/10/07

Dr. Shi Guimei reply Nutrition


Hello Tsuyoshi: Indeed, spinach contains oxalic acid, which can interfere with iron absorption.
The absorption of iron in the human body is influenced by several factors: the form of iron (only ferrous iron can be absorbed in the small intestine); the presence of phosphates, oxalates, and phytates in food (all three can bind with iron to form insoluble compounds, hindering its absorption); and the body's iron needs (iron absorption can increase according to the body's requirements).

Additionally, here are some common vegetables with relatively high iron content (measured in milligrams of iron per 100 grams of edible portion): dried radish 2.1, canned green bamboo shoots 2.5, Sichuan pepper 3.1, dried cabbage 5.2, chrysanthemum greens 3.3, red amaranth 4.1, red spinach 12.0, spinach 4.9, black beet 6.7, and Penghu loofah 3.4 (data source: Food Nutrition Composition Database of Taiwan, June 1997 edition).

Since you mentioned that you are a lacto-vegetarian, it is recommended to consider purchasing iron-fortified milk powder and consuming 1 to 2 cups daily, with each cup being 240cc, to increase your iron intake.

Wishing you and your family peace and happiness.
Best regards,
Shih Kuei-Mei, Head of the Nutrition Department, Taoyuan Hospital, Ministry of Health and Welfare.

Reply Date: 2002/10/07

More Info


Spinach has long been touted as a rich source of iron, often highlighted in dietary recommendations, especially for vegetarians and those looking to increase their iron intake. However, recent discussions in nutritional science have brought to light some important nuances regarding spinach and its iron content, leading to confusion among consumers. Let's delve into the facts and clarify the myths surrounding spinach as a source of iron.

Firstly, it is true that spinach contains iron; however, the type of iron present in spinach is non-heme iron, which is less readily absorbed by the body compared to heme iron found in animal products. Heme iron, which is found in meat, poultry, and fish, is absorbed at a rate of about 15-35%, while non-heme iron from plant sources like spinach is absorbed at a much lower rate, typically around 2-20%. This means that even though spinach contains iron, the amount that your body can actually utilize is significantly less than what is found in animal sources.

Moreover, spinach is high in oxalates, which are compounds that can bind to iron and inhibit its absorption. This means that while you might consume a good amount of spinach, the actual bioavailability of iron is reduced due to the presence of these oxalates. In fact, the oxalate content in spinach can be quite high, which is why some nutritionists recommend cooking spinach to reduce its oxalate levels, thereby potentially increasing the absorption of iron and other minerals.

Another important aspect to consider is the overall dietary context. Consuming vitamin C-rich foods alongside non-heme iron sources can significantly enhance iron absorption. For instance, pairing spinach with citrus fruits, bell peppers, or tomatoes can help improve the amount of iron your body absorbs. This is an important strategy for vegetarians and vegans who rely on plant-based sources of iron.

For individuals who are vegetarian or vegan, it is crucial to diversify iron sources. Other plant-based foods that are good sources of iron include lentils, chickpeas, quinoa, fortified cereals, pumpkin seeds, and tofu. Incorporating a variety of these foods into your diet can help ensure adequate iron intake.

In summary, while spinach does contain iron, it is not as rich a source as once believed, primarily due to the type of iron it contains and the presence of oxalates that inhibit absorption. For those relying on spinach as a primary source of iron, it is essential to consider cooking methods, food pairings, and overall dietary variety to ensure sufficient iron intake. If you are concerned about your iron levels, it may be beneficial to consult with a healthcare provider or a registered dietitian who can provide personalized advice based on your dietary habits and nutritional needs.

Similar Q&A

Calcium and Iron Intake: Myths and Facts About Supplementation

After reading articles published by other users, I learned that the simultaneous intake of calcium and iron is not effective. However, there are commercially available milk powders that contain both "high iron and high calcium." Isn't that misleading?


Dr. Hu Yuqing reply Nutrition
Hello NONO: "High Iron, High Calcium" is a nutritional claim. Please refer to the Food Information Network at food.doh.gov.tw under Nutrition and You > Nutritional Labeling > Nutritional Claim Announcements http://www.doh.gov.tw/ufile/Doc/Regulations_on_Nutritiona...

[Read More] Calcium and Iron Intake: Myths and Facts About Supplementation


Essential Foods for a High Zinc, Low Copper Diet for Children

My ten-year-old son is 135 cm tall and weighs 27 kg. He has Tourette syndrome, and the doctor advised a high-zinc, low-copper diet. He also has mild Mediterranean anemia. What types of foods should I prepare and what should I avoid to accommodate his needs? Thank you!


Dr. Lu Guanqi reply Nutrition
Hello, Xiao Feng. Zinc, copper, iron, and manganese are all trace metal elements that the human body requires. They are widely found in various foods and often overlap, such as in seafood, shellfish, lean meats, liver, legumes, and their products. Foods high in zinc include seafo...

[Read More] Essential Foods for a High Zinc, Low Copper Diet for Children


Foods to Lower High Iron Levels in Your Blood

What foods can help improve high iron levels in the blood?


Dr. Tang Weili reply Nutrition
Dear Yiya, Hello, has your doctor informed you about the reasons for your elevated iron levels? Is it possible to improve this through physiological metabolism? Currently, you should avoid consuming processed foods that claim to be high in iron, such as iron-fortified milk powde...

[Read More] Foods to Lower High Iron Levels in Your Blood


Can I Eat Iron-Rich Foods After My Second Dose?

Hello, doctor. I have a history of hereditary anemia. After receiving my second dose, I experienced significant bleeding, which has worsened my anemia. Just climbing a flight of stairs makes me feel dizzy. May I eat foods that help with blood replenishment, such as red beans, bee...


Dr. Cao Guotao reply Obstetrics and Gynecology
Hello, in addition to taking iron supplements, the foods you listed are also helpful. Additionally, it is important to investigate the underlying causes of anemia for proper treatment. Wishing you good health.

[Read More] Can I Eat Iron-Rich Foods After My Second Dose?


Related FAQ

Anemia

(Nutrition)

Eating Habits

(Nutrition)

Vegetarian Nutrition

(Nutrition)

Lutein

(Nutrition)

Vegetable Soup

(Nutrition)

Menstrual Period

(Nutrition)

Others

(Nutrition)

Six Food Groups

(Nutrition)

Fiber

(Nutrition)

Uric Acid

(Nutrition)