Managing Osteoporosis: Best Practices for Calcium Supplementation with Dried Fish - Internal Medicine

Share to:

Osteoporosis


Hello, doctor.
Thank you for your hard work.
My mother has osteoporosis and recently bought small dried fish to supplement calcium.
1: I am not sure what foods or medications should not be combined with small dried fish.
2: How should it be taken correctly to maximize its effectiveness? 3: Is it better to buy cooked small dried fish that are sold in the market? Thank you.

Cai Xiaojie, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2002/11/28

Dr. Xiao Yongxun reply Internal Medicine


Hello: In response to your question, non-pharmacological treatment options for osteoporosis include: 1.
Improving lifestyle habits: a.
Avoid smoking, excessive alcohol consumption, and excessive caffeine intake.
b.
Maintain a balanced diet rich in calcium, including foods like milk, yogurt, and cooked legumes.
c.
Limit the intake of excessive meat and processed foods.
2.
Engage in regular exercise, aiming for 30-60 minutes at least three times a week, including weight-bearing exercises such as walking, running, stair climbing, and hiking.
Regarding your concerns: 1.
If dried small fish have undergone nitration, they should be avoided with fermented foods to prevent the formation of carcinogens, and high-calcium foods should also be avoided with high-oxalate foods (such as spinach) to prevent calcium oxalate stone formation.
2.
Dried small fish are generally better absorbed when consumed with higher moisture content, which may enhance their effectiveness.
3.
There are no strict requirements regarding whether the dried small fish should be cooked; just adhere to the aforementioned principles.
Additionally, please discuss your osteoporosis condition in detail with your physician to develop an appropriate treatment plan.

Reply Date: 2002/11/28

More Info


Managing osteoporosis effectively requires a comprehensive approach, particularly when it comes to calcium supplementation. Dried fish, such as small fish or anchovies, can be an excellent source of calcium, especially for individuals who cannot consume dairy products. Here’s a detailed response to your questions regarding the use of dried fish for calcium supplementation.


1. Compatibility with Other Foods or Medications
When considering the consumption of dried fish for calcium supplementation, it is important to be aware of potential interactions with other foods and medications. Generally, dried fish is safe to consume with most foods; however, there are a few considerations:
- Oxalate-Rich Foods: Foods high in oxalates, such as spinach, rhubarb, and certain nuts, can inhibit calcium absorption. It is advisable to consume dried fish separately from these foods to maximize calcium uptake.


- Iron Supplements: If your mother is taking iron supplements, it is best to space the intake of dried fish and iron supplements apart by at least two hours. Calcium can interfere with the absorption of iron.

- Certain Medications: Some medications, particularly those for osteoporosis (like bisphosphonates), may have specific instructions regarding calcium intake. It is crucial to consult with a healthcare provider or pharmacist to ensure that there are no contraindications.


2. Correct Usage for Maximum Effectiveness
To maximize the benefits of calcium from dried fish, consider the following guidelines:
- Serving Size: Ensure that the serving size of dried fish is adequate to meet calcium needs. For example, a typical serving of small dried fish can provide a significant amount of calcium, but it’s essential to check the nutritional label for specific calcium content.

- Timing: It is generally recommended to consume calcium-rich foods or supplements at different times throughout the day to enhance absorption. For instance, if your mother takes calcium supplements, she might want to eat dried fish at a different meal.

- Cooking Methods: While dried fish is often consumed as-is, incorporating it into meals (e.g., soups, salads, or rice dishes) can enhance palatability and increase overall nutrient intake. Cooking does not significantly reduce the calcium content, but it can improve digestibility and flavor.


3. Choosing Cooked vs. Raw Dried Fish
When purchasing dried fish, it is advisable to choose products that are cooked or processed in a way that ensures safety and palatability. Here are some points to consider:
- Safety: Cooked dried fish is generally safer as it reduces the risk of foodborne illnesses. Ensure that the product is from a reputable source and has been properly processed.

- Nutritional Value: Cooked dried fish retains most of its nutritional value, including calcium. However, check the packaging to ensure that it has not been overly processed, which can sometimes lead to nutrient loss.

- Flavor and Texture: Cooked dried fish may be more palatable, especially for those who are not accustomed to the taste of raw dried fish. This can encourage regular consumption, which is essential for maintaining adequate calcium levels.


Additional Considerations
In addition to dried fish, it is important for your mother to incorporate a variety of calcium-rich foods into her diet. Other sources include leafy greens (like kale and bok choy), fortified plant-based milks, tofu, and nuts. Vitamin D is also crucial for calcium absorption, so ensure she gets adequate sunlight exposure or consider supplements if necessary.

Lastly, regular check-ups with a healthcare provider are essential for monitoring bone health and adjusting dietary or supplementation strategies as needed. Osteoporosis management is a long-term commitment, and a balanced diet, along with appropriate physical activity, plays a vital role in maintaining bone density and overall health.

Similar Q&A

The Calcium-Protein Battle: Understanding Osteoporosis Risks and Nutrition

I apologize for the intrusion. (I am currently serving at National Chiao Tung University) I have a question to ask. A colleague sent me an email, and I am unsure of its authenticity. Could Director Tang please respond? Thank you! The content is as follows: ----- Original Message ...


Dr. Tang Weili reply Nutrition
The causes of osteoporosis are complex. Approximately 1 in 3 women and 1 in 6 men will experience a hip fracture as they age. Women's bones are generally smaller and less dense than men's, and the decline in female hormones after menopause exacerbates bone loss. Consequ...

[Read More] The Calcium-Protein Battle: Understanding Osteoporosis Risks and Nutrition


Optimal Supplementation for Osteoporosis: Calcium, Fish Oil, and Vitamins

Hello, thank you for your valuable time in reviewing and responding. My mother is 63 years old and has been taking calcium supplements to help with osteoporosis. She is using the 500mg calcium with D3 and K2 from Life Extension. After exercising, she sometimes feels soreness and ...


Dr. Chen Bochen reply Orthopedics
Hello, regarding your question, I found online that fish oil and calcium supplements may have interactions. How should I supplement them properly? >>> It is recommended to take them at least two hours apart. Is it okay to take a multivitamin like Centrum after breakfast ...

[Read More] Optimal Supplementation for Osteoporosis: Calcium, Fish Oil, and Vitamins


Understanding Bone Meal: Is It the Right Calcium Supplement for You?

Hello! I cannot drink milk and I'm afraid to eat fish. The pharmacist suggested that I buy calcium tablets and bone meal to supplement my calcium intake. Could you please explain what bone meal is? My doctor advised me to increase my calcium intake due to a spinal injury, an...


Dr. Chen Yuemei reply Pharmacology
Hello: I haven't heard of the medication "Bone Granules." I asked a pharmacist at a local pharmacy, but they couldn't provide much information, as there are many domestic pharmaceutical companies and products available. If the pharmacy doesn't carry this ...

[Read More] Understanding Bone Meal: Is It the Right Calcium Supplement for You?


Best Cooking Methods to Preserve Calcium for Osteoporosis Patients

My friend has osteoporosis. The doctor told her to adjust her diet. She asked me to inquire which of the five cooking methods—steaming, boiling, pan-frying, stir-frying, or baking—preserves calcium in food the best. Is there any research on this topic? Thank you for your response...


Dr. Shi Guimei reply Nutrition
Hello! The dietary principles for osteoporosis should focus on two aspects: increasing calcium intake and absorption, and reducing calcium loss. To increase calcium intake and absorption, one should include: vitamin D, dairy products, legumes and their products, seafood, black se...

[Read More] Best Cooking Methods to Preserve Calcium for Osteoporosis Patients


Related FAQ

Calcium Absorption

(Nutrition)

Fish Bone

(Otolaryngology)

Fracture

(Nutrition)

Health Supplements

(Internal Medicine)

Osteoporosis

(Orthopedics)

Dietary Supplements

(Orthopedics)

Dietary Consultation

(Internal Medicine)

Skeleton

(Family Medicine)

Elderly

(Nutrition)

Family Medicine

(Nutrition)