8 Foods That Can Be Deadly If Overconsumed: Fact or Myth? - Nutrition

Share to:

Are these eight things really deadly if consumed in excess?


These eight foods can be deadly if consumed in excess—really? I saw this information online and I'm skeptical about its content, so I want to confirm:
(1) Century Egg: Manufacturers often add a certain amount of lead during the production of century eggs.
Frequent consumption can lead to lead poisoning and also cause calcium loss in the body.
(2) Stinky Tofu: During the fermentation process, stinky tofu is highly susceptible to microbial contamination and can release large amounts of basic nitrogen and hydrogen sulfide, which are harmful decomposition products of protein.
(3) Monosodium Glutamate (MSG): The recommended daily intake of MSG should not exceed six grams per person, as excessive consumption can be harmful.
(4) Spinach: While spinach is nutritious, it contains oxalic acid, which binds with valuable elements like zinc and calcium in food, leading to their excretion from the body and resulting in deficiencies of these minerals.
"Men lacking zinc may struggle to stand tall."
(5) Pork Liver: One kilogram of pork liver contains over 400 milligrams of cholesterol.
Excessive cholesterol intake can lead to atherosclerosis.
(6) Grilled Meat: The grilling process can produce harmful substances such as benzene, which are carcinogenic.
(7) Pickled Vegetables: If not prepared properly, pickled vegetables can contain carcinogens and nitrosamines, leading to health issues with prolonged consumption.
(8) Fried Dough Sticks: The alum in fried dough sticks is an inorganic substance containing aluminum, which should not be consumed frequently.

William, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2004/08/12

Dr. Xie Huimin reply Nutrition


Hello William: Generally, processed foods contain food additives to extend shelf life and enhance flavor.
Normally, the Department of Health has established usage standards.
If the production does not exceed these standards and our consumption frequency is low, there is no need to worry about food additives! Regarding your questions, here are some references:
(1) The traditional method of making century eggs involves coating duck or chicken eggs with an alkaline paste for curing, which causes the yolk and white to gel and develop a matured flavor.
The alkaline paste typically consists of two types: (a) quicklime, wood ash, sodium carbonate, salt, and water; (b) black tea, lime, salt, wood ash, and water.
The most challenging part of making century eggs is the gelling process.
Producers may add lead salts or copper salts to prevent liquefaction after gelling or to maintain the tea-brown color of the eggs.
(If added, the Department of Health stipulates that the allowable lead content in century eggs must not exceed 2 ppm.) To avoid selecting century eggs with lead salts, one should pay attention when choosing; generally, lead-free century eggs have a cleaner, whiter shell and interior without black spots, and the contents (egg white) should be a reddish-brown green rather than a deep black-green.
Additionally, look for century eggs labeled as high-quality.

(2) The production methods for stinky tofu vary by vendor, and the government may not be able to monitor them, so it is advisable to consume this type of food sparingly.

(3) The chemical composition of MSG (monosodium glutamate) is sodium glutamate.
In terms of nutrition, we recommend using it sparingly, especially for patients with certain conditions, such as hypertension.
If using MSG, it can be added after cooking when the heat is turned off, allowing the flavor to be released without producing toxic substances (generally, heating above 120 degrees Celsius for extended periods can produce harmful substances).
Consuming large amounts of MSG or free glutamate (≥3g) at once may trigger a temporary physical reaction known as "Chinese Restaurant Syndrome."
(4) Many plant-based foods contain oxalic acid or phytic acid, which can reduce calcium absorption when combined with calcium.
When supplementing with high-calcium foods, it is advisable to avoid consuming them with vegetables high in oxalic or phytic acid.

(5) Cholesterol has its functions, but for patients with hyperlipidemia, foods high in cholesterol should be consumed in moderation.
Foods high in cholesterol include animal organs (brain, liver, kidneys), shrimp and crab roe, and other animal fats.

(6) Cooking meat over charcoal can produce carcinogenic mutations in proteins, so it is recommended to avoid consuming grilled foods.

(7) Generally, pickled foods come with safety labels, so when purchasing, avoid those with unknown origins or incomplete packaging labels.
Additionally, pickled foods typically contain high levels of salt and should not be consumed in excess.

(8) Alum is classified as a leavening agent among chemical additives and is commonly used in making Taiwanese fried dough sticks.
It acts as a slow-reacting acidic agent, promoting the production of carbon dioxide gas from baking soda in the dough (baking soda is an alkaline powder that reacts better in acidic environments than in neutral ones), aiding in the expansion of the fried dough sticks and making them crispy, especially on the surface.
Furthermore, fried foods should be consumed sparingly; it is generally recommended to limit consumption to 1-2 times a month to reduce cumulative harm to your health.

Reply Date: 2004/08/12

More Info


The claim that certain foods can be deadly if overconsumed is a mix of fact and myth, and it’s essential to approach this topic with a nuanced understanding of nutrition and food safety. Let's break down the eight foods mentioned and their potential risks.

1. Century Eggs (皮蛋): Traditional century eggs are made using alkaline substances, and while there have been concerns about lead contamination due to improper manufacturing practices, reputable producers adhere to safety regulations. Lead poisoning is indeed a serious health risk, but consuming century eggs in moderation from trusted sources is generally safe. The calcium loss mentioned is more about the overall dietary balance rather than a direct effect of eating century eggs.

2. Stinky Tofu (臭豆腐): This fermented food can be a breeding ground for harmful bacteria if not prepared correctly. The fermentation process can lead to the production of harmful substances, but again, this risk is mitigated by sourcing from reputable vendors. Moderation is key, and it’s wise to be cautious with street food or unregulated sources.

3. Monosodium Glutamate (MSG): While some people report sensitivity to MSG, the scientific consensus is that it is safe for the general population when consumed in moderation. The recommendation of not exceeding 6 grams per day is a guideline to prevent potential adverse reactions, but it is not inherently toxic.

4. Spinach (菠菜): Spinach is indeed rich in nutrients but contains oxalic acid, which can bind to calcium and zinc, potentially leading to deficiencies if consumed in excessive amounts without a balanced diet. However, the health benefits of spinach generally outweigh the risks when eaten as part of a varied diet.

5. Pork Liver (豬肝): Liver is high in cholesterol and vitamin A. While it can be part of a healthy diet, excessive consumption can lead to hypercholesterolemia and vitamin A toxicity. Moderation is crucial, especially for individuals with pre-existing health conditions.

6. Grilled Meat (烤肉): Cooking meat at high temperatures, especially grilling, can produce harmful compounds like heterocyclic amines (HCAs) and polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs), which are linked to cancer. Limiting charred or heavily grilled meats and incorporating a variety of cooking methods can reduce these risks.

7. Pickled Vegetables (醃菜): Improperly prepared pickled foods can indeed contain harmful substances, including nitrosamines, which are carcinogenic. However, commercially prepared pickles typically follow safety guidelines. It’s advisable to consume pickled foods in moderation due to their high sodium content.

8. Fried Dough (油條): The use of aluminum compounds in some fried foods raises concerns about aluminum exposure. While occasional consumption is unlikely to pose a significant risk, frequent intake of fried foods can lead to other health issues, such as obesity and heart disease.

In conclusion, while there are valid concerns regarding the overconsumption of these foods, the key takeaway is moderation and sourcing from reputable producers. A balanced diet that includes a variety of foods is essential for good health. It’s also important to be aware of individual health conditions that may require dietary adjustments. Consulting with a healthcare professional or a registered dietitian can provide personalized guidance tailored to individual health needs.

Similar Q&A

Consulting Experts on Food Compatibility: Debunking Common Myths

I apologize for the interruption. I am looking for an expert who can assist with information verification. After compiling data from books and online sources, I have categorized a total of 68 items into four groups: protein sources (eggs, beans, fish, and meat), vegetables, fruit...


Dr. Xie Peiru reply Nutrition
Hello: I am unable to answer your question, and I apologize for that! Wishing you good health! Best regards, Pei-Ju from Qihospital.

[Read More] Consulting Experts on Food Compatibility: Debunking Common Myths


How to Eat Healthy on a Tight Schedule Without Overdoing Seasonings

Hello, nutritionist: I mostly eat out for my three meals, so I have difficulty controlling the amounts of oil, salt, monosodium glutamate, and other seasonings used in cooking. I assume I might be consuming them in excess. How can I obtain the necessary nutrients without putting ...


Dr. Shi Guimei reply Nutrition
Hello! People who eat out often find it challenging to control the amounts of oil, salt, and other seasonings. However, by using some simple techniques, it is indeed possible to reduce the intake of these ingredients. One effective method is to blanch greasy or heavily flavored d...

[Read More] How to Eat Healthy on a Tight Schedule Without Overdoing Seasonings


Is Eating Instant Noodles Too Often Bad for Your Health?

Hello, doctor. I've often heard that eating too much instant noodles can turn you into a mummy. Is this true? I usually eat two to three bowls of instant noodles each week. Does this have any impact on my health? Thank you.


Dr. Liu Qiaoyun reply Nutrition
Hello, Xiao Hong: Eating instant noodles will not turn you into a mummy because instant noodles do not contain preservatives. The common additives in instant noodles are mainly spices and antioxidants, which are added to prevent the oxidation of fats during storage due to heat or...

[Read More] Is Eating Instant Noodles Too Often Bad for Your Health?


Is Overeating High-Calorie Foods Safe for My Growing Brother?

Hello, doctor: I would like to ask about height-related issues. My younger brother is currently in the fifth grade and had an examination at Chang Gung Memorial Hospital. The doctor mentioned that he is lacking zinc in his diet, which is causing him to grow slowly, and advised th...


Dr. Cai Zonglin reply Internal Medicine
If you want to supplement zinc, foods rich in zinc include oysters or shellfish, red meat, whole grains, oats, pumpkin seeds, and sunflower seeds. You may also consult a nutritionist for further information. High-calorie foods that are low in zinc can lead to weight gain, which c...

[Read More] Is Overeating High-Calorie Foods Safe for My Growing Brother?


Related FAQ

Food Safety

(Nutrition)

Eating Habits

(Nutrition)

Elderly

(Nutrition)

Bulimia

(Nutrition)

Food Composition Database

(Nutrition)

Stroke Diet

(Nutrition)

Underweight

(Nutrition)

Fracture

(Nutrition)

Six Food Groups

(Nutrition)

Vegetable Soup

(Nutrition)