Is Sparkling Water Acidic or Alkaline? Benefits and Myths Explained

Carbonated water

Hello, Nutritionist: I would like to ask you two questions.

1.
Is carbonated water considered alkaline or acidic? Once ingested, can it truly produce acid-base neutralization, or does it require the addition of other foods? Is the popular carbonated water weight loss method in Japan really effective?
2.
Regarding dietary supplements (collagen + chlorella + vitamin C + coix seed extract + vitamin B), all from DHC, could consuming these in excess impose a burden on the body? Thank you!

Ya Ya, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2009/10/08

Dr. Cai Xiuwen reply Nutrition

Hello! The acidity and alkalinity of food are related to their mineral content, rather than being determined by taste, and they cannot be assessed using pH paper.
Foods that contain higher amounts of sodium, potassium, calcium, and magnesium are converted into alkaline oxides in the body, which are referred to as alkaline foods.
In contrast, foods that contain more phosphate, sulfur, and chloride ions are considered acidic foods, such as meats, eggs, and grains.
Regarding carbonated water, it primarily involves dissolving carbon dioxide in water.
The body naturally produces carbon dioxide through respiration and excretes it when exhaling, so the impact of carbonated water on blood pH is minimal.
Besides respiration, the kidneys also regulate blood acidity and alkalinity.
Therefore, it is advised not to expect significant effects from carbonated water.
As for the dietary supplements you mentioned, they are essentially foods, as they are not classified as drugs and cannot claim therapeutic effects; they can only be used for maintenance.
The safety of additional dietary supplements, which are processed extracts, is also a concern.
Furthermore, it is worth considering whether supplementation is necessary if these nutrients can be obtained from natural foods.
For example, collagen is a type of protein that will be broken down into amino acids in the gastrointestinal tract, and excessive intake can also burden the kidneys.
This information is provided by Dietitian Tsai Hsiu-Wen from Nantou Hospital, Department of Health.
Wishing you good health!

Reply Date: 2009/10/08

More Info

Sparkling water, also known as carbonated water, is generally considered to be acidic due to the presence of carbonic acid, which forms when carbon dioxide (CO2) is dissolved in water. The pH of sparkling water typically ranges from 3 to 4, making it more acidic than regular tap water, which has a neutral pH of around 7. However, it is important to note that the acidity of sparkling water is relatively mild compared to other acidic beverages, such as soda or fruit juices.

When consumed, sparkling water does not significantly alter the body's overall pH balance. The human body has a remarkable ability to maintain homeostasis, including the regulation of blood pH levels, which typically remain between 7.35 and 7.45. Therefore, while sparkling water is acidic in nature, it does not lead to a systemic increase in acidity in the body. The idea that consuming acidic foods or beverages can lead to an acidic body environment is a common myth; the body’s buffering systems, primarily involving the lungs and kidneys, effectively manage pH levels.

Regarding the popular trend of using sparkling water for weight loss, there is limited scientific evidence to support its effectiveness. Some proponents suggest that the carbonation can promote a feeling of fullness, potentially leading to reduced calorie intake. However, this effect may vary from person to person. Additionally, sparkling water can be a healthier alternative to sugary sodas and juices, as it is typically calorie-free and can help with hydration. Nonetheless, it is essential to be cautious about flavored sparkling waters, as they may contain added sugars or artificial sweeteners, which could negate any weight loss benefits.

As for the second part of your question regarding the consumption of dietary supplements such as collagen, spirulina (green algae), vitamin C, coix seed extract, and vitamin B, moderation is key. While these supplements can provide health benefits, excessive intake can lead to potential side effects or imbalances in nutrient levels. For example, high doses of vitamin C can cause gastrointestinal disturbances, while excessive collagen intake may lead to digestive issues. It’s also important to consider the source and quality of the supplements, as not all products are created equal.

In general, a balanced diet rich in whole foods—fruits, vegetables, whole grains, lean proteins, and healthy fats—should provide most individuals with the necessary nutrients without the need for excessive supplementation. If you are considering adding multiple supplements to your regimen, it is advisable to consult with a healthcare professional or a registered dietitian. They can help assess your individual nutritional needs and determine whether supplementation is necessary or if dietary adjustments would be more beneficial.

In summary, sparkling water is acidic but does not significantly affect the body's pH balance. While it may aid in hydration and potentially contribute to feelings of fullness, its role in weight loss is not well-established. Regarding dietary supplements, moderation is essential, and it is best to seek professional guidance to avoid potential adverse effects and ensure a balanced intake of nutrients.

Similar Q&A

Is Alkaline Ionized Water Safe? Debunking Myths and Health Risks

Hello, doctor. There are many products on the market labeled as "alkaline ionized water" that claim to adjust the body's pH balance. I would like to know if this is true. I previously saw news reports stating that excessive consumption could actually be harmful to ...

Dr. Hong Hongchang reply Internal Medicine
Hello, sir: Thank you for your inquiry. Here is my response to your question along with some recommendations: It is advisable to boil drinking water before consumption. Regarding hypertension and diabetes, since there is a family history, it is recommended to control weight and f...

Can Alkaline Ionized Water Help with High Uric Acid and Hepatitis B?

I have high uric acid levels. I've heard that drinking alkaline ionized water can help improve this condition. However, I also have hepatitis B and I'm not sure if it's safe for me to drink it.

Dr. Xie Yonghui reply Internal Medicine
You have a condition of hyperuricemia, which can lead to gout in severe cases. In addition to medication, treatment for gout should include dietary modifications (a low-purine diet) and adequate hydration. It is generally recommended to drink at least 2000cc of water daily to aid...

Healthy Tips for Beverage Lovers: How to Balance Your Diet

I am someone who really enjoys drinking beverages. Are there any remedies for people who love to drink, such as drinking more water or exercising to sweat more? Thank you.

Dr. Xie Peiru reply Nutrition
Hello, I am not sure which beverage you are referring to. Most canned drinks or bubble tea are processed, high in sugar, and contain a large amount of chemical additives, which can have long-term effects on the body, such as obesity, metabolic syndrome, and interference with the ...

Does Adding Sugar to Lemon Water Affect Its pH Balance?

Does adding sugar (acidic) to lemon water (alkaline) affect the acidity or alkalinity of the lemon? For example, what happens when freshly squeezed lemon juice is added to commercially available black tea?

Dr. Shi Guimei reply Nutrition
Hello! Sugar is considered a neutral food, so the pH level of lemon water with added sugar may differ slightly from that of unsweetened lemon water. However, our daily diet is mixed, making it impractical to meticulously analyze the impact of the pH levels of various foods on ove...