Milk Powder vs. Cow's Milk: Which is Better for Growth and Weight Management?

Is formula better than cow's milk?

I am currently a 16-year-old girl! I got my first period when I was 14.
I am currently 158 cm tall and weigh 49 kg.
I saw online that skim milk powder has 356 calories per 100g, while a cup of skim milk (245g) has 85 calories.
I want to ask if I still have a chance to grow taller, but I don't want to gain weight.
My minimum standard is to maintain my weight and try not to gain any.
Between the two options, which one should I choose? 01: Which one is more effective for growing taller? 02: Does the temperature (cold vs.
hot) make a difference? 03: Do I still have a chance to grow taller?

Qin, 10~19 year old female. Ask Date: 2007/01/11

Dr. Liu Qiaoyun reply Nutrition

Regarding your question about whether there is still a chance to grow taller, there is likely still an opportunity.
However, it is important to make the most of this time.
In addition to nutrition, getting enough sleep and exercising regularly are also crucial! This can help with both growth and weight loss.
In terms of nutrition, protein and calcium are essential, but a balanced diet is also necessary.
Don't be afraid of gaining weight and eat too little or rely mainly on snacks and drinks.
It's important to have regular meals.
The nutritional value of cold and hot milk is essentially the same.
Skim milk has lower calories, so you can prioritize that.
The calorie content should be based on the label, and it should be roughly what you calculate.
With the new year comes new hopes; I wish you success in growing taller!

Reply Date: 2007/01/11

More Info

When it comes to choosing between milk powder and cow's milk for growth and weight management, there are several factors to consider, especially for a 16-year-old girl like yourself who is concerned about maintaining a healthy weight while still supporting growth.

Nutritional Content
Both milk powder and cow's milk are rich sources of essential nutrients, particularly calcium and protein, which are crucial for bone health and growth. Cow's milk typically contains about 8 grams of protein and 300 mg of calcium per cup (approximately 245 grams), while milk powder can be more concentrated, providing higher levels of these nutrients per serving. For instance, non-fat dry milk powder contains around 35 grams of protein and 1,200 mg of calcium per 100 grams.

Growth Potential
Regarding your growth potential, it is important to note that growth plates in bones typically close after puberty, which can limit further height increase. However, at 16 years old, you may still have some growth potential left, especially if you have not yet reached your full adult height. Adequate nutrition, including sufficient protein and calcium intake, is vital during this period. Therefore, both milk powder and cow's milk can support your growth if consumed as part of a balanced diet.

Weight Management
If your goal is to maintain your weight without gaining excess fat, choosing low-fat or non-fat options is advisable. Non-fat milk powder has a lower calorie content compared to whole milk, making it a better choice if you're concerned about caloric intake. For example, as you mentioned, non-fat dry milk powder has about 356 calories per 100 grams, while a cup of non-fat cow's milk has approximately 85 calories. This means you can consume a larger volume of milk powder while still managing your calorie intake effectively.

Temperature Considerations
As for the temperature of the milk, whether you drink it cold or hot does not significantly affect its nutritional value. The nutrients remain intact regardless of temperature; however, some people may find that warm milk is easier to digest, while others prefer cold milk. This choice is largely based on personal preference and does not impact the nutritional benefits.

Conclusion
In summary, both milk powder and cow's milk can be beneficial for your growth and weight management goals. If you are looking to maximize your nutrient intake while keeping calories in check, non-fat milk powder may be the better option. However, incorporating both into your diet can provide variety and ensure you receive a broad spectrum of nutrients.
Additionally, remember that maintaining a balanced diet with a variety of foods, regular physical activity, and adequate sleep are all essential components of healthy growth and weight management. If you have specific dietary concerns or health issues, consulting with a healthcare professional or a registered dietitian can provide personalized guidance tailored to your needs.

Similar Q&A

Choosing Between Milk and Soy Milk: Which is More Nutritious?

Hello, Nutritionist: I am relatively thin and recently want to drink milk to supplement my nutrition. Could you please advise whether powdered milk or fresh milk available in the market is more suitable and nutritious? Also, I heard from a teacher before that "milk is not ea...

Dr. Cai Xiuwen reply Nutrition
Hello! Milk is a highly nutritious food that not only contains high-quality protein but is also rich in B vitamins and calcium. Regarding your questions: 1. Which is more suitable and nutritious, powdered milk or fresh milk available in the market? Answer: Essentially, both po...

Fresh Milk vs. Formula: Which is Better for Your Toddler's Nutrition?

Hello, Nutritionist: My daughter is currently 1 year and 9 months old. Since she was 1 year and 7 months, I have replaced all her formula milk with regular whole milk. In the morning, she drinks about 180cc of goat milk from Chianan, about 150cc of full-fat cow's milk from G...

Dr. Shi Guimei reply Nutrition
Hello! For children over one year old, dairy sources can include either fresh milk or formula milk. If a child has external moles, it is advisable to first check if they are consuming enough vegetables and fruits during their meals, as well as whether they are not drinking enough...

Milk vs. Calcium Supplements: Which is Better for Nutritional Needs?

Which is easier to supplement insufficient nutrients, drinking milk or taking calcium tablets? Some recommend calcium supplements like [Gordon Calcium] and [Hongxianglan]. Are these suitable? Could these products be harmful? Do they really promote height growth? What nutrients ar...

Dr. Xie Peiru reply Nutrition
Hello: From a nutritionist's perspective, it is recommended to use fresh foods to supplement calcium deficiency. The dietary principles for calcium supplementation are as follows: 1. Choose high-calcium foods to ensure adequate calcium intake: Calcium sources can be divide...

Milk and Health Foods: Debunking Myths and Clarifying Nutrition for Seniors

In the media, we often hear various experts expressing different opinions about milk, leading to confusion and making it difficult for people to understand. There is a book that interviews renowned doctors from major hospitals about their daily health habits, and none of them enc...

Dr. Cai Xiuwen reply Nutrition
Hello Kiki, this is a very good question. Much of the scientific and medical knowledge comes from years of experience and research experiments. In the past, many studies have shown that various arguments have both pros and cons, and after further research, a consensus has been re...