Is it necessary to apply strong force to bend the knee during rehabilitation treatment when it cannot flex normally?
In early July of this year, I suffered a comminuted closed fracture of the tibia below the knee due to a car accident.
I began rehabilitation and had my cast removed in mid-August.
The fracture has generally healed well, but I am unable to bend my knee normally (currently able to bend to about 85 degrees) and cannot fully extend it while walking.
I am still undergoing rehabilitation therapy.
I would like to ask the doctor: (1) Is it necessary to forcefully bend the knee during rehabilitation when it cannot bend normally, as this often leads to inflammation and swelling? (2) Does progress tend to stall when bending the knee to 85 to 90 degrees? (3) What exercises can effectively help improve bending and straightening? (4) Would it be advisable to perform surgery to remove adhesions in the knee and forcibly bend it to 120 degrees under anesthesia at this time? Thank you, doctor.
I greatly appreciate your help.
Wishing you all the best and may everything go smoothly.
Mr. Chen, 40~49 year old female. Ask Date: 2009/12/14
Dr. Lai Yanting reply Rehabilitation
Hello Mr.
Chen: Thank you for your questions.
(1) During rehabilitation, is it necessary to forcefully bend the knee if it cannot flex normally? This often leads to inflammation and swelling.
If the fracture has healed well, knee flexion can be improved through rehabilitation techniques such as "mobilization" and "stretching exercises." (2) Is progress likely to stall when bending the knee to 85 to 90 degrees? It depends on whether the fracture has affected the joint surface.
Damage to the joint surface can make progress more difficult.
(3) What exercises can effectively help improve flexion and extension? Please have your therapist guide you in home rehabilitation.
The choice of exercises should be based on X-rays and clinical findings to provide appropriate recommendations.
(4) Is it advisable to perform surgery to remove adhesions in the knee and forcibly bend it to 120 degrees under anesthesia at this time? If rehabilitation for knee flexion and extension angles has consistently failed to progress, it may indeed be necessary to consider anesthesia for forced flexion and removal of adhesions.
I recommend discussing this with your attending physician.
Finally, I wish you health and happiness!
Reply Date: 2009/12/14
More Info
Rehabilitation after a knee injury, especially following a severe fracture like a comminuted tibial fracture, can be a challenging process. Your concerns about knee flexibility and the rehabilitation process are valid, and it's important to address them carefully to ensure optimal recovery.
1. Is Forceful Bending Necessary?
Forceful bending of the knee during rehabilitation can sometimes be necessary to regain range of motion, but it should be approached with caution. If you are experiencing inflammation and swelling as a result of aggressive bending, it may indicate that your knee is not ready for such intensity. Instead of forceful bending, a more gradual approach is often recommended. Gentle stretching and mobilization techniques can help improve flexibility without causing excessive pain or inflammation. It's crucial to communicate with your physical therapist about your pain levels and any swelling you experience, as they can adjust your rehabilitation program accordingly.
2. Progress Stalling at 85-90 Degrees
Reaching a flexion of 85-90 degrees is a significant milestone, but it is common for progress to stall at this stage. This plateau can occur due to various factors, including muscle tightness, joint stiffness, or even psychological barriers related to pain and fear of movement. Continuing with a consistent rehabilitation program that includes both passive and active range of motion exercises is essential. Your therapist may also incorporate modalities such as heat or ultrasound therapy to help reduce stiffness and promote healing.
3. Effective Exercises for Improvement
To improve knee flexion and extension, consider incorporating the following exercises into your rehabilitation program, always under the guidance of your therapist:
- Heel Slides: While lying on your back, slide your heel towards your buttocks, bending your knee as much as possible, then slide it back out. This can help improve flexion gradually.
- Quadriceps Sets: Tighten your thigh muscle while keeping your leg straight. Hold for a few seconds and release. This helps strengthen the quadriceps, which is crucial for knee stability.
- Straight Leg Raises: While lying down, keep one leg straight and lift the other leg to the height of the straight leg. This helps strengthen the muscles around the knee without putting too much strain on the joint.
- Wall Slides: Stand with your back against a wall and slide down into a squat position, then return to standing. This can help improve both flexion and strength.
4. Surgical Intervention for Adhesions
If conservative rehabilitation does not yield the desired results, surgical intervention may be considered. Procedures like arthroscopic surgery to remove adhesions or scar tissue can help restore range of motion. However, this decision should be made carefully, considering the potential risks and benefits. The idea of forcing the knee to bend to 120 degrees under anesthesia, known as manipulation under anesthesia (MUA), can be effective in some cases, but it carries risks such as further injury or complications. It's essential to have a thorough discussion with your orthopedic surgeon about your specific situation, the potential outcomes, and whether this approach is appropriate for you.
In conclusion, rehabilitation after a knee injury requires patience and a tailored approach. It's crucial to work closely with your healthcare team, including your orthopedic surgeon and physical therapist, to develop a rehabilitation plan that suits your needs and promotes healing. Always listen to your body and report any significant pain or swelling to your therapist, as they can adjust your program to ensure you are progressing safely. Wishing you a smooth recovery and improved knee function!
Similar Q&A
Recovering from Patellar Fracture: Addressing Limited Knee Flexion
I would like to ask the doctor: I had a car accident on May 8th and fractured my patella into two pieces. After surgery, I was instructed to wear a knee brace that does not allow bending. The doctor said on June 12th that I could stop wearing it while sleeping, but I still cannot...
Dr. Li Yongheng reply Orthopedics
1. Currently, there is joint stiffness. 2. Engage in active rehabilitation or consult a surgeon for joint manipulation. 3. You may visit an external rehabilitation clinic. 4. Currently, you may not need to use crutches or a knee brace (please consult your surgeon first). ...[Read More] Recovering from Patellar Fracture: Addressing Limited Knee Flexion
Rehabilitation After ACL Reconstruction: Addressing Knee Flexibility Issues
Hello Doctor, it has been nearly six months since my surgery, but I still cannot bend my knee to the extent of bringing my thigh to my calf (approximately 170 degrees). Could there be any issues with this? Is it dangerous if I try to forcefully bend it all the way? I still cannot...
Dr. Chen Yongxue reply Orthopedics
Hello, 1. After anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction, general usage is usually fine; however, there may be limitations when bending to extreme angles. It is advisable to discuss this with your attending physician. 2. The strength needed for climbing stairs can be ac...[Read More] Rehabilitation After ACL Reconstruction: Addressing Knee Flexibility Issues
Understanding Left Knee Stiffness: Concerns and Treatment Options
Hello, doctor. I was in a car accident last October, and my left knee was injured. I have been undergoing rehabilitation since then (diagnosed with a sprain and hematoma). I can bend and squat at a good angle, but I still cannot fully straighten it; I'm still a bit short. Is...
Dr. Li Wenlin reply Orthopedics
Hello: In response to your question, whether or not to undergo joint mobilization should be based on the advice of your attending physician, as they are most familiar with your detailed medical history. If you are not satisfied with your current physician, you may also consider s...[Read More] Understanding Left Knee Stiffness: Concerns and Treatment Options
Effective Home Rehabilitation After Knee Ligament Surgery
Hello, I had a car accident in December, and it seems that I have a ligament tear in my knee. I underwent surgery on December 4th, where a screw was inserted, and my leg was immobilized in a cast. During my follow-up appointment on January 1st, the cast was removed, but I am unab...
Dr. Shi Guozheng reply Orthopedics
You should practice both extension and flexion, as well as lifting the leg to increase thigh strength. You can start by applying a warm compress to the knee joint for about ten minutes before beginning the flexion exercises. Bend your knee as much as you can tolerate, then slowly...[Read More] Effective Home Rehabilitation After Knee Ligament Surgery
Related FAQ
(Rehabilitation)
Knock Knees(Rehabilitation)
Muscle Strain(Rehabilitation)
O-Shaped Legs(Rehabilitation)
Neck Stiffness(Rehabilitation)
Buttocks(Rehabilitation)
Leg Soreness(Rehabilitation)
Artificial Ligament(Rehabilitation)
Coccyx Pain(Rehabilitation)
Dislocation(Rehabilitation)