Do Oats and Milk Powder Cancel Out Calcium and Iron Absorption? - Nutrition

Share to:

Nutritional Counseling


Hello, nutritionist: Since I have been consuming oatmeal (which can be prepared with hot water) and a blended milk powder (high in iron and calcium) together for breakfast, will this combination negate the calcium and iron content? If so, how should I consume them?

Xiao Zhen, 30~39 year old female. Ask Date: 2016/06/04

Dr. Xie Huimin reply Nutrition


Dear Xiao Zhen, mineral absorption is influenced by multiple factors.
Even if a single factor has an impact, it is generally not significant.
I believe that this approach is practical.

Reply Date: 2016/06/04

More Info


When it comes to the combination of oats and milk powder, particularly in the context of calcium and iron absorption, it's important to understand the nutritional dynamics at play. Oats are a nutritious whole grain, rich in fiber, vitamins, and minerals, while milk powder is a concentrated source of protein, calcium, and other essential nutrients. The concern about whether these two foods can "cancel out" each other's nutrient absorption is a common one, especially among those who are health-conscious or have specific dietary needs.

Firstly, it's essential to recognize that the absorption of minerals like calcium and iron can be influenced by various dietary factors. For instance, certain compounds found in foods, such as phytates (found in whole grains like oats) and oxalates (found in some leafy greens and nuts), can bind to minerals and inhibit their absorption. However, the impact of these compounds is often overstated. While they can reduce the bioavailability of minerals, the extent to which they do so depends on several factors, including the overall composition of the diet, the presence of other nutrients, and individual digestive health.

In the case of oats and milk powder, the combination can actually be quite beneficial. Oats provide a good source of fiber, which can aid in digestion and promote a feeling of fullness, while milk powder contributes protein and calcium. The presence of calcium in milk can help mitigate the effects of phytates in oats, as calcium can compete with phytates for binding sites, potentially enhancing the overall absorption of both minerals.

Moreover, the idea that consuming oats and milk powder together will completely negate the absorption of calcium and iron is a simplification. While it's true that excessive intake of phytates can reduce mineral absorption, the amounts typically consumed in a balanced diet are unlikely to lead to significant deficiencies. For most individuals, enjoying oats with milk powder as part of a varied diet should not pose a problem regarding nutrient absorption.

If you are particularly concerned about maximizing nutrient absorption, here are a few tips:
1. Variety is Key: Ensure that your diet includes a wide range of foods. This variety can help balance out any potential inhibitory effects of certain foods on mineral absorption.

2. Timing Matters: If you are worried about iron absorption specifically, consider consuming iron-rich foods separately from high-phytate foods. For example, if you have oats for breakfast, you might want to have a source of iron (like lean meat or legumes) at a different meal.

3. Cooking Techniques: Cooking oats can reduce their phytate content, making the minerals more bioavailable. Soaking oats overnight or cooking them can be beneficial.

4. Consider Vitamin C: Consuming vitamin C-rich foods (like fruits) alongside iron sources can enhance iron absorption. This is particularly important for non-heme iron sources (like those found in plant foods).

5. Monitor Your Intake: If you have specific dietary restrictions or health conditions (like anemia), it may be worth consulting with a healthcare professional or a registered dietitian. They can provide personalized advice based on your individual health needs.

In conclusion, while there are some interactions between the nutrients in oats and milk powder, the overall impact on calcium and iron absorption is likely minimal for most people. Enjoying these foods together as part of a balanced diet can provide numerous health benefits without significant concerns about nutrient cancellation.

Similar Q&A

Are Breakfast Cereals with Milk Really Healthy? Nutritional Insights Explained

Are those cereal breakfasts sold outside, like Kellogg's, really good for you? Many people say that eating cereals with milk for breakfast can reduce calcium absorption. There's also a saying that iron plus calcium equals zero, meaning that consuming them together is es...


Dr. Shi Guimei reply Nutrition
Hello! If a certain type of breakfast claims to be high in iron, it's important to note that calcium and iron have antagonistic effects on absorption, which can affect each other's absorption rates. However, this does not mean that consuming high-iron or high-calcium fo...

[Read More] Are Breakfast Cereals with Milk Really Healthy? Nutritional Insights Explained


Managing Anemia and Osteoporosis: Nutritional Tips for Vegetarians

If you have anemia and osteoporosis, how can you supplement iron and calcium in your daily diet (I am vegetarian)? Also, I've heard that commercially available high-iron and high-calcium milk powders are not very effective; is that true? Please let me know, thank you!


Dr. Shi Guimei reply Nutrition
Hello Tsuyoshi, First, to address your second question, iron and calcium have antagonistic effects on absorption in the human body. This means that consuming high-iron and high-calcium foods simultaneously may have adverse effects. Therefore, it is generally recommended to consu...

[Read More] Managing Anemia and Osteoporosis: Nutritional Tips for Vegetarians


Chocolate vs. Milk: How Chocolate Affects Calcium Absorption

It is well known that chocolate can reduce calcium absorption. However, when consuming certain breakfast cereals (such as chocolate-flavored cereals or chocolate milk), will calcium still be absorbed? Additionally, what is the extent of this reduction? Is it a 1:1 ratio? For exam...


Dr. Cai Xiuwen reply Nutrition
Hello! Chocolate contains a higher amount of oxalic acid, which binds with calcium to form calcium oxalate, thereby "reducing" calcium absorption. This is a matter of absorption levels, and it does not mean that calcium cannot be absorbed at all. The extent to which cho...

[Read More] Chocolate vs. Milk: How Chocolate Affects Calcium Absorption


Calcium and Iron Intake: Myths and Facts About Supplementation

After reading articles published by other users, I learned that the simultaneous intake of calcium and iron is not effective. However, there are commercially available milk powders that contain both "high iron and high calcium." Isn't that misleading?


Dr. Hu Yuqing reply Nutrition
Hello NONO: "High Iron, High Calcium" is a nutritional claim. Please refer to the Food Information Network at food.doh.gov.tw under Nutrition and You > Nutritional Labeling > Nutritional Claim Announcements http://www.doh.gov.tw/ufile/Doc/Regulations_on_Nutritiona...

[Read More] Calcium and Iron Intake: Myths and Facts About Supplementation


Related FAQ

Calcium Absorption

(Nutrition)

Calcium Absorption

(Orthopedics)

Anemia

(Nutrition)

Fiber

(Nutrition)

Fracture

(Nutrition)

Dietary Adjustment

(Nutrition)

Lutein

(Nutrition)

Gout Diet

(Nutrition)

Elderly

(Nutrition)

Dietary Supplements

(Obstetrics and Gynecology)