Calcium supplementation for osteoarthritis?
Hello, Nutritionist: My mother is 56 years old and has mild diabetes and hypertension, which are well controlled.
In April of this year, she visited a doctor for osteoarthritis and was prescribed anti-inflammatory pain medication, stomach medication, and calcium supplements.
Initially, her pain improved significantly, and now she only needs to take calcium supplements.
However, during the period of taking calcium supplements, she gained a lot of weight, which made her uncomfortable (I think it feels like edema).
She has not taken them for about three weeks now, but her dietary intake of calcium is limited, and she cannot consume too much.
This is really troubling.
Please provide guidance.
Thank you! My mother is approximately 155 cm tall and weighs about 70 kg.
Xiao Xin, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2003/10/05
Dr. Liu Qiaoyun reply Nutrition
Hello: You are truly a caring and filial child.
The concern you mentioned about calcium supplements causing weight gain is quite paradoxical! I consulted with a hospital pharmacist, and there are no such side effects reported! Your aunt's height is 155 cm, and her ideal weight should be around 48-59 kg.
Being overweight can also affect joint health and the management of diabetes and hypertension.
It might be beneficial for your aunt to consult with a rehabilitation therapist and a nutritionist at her hospital to discuss how to incorporate exercise and dietary changes for effective weight management.
(I suspect that reduced activity due to arthritis might also contribute to weight gain.) Regarding the issue of calcium supplements, it would be advisable to consult an orthopedic physician to check if there are any concerns with the calcium supplements and to determine whether the weight gain is due to fat or water retention.
This way, she can feel more at ease taking calcium supplements and identify the root cause of the weight gain! Wishing you health and happiness.
Best, Chiao-Yun 10/6.
Reply Date: 2003/10/05
More Info
Calcium supplementation is a common recommendation for individuals with osteoarthritis, particularly for those who may be at risk of osteoporosis due to age or other health conditions. In your mother's case, her existing health issues, including mild diabetes and hypertension, along with her osteoarthritis, necessitate a careful approach to calcium supplementation and overall health management.
First, it's important to understand that calcium is essential for bone health, and adequate intake can help prevent further deterioration of bone density, especially in postmenopausal women who are at a higher risk for osteoporosis. However, the concern about weight gain or water retention associated with calcium supplements is not widely supported by scientific evidence. Calcium itself does not typically cause weight gain; rather, it is possible that other factors, such as dietary changes or decreased physical activity due to joint pain, may contribute to weight fluctuations.
Given your mother's height of 155 cm and weight of 70 kg, her Body Mass Index (BMI) is approximately 29, which classifies her as overweight. This excess weight can exacerbate joint pain and may complicate the management of her osteoarthritis, diabetes, and hypertension. Therefore, weight management should be a priority in her overall health plan.
Here are some recommendations for managing calcium intake and overall health:
1. Dietary Sources of Calcium: Encourage your mother to consume calcium-rich foods that are low in calories and fat. Good sources include low-fat dairy products (like yogurt and cheese), leafy green vegetables (such as kale and broccoli), and fortified foods (like certain cereals and plant-based milk). Since she has lactose intolerance, lactose-free dairy options can be beneficial.
2. Calcium Supplementation: If dietary intake is insufficient, calcium supplements can be beneficial. It's essential to choose a supplement that is well-absorbed, such as calcium citrate or calcium carbonate. The recommended daily intake of calcium for women aged 51 and older is about 1,200 mg. If she is taking supplements, she should ensure that her total calcium intake (from food and supplements) does not exceed this amount.
3. Vitamin D: Vitamin D is crucial for calcium absorption. If your mother is not getting adequate sun exposure (which can be challenging in winter months or due to lifestyle), consider discussing vitamin D supplementation with her healthcare provider.
4. Weight Management: To address weight concerns, a balanced diet combined with regular physical activity is essential. Low-impact exercises, such as swimming, cycling, or walking, can help manage weight without putting excessive strain on her joints. A physical therapist or a certified trainer with experience in working with individuals with osteoarthritis can provide tailored exercise recommendations.
5. Monitoring and Adjustments: Regular follow-ups with her healthcare provider are important to monitor her weight, joint health, and overall well-being. If she experiences any side effects from supplements or medications, these should be discussed with her doctor to explore alternatives.
6. Hydration: Sometimes, feelings of bloating or water retention can be alleviated by ensuring adequate hydration. Encourage her to drink plenty of water throughout the day.
In conclusion, while calcium supplementation is important for bone health, it should be part of a comprehensive approach that includes dietary management, physical activity, and regular medical oversight. By focusing on a balanced diet, appropriate supplementation, and weight management strategies, your mother can improve her overall health and potentially alleviate some of the discomfort associated with her osteoarthritis.
Similar Q&A
Managing Osteoarthritis: Nutrition Tips and Supplement Guidance
Hello! Last month, I sought medical attention due to pain in my left hand. After X-rays and MRI scans, the doctor diagnosed me with degenerative arthritis. Since multiple joints have bone spurs, surgery is not an option. Therefore, the physician recommended physical therapy and a...
Dr. Shi Guimei reply Nutrition
Dear Amy, Hello! Based on your condition, you should increase your intake of calcium-rich foods. It is recommended to drink 1.5 to 2 cups of low-fat or non-fat milk daily (each cup being 240cc). Other good sources of calcium include legumes such as soybeans and black beans, as w...[Read More] Managing Osteoarthritis: Nutrition Tips and Supplement Guidance
Understanding Osteoporosis: Calcium and Vitamin D Intake for Joint Health
Hello, doctor. I underwent a bone density test this year and found that I have osteopenia in the hip joint with a score of -2.1. The doctor recommended that I take calcium supplements. I have some questions regarding a calcium supplement I purchased, which contains 1536 mg of cal...
Dr. Li Yongheng reply Orthopedics
Hello, based on your age, your intake of calcium and vitamin D should be sufficient. Chewing calcium tablets before swallowing can enhance absorption. Additionally, spending 5 to 10 minutes in the sun daily is adequate, so there is no need to purchase additional vitamin D supplem...[Read More] Understanding Osteoporosis: Calcium and Vitamin D Intake for Joint Health
Managing Osteoarthritis: Is Move Free the Right Supplement for You?
I have osteoarthritis in my knees, which causes pain when walking. After being diagnosed by an orthopedic doctor, I was advised to take "Wei Gu Li." Since this health supplement is not covered by health insurance, I purchased Move Free, which is manufactured in the Unit...
Dr. Yang Zhengfan reply Orthopedics
Dear Ms. Chang, you have not yet met the criteria for health insurance coverage for calcium supplements. The recommended dosage for general calcium supplements is three times a day, one tablet each time, or twice a day, two tablets each time. There are no specific safety concerns...[Read More] Managing Osteoarthritis: Is Move Free the Right Supplement for You?
Evaluating Calcium Supplements: Benefits and Potential Risks
Hello Doctor, could you please help me review this calcium supplement? 1. Will it be effective? 2. Does it contain any ingredients that are not beneficial for the body (components that a physician would not recommend)? Thank you. Ingredients: - Natural glucosamine 300 mg - Chon...
Dr. Cai Jueren reply Family Medicine
Hello: These ingredients are all natural food components. The only thing to be aware of is to not consume the product if you have an allergy to shellfish. This means that if you have previously had an allergy to shellfish, you may experience an allergic reaction. As for whether s...[Read More] Evaluating Calcium Supplements: Benefits and Potential Risks
Related FAQ
(Nutrition)
Dietary Supplements(Orthopedics)
Fracture(Nutrition)
Gout Diet(Nutrition)
Health Supplements(Nutrition)
Gastrointestinal(Nutrition)
Leg Obesity(Nutrition)
Elderly(Nutrition)
Knee Cartilage(Orthopedics)
Degenerative Arthritis(Orthopedics)