Are There Vegan Calcium Supplements? A Guide for Plant-Based Nutrition

Are there vegetarian calcium supplements?

Hello, nutritionist: Due to my father's vegetarian diet, I would like to supplement him with calcium tablets.
However, I have heard that the vitamin D3 in calcium tablets is of animal origin, while D2 is plant-based.
Is it sufficient to just pay attention to this point to ensure safe consumption? Additionally, if the calcium tablets are derived purely from plant sources (I heard that Wei Wang Jia Mei Calcium is one of them), will the oxalate content be very high? Could this lead to an increased risk of kidney stones? Furthermore, some calcium tablets, like Ting Li Calcium, contain additional metal components such as manganese and copper.
Do these really provide any benefits? I would greatly appreciate your response.
Thank you!

A-Nuo, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2005/05/19

Dr. Cai Xiuwen reply Nutrition

Hello! Vitamin D helps with the absorption and utilization of calcium, which is why many commercially available calcium supplements are fortified with vitamin D.
There are two types of vitamin D: one is vitamin D3, found in animal liver oil, and the other is vitamin D2, produced from the ultraviolet irradiation of ergosterol.
When the skin is exposed to sunlight, it converts to the vitamin D that the body needs.
Unless one deliberately avoids sunlight or only goes out at night, deficiency is unlikely.
Whether plant-based calcium supplements contain higher levels of oxalates depends on the specific product ingredients, as the method of production can also have an impact.
The formation of calcium oxalate stones has many causes, including individual constitution, water intake, and oxalate consumption; not all foods containing oxalates will necessarily lead to stone formation.
Manganese, copper, and other minerals are related to the regulation of physiological functions and do not have a significant relationship with the physiological functions of calcium.
Wishing you good health.
This information is provided by Dietitian Tsai Hsiu-Wen from Nantou Hospital, Department of Health, Executive Yuan.

Reply Date: 2005/05/19

More Info

When considering calcium supplements for a vegan diet, it's essential to understand the different forms of calcium and the additional nutrients that may be included in these supplements. Calcium is crucial for bone health, and while many people obtain sufficient calcium from dairy products, vegans must find alternative sources to meet their nutritional needs.

First, regarding vitamin D, which is often added to calcium supplements to enhance calcium absorption: Vitamin D3 (cholecalciferol) is typically derived from animal sources, such as fish liver oil or lanolin (a substance derived from sheep's wool). On the other hand, vitamin D2 (ergocalciferol) is plant-based and is produced from yeast or fungi exposed to ultraviolet light. For vegans, it is advisable to choose calcium supplements that contain vitamin D2 to ensure they align with their dietary preferences.

Next, you mentioned concerns about oxalate content in plant-based calcium supplements. Oxalates are naturally occurring compounds found in various plants, and they can bind to calcium, potentially reducing its absorption and increasing the risk of kidney stone formation in susceptible individuals. Foods high in oxalates include spinach, rhubarb, and beets. However, the oxalate content in calcium supplements can vary based on the source of the calcium. For instance, calcium derived from algae or certain plant sources may have different oxalate levels compared to those derived from other sources. It is crucial to read the labels and possibly consult with a healthcare professional or a registered dietitian to choose a supplement that minimizes oxalate content.

Regarding the concern about kidney stones, it is essential to note that not everyone who consumes high-oxalate foods will develop kidney stones. Factors such as hydration, overall diet, and individual predisposition play significant roles. Adequate hydration can help dilute urine and reduce the risk of stone formation. If your father has a history of kidney stones, it would be wise to consult with a healthcare provider before starting any new supplement regimen.

As for the inclusion of trace minerals such as manganese and copper in calcium supplements, these minerals can play supportive roles in various physiological functions. Manganese is involved in bone formation and metabolism, while copper is essential for iron metabolism and the formation of connective tissue. However, the amounts present in supplements should be within recommended dietary allowances, as excessive intake of trace minerals can lead to toxicity. Therefore, it is advisable to choose supplements that provide these minerals in appropriate amounts.

In summary, when selecting a vegan calcium supplement for your father, consider the following:
1. Vitamin D Source: Look for supplements that contain vitamin D2 instead of D3.

2. Oxalate Content: Research the source of calcium and its oxalate content. Consult with a healthcare professional if there are concerns about kidney stones.

3. Trace Minerals: Ensure that any additional minerals included in the supplement are within safe limits and beneficial for overall health.

Lastly, it is always beneficial to encourage a diet rich in calcium from whole food sources. Leafy greens, fortified plant milks, tofu, almonds, and certain legumes can provide substantial amounts of calcium. A balanced diet, combined with the right supplements, can help ensure that your father meets his nutritional needs while adhering to a vegan lifestyle.

Similar Q&A

Calcium Sources for Vegetarians and Those with Stomach Issues

1. How can vegetarians supplement calcium (age 65)? 2. For someone who frequently experiences stomach discomfort and takes medication (age 44), can they supplement through food or medication?

Dr. Tang Weili reply Nutrition
If you are following a strict vegan diet, it is essential to maintain a balanced and diverse diet every day. Those who consume eggs and dairy (lacto-ovo vegetarians) are less likely to experience deficiencies in calcium and vitamin B. Otherwise, it is crucial to include legumes (...

Evaluating Calcium Supplements: Benefits and Potential Risks

Hello Doctor, could you please help me review this calcium supplement? 1. Will it be effective? 2. Does it contain any ingredients that are not beneficial for the body (components that a physician would not recommend)? Thank you. Ingredients: - Natural glucosamine 300 mg - Chon...

Dr. Cai Jueren reply Family Medicine
Hello: These ingredients are all natural food components. The only thing to be aware of is to not consume the product if you have an allergy to shellfish. This means that if you have previously had an allergy to shellfish, you may experience an allergic reaction. As for whether s...

Managing Anemia and Osteoporosis: Nutritional Tips for Vegetarians

If you have anemia and osteoporosis, how can you supplement iron and calcium in your daily diet (I am vegetarian)? Also, I've heard that commercially available high-iron and high-calcium milk powders are not very effective; is that true? Please let me know, thank you!

Dr. Shi Guimei reply Nutrition
Hello Tsuyoshi, First, to address your second question, iron and calcium have antagonistic effects on absorption in the human body. This means that consuming high-iron and high-calcium foods simultaneously may have adverse effects. Therefore, it is generally recommended to consu...

Can a Vegan Diet Lead to Protein and Vitamin B12 Deficiencies?

I started eating vegetarian about six months ago, and I am now fully vegan. Recently, I heard that a vegan diet can lead to deficiencies in certain proteins and vitamin B12, which are primarily found in animal products. Could you please tell me what nutrients can be obtained from...

Dr. Hu Yuqing reply Nutrition
Nutritionist Hu Yu-Ching advises that vegans should supplement with Vitamin B12 and pay attention to their intake of Vitamins D, A, calcium, and iron. Dairy and eggs can provide Vitamin B12, which helps to compensate for the deficiency that may arise from a plant-based diet. Ther...